Aug 19, 2024
Pro-Palestinian Protests Remind DNC Of PAINFUL Reality
A large group of pro-Palestinian protestors surrounding the DNC are a stark reminder of the Democratic party's rift on Israel’s war in Gaza.
- 18 minutes
Over the course of the week.
There are at least
six major protests planned.
The demonstrations kicked off on Sunday,
on the eve of the convention, with
a march for Bodies Outside Unjust Laws,
which was organized by a coalition
of several different activist groups
[00:00:16]
to demand action
on reproductive rights, LGBTQ rights
and on the an end to the War on Gaza.
Free Palestine. Palestine.
Free. Free Palestine.
Now there's clearly increased excitement
toward Kamala Harris now that Joe Biden
[00:00:34]
has dropped out of the race
and Harris is the Democratic nominee.
However, not every Democratic voter
is fully on board
with the Harris Wallace ticket,
and pro-Palestinian demonstrators
have decided to move ahead
with the demonstrations surrounding
the Democratic National Convention.
[00:00:51]
Now, just a little bit about the protests.
Large scale protests are planned
at the Israeli consulate
in downtown Chicago and in the streets
and parks near the convention
on Tuesday, Wednesday and Thursday.
There are some protests taking place today
as well, but there is, you know,
[00:01:08]
an entire like schedule of protests
and demonstrations that will take place
throughout the entirety
of the Democratic National Convention.
Now, what is the Harris camp doing
to reach out to these demonstrators?
Because keep in mind, like the strategy,
and I think it's a smart strategy
[00:01:26]
by Harris, is to respond to some of the
negativity in the Trump campaign with joy,
with positivity, with a positive message.
But it's kind of difficult to do that
when Biden and Harris are being protested
right now by pro-Palestinian protesters.
[00:01:41]
So she has tried to reach out to them.
On Thursday, for instance,
Julie Chavez Rodriguez, who's Harris's
campaign manager, flew to Detroit
to meet privately with Abbas Allawi,
who's a Michigan delegate
to the convention representing
[00:01:57]
uncommitted primary voters.
She also met with Arab,
American and Jewish leaders.
Then you also have senior officials from
the DNC holding meetings on Thursday with
other uncommitted delegates in Chicago,
and they're also planning to hold
daytime panel discussions during
the convention with Palestinian Americans,
including uncommitted delegates
[00:02:15]
and with Jewish Americans.
But there is a lot of disagreement
about this
when it comes to some Jewish Democrats.
In fact, they want Harris and Tim Walz,
her running mate, to essentially
show voters that they will not concede
to the demands of these demonstrators,
[00:02:35]
that they will not be cowed
by the left flank of the Democratic Party.
In fact, they were pretty irritated
by Harris reaching out to the organizers
of these demonstrations.
So they're the founders of the protest
group, the Uncommitted National Movement.
[00:02:53]
And so they had suggested
that after meeting with Harris
or representatives for Harris,
that she was open to an arms embargo.
That is what they're demanding, right?
That the U.S.
Government stop sending military aid
to Israel as they are committing
[00:03:08]
these atrocities in the Gaza Strip,
and also, by the way, in the West Bank.
Let's not forget about that.
But the vice president's National Security
advisor, Phil Gordon, rushed in to say,
no, no, she's not open to an arms embargo.
And by the way, Phil Gordon,
I think, is telling the truth.
[00:03:24]
I think that's absolutely right.
I don't think she's open
to an arms embargo.
Now, Palestinian rights organizations say
that the request of uncommitted delegates
for prime time speaking spots
at the DNC were just rejected.
- Rebuffed, of course.
- Hey, don't scroll away.
[00:03:40]
Come back, come back.
Because before the video continues,
we just want to urge you
to lend your support to tight U power.
Our honest reporting.
You do it at tyt.com/team
and we love you for it.
I want to get into
what the polling indicates
because unfortunately in this like really,
really breaks my heart and pains me.
[00:04:00]
But based on what the polls say,
Kamala Harris seems to be able to do this
without much political ramifications.
I think those.
Polls are totally skewed,
and I'll tell you why in a second, okay?
But but they're not useless.
They do show some things,
but not exactly how they're framed.
[00:04:17]
So first though, look,
let's talk strategy, okay?
Because I'm a person who gives no
ground on rhetoric and I'm not going
to accept things that aren't true at all.
Okay.
And when it's thick with what is reality,
we're not going
[00:04:33]
to give into Israeli propaganda
or US propaganda at the same time.
I'm practical. What is our goal?
Eyes on the prize
and the war and the occupation.
Okay. And that's what we got to get to.
So as I'm reading these stories
and they're taking quotes from Arab
[00:04:49]
American leaders, Muslim leaders,
peace leaders, etc., but also pro-Israeli
leaders within the Democratic Party.
And the pro-Israeli leaders say, well,
look, there's no you might as well come to
our side 100% because you're never going
to get these protesters to agree with you.
- So they're never going to be satisfied.
- They're never going to be satisfied.
[00:05:06]
They're unmovable and unreasonable.
So you're never.
Even if you give them a concession,
it's not going to be enough.
So you might as well just get our votes.
And when you look at it, you go,
well, just from a not from a policy
or a moral perspective, but from
a political perspective that that could be
compelling to the Democratic Party.
[00:05:21]
Right.
But then when you look at the next
sentence, though, it gives away the game
because that person says to in that case,
Politico, they go, well, that's because,
of course, the Democratic Party would
never cut funding to Israel and would
never do a weapons embargo and would never
not agree with everything Israel says.
[00:05:37]
So that's why the Palestinian side
is unreasonable.
No, no, no, brother,
that's why you're unreasonable.
Okay, so the Israeli side
demands 100% of what they want.
And then they say, look at
the Palestinian side and the peace side.
They're demanding one thing like a weapons
embargo, not cutting off all funding,
[00:05:57]
not, you know, all the different things
that we could do
to check the Israeli government.
Just a weapons embargo, right?
They're like, can you believe
they had the nerve to ask for one thing?
You see how unreasonable they are?
No, I see how unreasonable you are.
Yeah.
The entitlement is infuriating,
to say the least.
[00:06:15]
And, you know, if there was
a recent attack on Tel Aviv.
Okay.
And obviously horrific.
Not in favor of any of that stuff.
Civilians should be safe.
They shouldn't live in fear.
I don't care if we're talking about
Palestinian civilians
[00:06:31]
or Israeli civilians.
Period. End of story.
Okay, but it is amazing to me
that a single Israeli civilian dying.
Oh, I mean, you'll see the Israeli
officials come out, give statements
about it, talk about humanize them,
about how many kids they had,
[00:06:47]
what kind of music they liked it
because they see their fellow Israelis
as human beings, but they do not
see Palestinian civilians, including
literal children, as human beings.
They have so effectively dehumanized them.
And I'm not just talking about far
right Israeli government officials.
[00:07:04]
I'm also talking about, you know, people
in this country, within our own government
who have gone so far to dehumanize
Palestinians that they don't care.
They they look at the numbers,
they see the rising death toll.
They read the stories about a woman
and six of her children being wiped out
[00:07:23]
in a single Israeli airstrike.
It's Hamas's fault. It's Hamas's fault.
- Yeah, that's what.
- They always say.
They're constant.
Honestly, I'm sorry,
but stupid refrain is Hamas made us murder
all the Palestinian civilians.
No they didn't. You have agency.
[00:07:40]
You didn't have to drop
A2000 bomb pound bomb on families.
You didn't have to drop 100,000 bombs
in civilian areas and to pretend that
somebody made you murder all those people?
No. You chose to do that.
If you're Netanyahu and this grotesque
right wing Israeli government.
[00:07:57]
So, guys, back to strategy
and practical side.
So the Palestinian side and the peace
side here in America, what did they want?
Okay. So they want a weapons embargo.
And that's pretty much the only thing
they're asking for
in terms of the ceasefire deal.
Now Israel is asking
for further occupation of Gaza.
[00:08:15]
They want to put two corridors in
and keep that land.
And so but the and I went
and talked to protesters today.
I talked to Jill Stein.
I talked to the people organizing
the events
and the protests today out in the streets.
And so they're not even saying,
hey, no occupation of Gaza,
[00:08:33]
which they definitely should say, right?
They're not asking to end
the occupation of the West Bank.
Those are all things we want,
and those are great.
But that is not part of the ceasefire
deal, and that is not what is being asked
of Kamala Harris right now.
The ask right now is very it's
I don't even think it goes far enough.
[00:08:49]
I would cut funding to Israel
in order to put pressure on.
But the thing that I care most about,
and what the organizers care most about
is get to the results.
Either way, get to a cease,
a real cease fire.
And however you do it, you know what?
You don't want to do it
with a weapons embargo or cutting funding.
You find a different ingenious way
to do it.
[00:09:05]
Great. Who cares?
Get to the cease fire.
Save those lives. That's what we want.
You can't be more reasonable than that.
Now, look, a lot of times
the protesters have terrible optics, and
they'll come in with, like, weirdo masks
and do graffiti and stuff and things.
That are dehumanizing
toward Israeli civilians.
[00:09:21]
Right.
And remember, that's not anywhere
near the majority of the protesters.
But there will be some people that do
things like that, whoever they are.
Okay.
So then the press will come out and say,
oh yeah, they're all pro Hamas.
They're all terrorists.
Everybody who wants peace are terrorists.
They'll say insane things like that,
right.
[00:09:37]
So I get that the protesters
sometimes are not the best on optics,
but what they're but their core.
- Ask is super.
- Reasonable.
And is Kamala Harris or Tim Walz
or anyone in the Democratic Party
going to give it to them?
Absolutely not.
So that pro-Israel person that talked
to Politico, in a sense they're not wrong.
[00:09:55]
They're saying Israel wants 100% and the
Democratic Party is going to give us 100%.
So stop pretending to the peace protesters
that you're in favor of peace,
or you're in favor of Palestinians
or treating them like human beings,
because we all know you're not,
because we already paid you.
[00:10:11]
We already paid you to be indecent
and immoral to Palestinians
and to continue this war.
So, guys, look, there's a lot
to be excited about here at the DNC.
Kamala Harris and Tim Walz
are doing a great job on other things
like an populist economic positions, etc.
[00:10:28]
But the world is not black and white.
It is not binary.
Their position on Israel is awful
and is enormously unlikely to ever change.
And they think, oh, it's okay.
Every once in a while we'll say,
oh, we think Palestinians are also human?
Good enough? No, not good enough.
[00:10:44]
That's.
I mean, like, thank you
for acknowledging that they exist
and that they're human beings,
but Jesus Christ, that bar is so low.
And until we stop financing
the slaughter of those human beings,
your words are empty.
[00:11:00]
I'm going to say something
that might upset some people,
but I just have to get it off my chest.
Democratic voters
have shockingly low standards.
And so the second that Biden dropped out
and it became clear that Harris
was the presumptive nominee,
[00:11:15]
I can't emphasize enough
how disappointed I am in progressive
and leftist Democratic voters who
immediately decided to fall in line and,
like, become like obsessive promoters
of Kamala Harris without using
[00:11:33]
any of their leverage whatsoever.
Because, look, why would Kamala
Harris do anything for you if you're
already supporting her preemptively.
No matter what.
Yeah. I'm sorry.
- I mean, that's just the truth.
- No, no, I know, I know, so.
Look, guys, the.
But those same, like, leftists are then
going to turn around and be heartbroken
[00:11:51]
when she doesn't give you an inch on Gaza.
She's not going.
- To give you an inch.
- She's not going to give it to you guys.
Why would she? So look what I'm saying.
And what we're both saying is, can we
please be realistic in both directions?
So if she's terrible on Gaza, as almost
every American politician is, that doesn't
[00:12:08]
mean she's terrible on everything else.
That doesn't mean
that you should hate her forever.
Okay?
But if you're telling everybody,
oh, it's a beautiful new day, Kamala
Harris is going to agree to everything
progressives want, including on Gaza.
You're just setting up your audience
for disappointment, and then they're going
to be more mad at her because they're
going to think that she somehow
[00:12:26]
betrayed her own values or turned around.
No, she was never anything
but 100% pro-Israel, right wing Israel,
Netanyahu, Israel.
So stop lying to your audiences.
It's just that she's some sort of godsend
who's going to give you
every miracle in the world.
[00:12:41]
She's not going to do that. Okay?
And then don't turn on her and be like,
oh my God, I was heartbroken because I'm
an idiot and I don't know, politics.
And I didn't know that she was
an establishment Democrat.
And I can't believe
she's agreeing with Israel.
Of course she's going
to agree with Israel.
You apply pressure so that she does not.
We save human lives.
[00:13:00]
But in order to do that,
you don't give away your cookies.
In the beginning, like Anna said, don't go
in and go, oh my God, it's not Biden.
- She's going to give us everything.
- No, no, no.
Okay.
You have to fight for those positions.
They're still Democrats.
So finally, you know,
earlier we talked a little bit about how
[00:13:17]
Kamala might just be able to give these
demonstrators the middle finger and it
won't necessarily hurt her politically.
And what am I referring to?
So there was new polling data by
the University of Chicago and Gen Forward,
and they found some mixed results
when it comes to Democratic voters
[00:13:34]
under the age of 40. So here's
what they found. 36% of them
disapproved of military aid to Israel,
while while 33% approved
and 29% really had no opinion.
The poll showed that the Gaza war ranks
near the bottom of young voters concerns,
[00:13:52]
well below immigration,
economic growth and income inequality.
Yeah.
So there's two notes of caution there.
But at the same time,
just like we always tell you, not binary.
So when you look at that poll, if you
thought that 100% of the American people
were on the side of cutting off aid to
Israel, wakey, wakey, that's not the case.
[00:14:11]
So there are plenty of people
who disagree with us.
Okay.
But at the same time, look at the framing
of the question because they didn't ask,
hey, are you in favor of a ceasefire?
Because that would have gotten about 70,
80, 90% of young people, people under 40,
saying they're in favor of it.
[00:14:26]
If you said end of occupation, again,
it would have been a giant number
in favor of ending the occupation.
- And that's.
- Not theoretical.
There are polls that have those numbers.
So yeah.
So this poll is do you want
to cut off military aid, which again,
if you only watch mainstream media
is considered like sacrilege,
[00:14:44]
like it's almost against Jesus and God
to cut off military aid to Israel because
all mainstream media has ever said is
Israel is the most holy, immoral, greatest
ally democracy that we have ever had.
And we must give them all of our money.
ET cetera.
[00:14:59]
ET cetera.
So now, when you ask,
should we cut off military aid,
which in Washington is super extreme?
Yeah.
The plurality of under 40 voters say.
Yeah.
What you think is extreme. We agree with.
Right.
And so the framing of the question
is enormously important.
[00:15:16]
And then they ask, hey,
where do you prioritize this?
And I get it.
Like if you're a young person, like I
would have told you that ahead of time,
of course they're going to prioritize the
economy, health care, things like that.
Jobs first
because it affects them more, right?
The fact that Gaza
doesn't affect their real lives at all,
[00:15:35]
and they still have it high on the list.
And they care is amazing
and it's wonderful.
And it's very moral of younger Americans
to care about someone
that isn't even in this country.
Right.
And so and then the last thing, guys, is,
even if an issue comes in number seven,
[00:15:52]
number 13, number four,
whatever the number is,
some issues have outsized impact
because of the moral clarity involved.
Right? So it could be a tiny issue.
But if it looks like, hey, you know what,
the people on that side are the ones that
[00:16:09]
are clearly immoral and it gives you pause
about them as human beings, then
that issue can have an outsized impact.
And the reason why you're seeing so many
protests and so many young people that are
animated about this issue is because
to them, it's it provides moral clarity
[00:16:26]
on the character of our politicians.
So if they take it for granted.
Oh, don't worry, it's a little bit
lower priority for younger voters.
Don't worry, only a plurality of them
want us to cut off military aid to Israel.
I think that they're going to make
a mistake because a lot of those younger
[00:16:42]
voters, which, by the way, they now have
back they regained 20 points just like we
told you, okay, among younger voters.
But some of those voters
will go back when they realize,
no, she's not going to give them anything.
And she's still.
And guys, the most important part is,
unfortunately, this is the one issue
[00:16:59]
that everybody pays attention to.
And I say unfortunately, because I
wish they paid more attention to the drug
companies, the oil companies, etc.
That are robbing us blind.
But on this issue, it's super clear that
any politician that's saying that's okay,
we're going to keep sending money
to kill more Palestinians.
They're only doing it for the donor money
and everybody knows that.
[00:17:16]
So when you say, hey, I'm doing
it for the donor money implicitly,
that's going to hurt you.
You could believe me now,
or you could believe me later.
I mean, I've been through this movie
200 times where they'll say,
oh, no, no, we don't believe you.
I saw that one.
- Poll.
- That was framed.
Right.
And I think we could ignore
this issue now.
[00:17:32]
And you'll ignore it at your peril.
And then after she's hurt in the polling
and now there isn't that much time left,
maybe they could, you know, try to adjust,
but they won't because there's I again.
Look, maybe it's a different time.
She picked walls.
She did it economically.
Populist proposals.
Maybe she'll do the right thing
in the third miracle here.
[00:17:50]
But if you're expecting a third miracle,
don't hold your breath.
I would be shocked if any establishment
Democrat ever veered an inch
from giving Israel every amount of money
they have ever asked for.
Thanks for watching The Young Turks
really appreciate it.
Another way to show support
is through YouTube memberships.
[00:18:07]
You'll get to interact with us more.
There's live chat emojis, badges.
You've got emojis of me,
Anna John Jr. So those are super fun.
But you also get playback
of our exclusive member only shows
and specials right after they air.
[00:18:23]
So all of that, all you got
to do is click that join button
right underneath the video.
Thank you.
Now Playing (Clips)
Episode
Podcast
The Young Turks: August 19, 2024
Hosts: Ana KasparianCenk Uygur
- 13 minutes
- 18 minutes
- 7 minutes
- 16 minutes
- 15 minutes
- 43 minutes