Dec 9, 2024
SHOCK: Trump Wants to Make A Deal With Democrats On Immigration
President-elect Donald Trump expressed zero empathy to all undocumented immigrants (and their families) in the country.
- 13 minutes
I'll tell you what's going to be horrible
when we take a wonderful young woman
who's with a criminal and they show
the woman and she could stay by the law,
but they show the woman being taken out,
or they want her out.
[00:00:16]
And your cameras are focused on her
as she's crying,
as she's being taken out of our country.
And then the public turns against us.
But we have to do our job.
President elect Donald Trump
elaborated on his immigration policies
and what he intends to carry out
during a lengthy sit down interview with
[00:00:34]
Kristen Welker over at Meet the Press.
And while he seemed to have,
well, zero empathy for most
undocumented immigrants in the country,
he did say that he wants
to work out a deal with Democrats
when it comes to some of the
undocumented immigrants in the country.
[00:00:50]
We're going to get to those details
in just a minute.
But before we do, let's hear his take
on what should happen
when it comes to families
with the mixed immigration status.
Let's take a look.
You're saying yes, you're going to focus
on the people with criminal histories, but
[00:01:07]
everyone who's here illegally has to go.
I'm saying you're.
Saying we have to get
the criminals out of our country.
We have to get people that were taken out
of mental institutions and put them back
into their mental institution,
no matter what country it is.
The estimated 4 million families in
America who have mixed immigration status.
[00:01:24]
So I'm talking about parents
who might be here illegally,
but the kids are here legally.
Your borders are.
- Talking about.
- Separation.
Well, I mean,
there are two aspects to this.
Your border czar, Tom Homan,
said they can be deported together.
Is that the plan?
Well, that way you keep the.
No. Well, I don't want to be
breaking up families.
[00:01:42]
So the only way you don't break
up the family is you keep them together
and you have to send them all back.
So that is exactly what Tom Homan also
said and said it without any apology, any
concern about how it might come across.
[00:01:58]
And what's interesting is people seem
to be cheering that on.
Right. And so I. Don't believe it.
- You don't believe.
- It. Yeah.
So here's my thoughts on it.
So and I thought that interview
was really telling.
So let's start with the, let's start
[00:02:17]
with the bad news and go to the good news.
So the bad news is they're he
claims they are really going to try
to deport everyone right now.
Will they be able to do that?
No, I don't think they can.
Right.
And nor do I think he's going
to actually execute it.
In fact, the very first clip we showed you
is the most important one.
[00:02:35]
I'm going to come back to it in a second.
So are they going to deport people
who have criminal convictions but were,
you know, had served their sentence
and are now out in, in America,
but they are undocumented, etc..
Oh yeah, they're going
to definitely deport those guys.
Right.
So and there's no force on earth
that's going to stop them from doing that.
[00:02:53]
So I know that there's people on the left
who are getting ready to oppose that.
Oh, don't send out the criminals.
It's never going to work.
Okay. So that's going to happen.
And so we'll see where we draw the line
on what they mean by criminals.
Right.
And that's a very important distinction.
[00:03:08]
Okay.
Now then they're going to move on
to the next category.
And that's where the rubber
is going to hit the road.
So the Homans of the world,
he surrounded himself with a lot
of very anti-immigrant people.
And he himself is
very anti-immigrant in that regard.
Trump is.
So when they go to deport the actual,
what, 12, 13 million?
[00:03:26]
I don't know, however many millions
of undocumented immigrants,
then you're going to see the,
the pictures that he was alluding to
in that first clip of people crying
and the backlash, the backlash, etc..
Now, do you remember what happened
the last time there was backlash?
[00:03:41]
It took a long time.
There was a ton of pressure
about the kids in cages.
But Trump then backed away
from that policy
because he doesn't like to be unpopular.
And so what he was saying there is
I'm going to try to deport
as many people as possible and then see
how much the American people howl.
[00:03:59]
And when he I think what he's saying
is when he gets in my mind
that they're howling too much.
I'll know I went too far.
But which, by the way,
means that I don't think
that starting maximalist is a good idea.
But when they get to a point
where we are all uncomfortable, okay,
[00:04:16]
which will be probably relatively quick,
we've got to fight back.
Okay.
Because he's looking to see
how much people are going to fight back.
He responds, you're right.
He responds to how people react
to the way he implements policies
or carries out policies.
[00:04:32]
And it's you're right.
He loves validation.
He wants to be admired.
And look, you can see that as good or bad.
There is a positive element to it.
You know, compare that to, let's say,
Joe Biden, who sees the majority
[00:04:49]
of the Democratic base incredibly unhappy
with the unlimited support toward Israel
and what it's doing in Gaza.
They didn't care. They didn't care.
You see, Biden's approval numbers
drop consistently.
Didn't care.
Does not care about
how his own base feels about him.
[00:05:06]
On the other hand,
you have someone like Donald Trump
who is very responsive to his base.
Now, it really depends
on what his base wants.
But to their credit, last time around,
when he was too draconian
in his immigration policies
and when he was deporting too many people
and putting people in those cages,
well, there was backlash.
[00:05:24]
And he did back off of that policy.
So I think you make a good point there.
But there was another element
in this conversation that I thought
was I don't agree with at all.
And so you're about to hear it
in this next video.
Take a look.
You've promised to end
birthright citizenship on day one.
[00:05:41]
- Is that still your plan?
- Yeah, absolutely.
The 14th amendment, though,
says that, quote, all persons born
in the United States are citizens.
Can you get around the 14th amendment
with an executive action, a change?
We'll maybe have to go back
to the people, but we have to end it.
- We're the only country that has it.
- Through an executive action.
[00:05:58]
We're the only country that has it.
We are not the only country
that has birthright citizenship.
I just want to be clear about that.
This is just some
of the countries on the globe.
Antigua and Barbuda, Argentina. Barbados.
Belize, Bolivia, Brazil,
Canada, Chad, Costa Rica, Cuba,
[00:06:17]
El Salvador, Fiji, Grenada.
You've got Guatemala.
You guys get the picture.
There's plenty of other countries
that have birthright citizenship.
Also, how do you end
birthright citizenship?
What does that mean?
How do you become a citizen
if you end birthright citizenship?
Yeah.
So does it mean we end
birthright citizenship?
[00:06:34]
If your parents are immigrants
or undocumented immigrants or legal
immigrants, or we end it all together,
in which case, nobody's American anymore
when they're born in America.
So how does that make any sense?
So look, so I this was
so clarifying this interview.
[00:06:51]
I get what he's doing.
So he's setting the two boundaries
that are kind of.
There's good news and bad news, right?
The bad news is he.
Well depends on how your perspective.
So let me.
So the boundaries are he's saying
if you're convicted criminal you're gone.
Not negotiable. Right.
[00:07:08]
The second thing he's saying is
he's giving us hope about the dreamers,
which we're going to talk
a little bit more about in a second,
that he might actually do a deal
about them, which would steal
the Democrats thunder, Democrats thunder.
And it's actually a really great idea.
And we would be happy to make sure
that we protect the dreamers.
[00:07:25]
By the way, if I see any left wing
show telling us that we shouldn't protect
the dreamers because it would help Trump,
I'm going to lose it.
Okay. You've got to let go of your mania.
Okay. We want the dreamers protected.
Everyone is on our side.
Has always wanted the dreamers protected.
[00:07:41]
I'm not saying Trump's going to do it.
I'm saying if he does it
take yes for an answer.
Stop being like no.
It's a secret, evil, racist plan
to protect the dreamers.
Okay, now let's get to the hard parts.
Right?
The hard parts are in the middle.
So when he starts talking about
deporting everyone, I think it's crazy.
[00:07:57]
I think they won't be able to do it.
Number two, the thing that he mentioned
first where, hey, the kids are citizens,
but the family,
their parents are undocumented.
We're sending them all back.
No, no, you're not sending
any citizens back.
Okay, so there's going to be a giant,
giant pushback there.
[00:08:14]
And that pushback has to be significant
enough to make him change his mind.
And then and then lastly, this ending
birthright citizenship is insanity.
Total insanity.
And and he's got
to actually get an amendment.
You can't do that without an amendment.
He seems to acknowledge that.
[00:08:29]
But again, there there's a little sliver
of hope, because when he acknowledged
that it has to be done through
an amendment that's basically saying
we're not going to do it.
Amendments are near impossible, right?
And certainly he couldn't get three
quarters of the states to agree to that,
because there's tons of blue states.
And his even if he doesn't know that,
his advisors know that, right.
[00:08:47]
So they're going to push
to see how far they can push.
And when the time comes, which is going
to be really near the beginning.
We got to push back to protect the people
that we need to protect.
I'm going to venture to say
that the vast majority of Americans,
including Republican voters, would not
want to end birthright citizenship.
[00:09:03]
That's crazy.
- Like that's.
- Crazy.
Totally crazy. And because that.
Puts your own citizenship in jeopardy.
But even if you said it, oh, to those
dirty undocumented immigrants, etc.,
still people are going to push back
on birthright citizenship.
That's not the majority of the country
is not there, and they're going
to find that out the hard way.
[00:09:18]
Okay.
But look, the one we keep talking
about this as an advantage, right?
Because it is we're doing honest analysis.
Trump is, ironically,
more of a traditional politician
before the donor class took over.
[00:09:34]
Now, because of the donor class,
establishment Republicans
and establishment Democrats will never,
ever disagree with their donors.
And if you got some knucklehead
on the right or the left telling you that,
oh, no, the donors aren't in charge,
Kamala Harris and Joe Biden.
But golly gee,
if they was the moral thing to do.
[00:09:51]
They would defy their donors.
That person is a fool
and is showing you that.
Well, other than their ass,
they're showing you that they
don't understand politics at all.
Not 1%. I think it's important to hear
what he's saying here.
And you're right,
Democrats should take the win.
If he actually does pursue this.
Take a look.
[00:10:07]
We have to do something
about the dreamers, because these are
people that have been brought here
at a very young age, and many of these
are middle aged people now.
They don't even speak
the language of their country.
And yes, we're going
to do something about that.
- Does that.
- Mean, what are you going.
To do?
I will work with the Democrats on a plan,
and if we can come up with a plan.
[00:10:25]
But the Democrats have made it
very, very difficult to do anything.
Republicans are very open to the dreamers.
The dreamers.
We're talking many years ago they were
brought into this country many years ago.
Some of them are no longer young people,
and in many cases they become successful.
[00:10:42]
They have great jobs.
In some cases they have small businesses.
In some cases they might
have large businesses.
And we're going to have
to do something with them and you.
Want them to be able to stay.
That's what you're saying?
- I do.
- I want to be able to work something out.
And it should have been able to be
worked out over the last 3 or 4 years,
[00:10:58]
and it never got worked out.
So obvious dig at the Biden administration
and the Democratic Party in the end.
I think that that was a legitimate
and credible dig, because they should have
done something about the dreamers over
the last four years, and they did not.
Now, if Trump is being real
and he wants to pursue legislation
[00:11:17]
to provide protections for dreamers,
and it seems like he's being honest
about wanting to do that,
Democrats should absolutely work
with him to make that happen
and not play games, Partizan games
to prevent it from happening.
We also need to be honest about
why the protection for the dreamers
ended in the first place,
which was an executive order by Obama.
[00:11:35]
That executive order
protected the dreamers.
DACA kept them here in the US without
worry or fear that they'd be deported.
And then in Trump's first term,
he undid that executive order.
So if he cares about.
If he cared about the dreamers,
why did he do that?
So let's be honest about that.
[00:11:51]
So look at the same time, why haven't we
been able to protect the dreamers so far?
Because the Republicans, let's be honest.
So like they're I don't think
there's a lot of donor money
in not protecting the dreamers.
So normally that's the one thing
that inhibits the Democratic establishment
from getting something done.
[00:12:06]
But those establishment Republicans
were dead set against it.
So if Trump can make them heal, yep.
That would get rid of our giant
impediment, which is the Republican Party.
Okay. So let's be clear about that.
So, to finish my earlier point,
look, when you have someone
[00:12:24]
strictly serving the donor class
like Mitch McConnell or Joe Biden, they're
never, ever going to move on anything.
And I think a lot of the progressives in
Congress, too, were very naive about this.
They were like, oh, no,
they are our colleagues
and we can get them to do the right thing.
[00:12:39]
And unfortunately, we were right.
You couldn't because they
don't care about the policies.
They only care to serve the donors.
That is Why does Trump
care about the donors?
Of course he put the donors
in charge of the government, right.
Miriam Adelson guest foreign policy.
Elon Musk gets domestic policy, etc.
[00:12:56]
But at the same time, he's more
of a traditional politician in that he
actually cares about his popularity.
He actually cares.
Hey, am I losing my base?
Am I not losing my base? Etc.
So that is an advantage
that we could use to say, hey, if you want
to be more popular, do things people like
rather than things that people don't like.
[00:13:13]
And that is and that we did not have
with any Democrat or Republican
that was establishment
because they were absolutely immovable.
Thanks for watching The Young Turks
really appreciate it.
Another way to show support
is through YouTube memberships.
You'll get to interact with us more.
There's live chat emojis, badges.
[00:13:31]
You've got emojis of me
Anna John Jr. So those are super fun.
But you also get playback
of our exclusive member only shows
and specials right after they air.
So all of that, all you got
to do is click that join button
right underneath the video.
[00:13:46]
Thank you.
Now Playing (Clips)
Episode
Podcast
The Young Turks: December 9, 2024
Hosts: Cenk UygurAna Kasparian
- 15 minutes
- 23 minutes
- 20 minutes
- 13 minutes
- 8 minutes
- 11 minutes