Dec 11, 2025
Kristi Noem Forced To Confront Veteran She Deported
Secretary of Homeland Security Kristi Noem was forced to answer to a veteran she deported during a congressional hearing.
- 10 minutes
All right, one last story for you guys.
Let's roll it.
Madam Secretary, how many United States
military veterans have you deported?
Sir, we have not deported U.S.
Citizens or military veterans.
[00:00:16]
Oh, is that so?
Well, Secretary of Homeland Security
Kristi Noem
claims that she has not deported
any citizens or military veterans.
But Representative Seth Magaziner
brings up two instances
where DHS has done exactly that.
[00:00:31]
Before we get into the details, Jake,
I know you and Anna covered
a similar story earlier this week,
so I'd love to get your $0.02.
Yeah, no, this is different because,
Democrats effectively
stood up to Kristi Noem.
That's like the most shocking news
you'll hear all month.
[00:00:48]
So you're going to see
a bunch of instances here where Democrats
do a fantastic job in hearings.
I'm blown away by it. So let's show you.
All right.
So the first case that Magaziner brought
up involved the deportation of a veteran
who was shot twice while serving
in the US military in Panama in 1989.
[00:01:11]
Madam Secretary, we are joined on zoom
by a gentleman named Sejun Park.
He is a United States Army combat veteran
who was shot twice while serving
our country in Panama in 1989.
Like many veterans, he struggled
with PTSD and substance abuse.
[00:01:27]
After his service, he was arrested
in the 1990s for some minor drug offenses.
Nothing serious.
He never hurt anyone besides himself, and
he's been clean and sober for 14 years.
He is a combat veteran,
a Purple Heart recipient.
He has sacrificed more for this country
than most people ever have.
[00:01:45]
Earlier this year, you deported him
to Korea, a country he hasn't lived in
since he was seven years old.
All right, so that was one.
And the second case that he brings up
is that of the wife
of Navy combat veteran Jim Brown.
[00:02:04]
His name is Jim Brown from Troy, Missouri.
He is a Navy combat veteran
who served our country in the Gulf War.
He's married to a woman named Donna,
who came to our country legally
from Ireland when she was 11 years old.
She has lived here for 48 years.
[00:02:21]
Because of you, Jim's wife, Donna, has
been in prison for the last four months.
She did not come here illegally, and she
has never committed any crime other than
writing two bad checks totaling $80.
Ten years ago.
[00:02:36]
She is currently in prison
and facing deportation.
So in both of those cases,
no one thanked the veterans for their
service to our country and then committed
to looking over their cases.
I can't say that I'm entirely confident
anything will come from that.
[00:02:54]
The reason being, you know, the objective
of Ice isn't to get dangerous
illegal criminals out of this country.
It's to bolster the Trump administration.
They know that the majority of people
who voted for Trump in 2024
did so because of illegal immigration.
They know that a big part of the messaging
coming from the Trump campaign
[00:03:12]
was anti-immigrant.
So now they have to maintain the image
of being tough on immigration.
The problem is that the Trump claim
that there are gangs
of dangerous drug criminals and terrorists
running rampant across our country,
[00:03:28]
it turns out, wasn't entirely true.
So now they've got to at least look
like they're being tough on immigration.
But even the right wing
is taking notice of it.
Take a look.
When you have this clumsy,
you know, kind of somewhat insane
[00:03:45]
over the top deportations, people are
looking at this and going, it's unserious,
it's unserious, it's childish, it's cruel.
I think one of the problems with whatever
the MAGA movement has evolved into
[00:04:00]
is it's duped their hardcore followers
so much that the only thing left now
is performative cruelty.
So of course, we know now
that about a third of the people arrested
by Ice had no criminal record at all.
And that's nearly 75,000 people.
[00:04:18]
And the people who voted for Trump
in 2024 did so because they were told
that these immigrants were dangerous,
violent criminals, and they wanted
those dangerous, violent people gone.
Even those voters did not ask for
nonviolent, non-criminal immigrants who
[00:04:33]
came here legally to be targeted this way.
So, Jake, what are your thoughts here?
Yeah. So I'll tell you why it's happening.
And then, shockingly,
Nick Fuentes is also going to agree.
So, and he's going to make
a similar point to Dylan.
[00:04:49]
So I'll come back to that in a second.
First, they're deporting about 840
people a day so far this year.
But in order to break Obama's record,
they have to do 3000 a day.
Now, obviously it's not going to happen.
It's already too late.
But Stephen Miller put a ton of pressure
on them to do that because he wanted Trump
[00:05:07]
to be the deporter in chief, not Obama.
And so there's a lot of ironies
in that statement.
But, since they can't make it
and since they can't square two different
things at the same time, they're going
to have to do something else instead.
[00:05:23]
What do I mean
by the two different things?
Well, you can't make both your base
and the general population happy here
because they're in conflict.
The base wants mass deportations,
and they're not unclear about that.
And that is a significant chunk
of Republican voters.
But the general population in America
does not want mass deportations,
[00:05:43]
and they want the border closed.
Trump did give them that.
That's why he was popular
in the beginning with that.
They do want undocumented criminal,
folks to be taken out of the country.
And that was popular.
And Trump did do that in the beginning.
But now when they got
to mass deportations,
[00:05:59]
they lost Rogan, Dylan, everyone, all the
independent podcasters, independent media.
But most importantly,
they lost independent voters.
And so now all of a sudden,
Trump is pulling badly in immigration
because he's gone way too far.
[00:06:14]
So since he can't get, you know,
good polling on this and make his base
happy at the same time, instead,
he's doing this switcheroo, this three
card monte that Dylan is talking about.
So, well, I can't give you the amount
of deportations you want, so I'll give you
[00:06:32]
performative cruelty instead.
Shockingly, even Nick Fuentes
acknowledges that and recognizes that.
- Watch.
- So I do think it's performative.
And what I mean by that is, you know,
when they're doing the deportations,
[00:06:50]
they know the deportations are not
where the base wants them to be.
They deported.
The figures are disputed,
but from my data it's 300,000 in the year,
which is not a massive deportation.
They know the base is unhappy with that.
So what do they do?
The deportations
that they are carrying out.
[00:07:07]
They do a big spectacle
and they arrest everybody and they film it
and they put a hype at it.
And there's a meanness in there.
They played that song, I think,
from Sabrina Carpenter or something,
and they make it a joke.
They make it glib,
and they do that because they're not
delivering on the promise.
[00:07:24]
So they compensate by doing it meaner,
edgier, more, more mean spirited,
so that the base will overlook
the fact that it's not happening.
And I think that's, by definition,
performative cruelty.
You can call me a hypocrite,
but it's definitely true about
what they're doing in the administration.
[00:07:42]
Yeah, I show you guys that because not
because we agree with Fuentes.
Fuentes wants mass deportation.
I'm on the left. I don't want it.
Dylan's an independent.
He doesn't want it.
Fuentes does want it.
But we all agree
that we have eyes and ears.
[00:07:57]
And whether you want the mass deportation
or not, that's not exactly this.
This is performative cruelty
to try to trick you into thinking
mission accomplished.
And and now all the way back to the
Democrats effectively challenging Noam.
I mean, here's veterans with, like,
microscopic infractions that took bullets
[00:08:17]
for this country being deported.
What is that?
I mean, I so I think that the that
the administration is misreading this.
Number one,
they're getting caught by their own side.
We see you.
This isn't really a mass deportations.
[00:08:33]
I mean, I think to me qualifies,
but it doesn't qualify for his base.
And you're not tricking us
with the performative cruelty,
and no one asks you to deport veterans
who took bullets for this country.
So it went very poorly for Noam there.
And surprisingly good grilling
by the Democrats.
[00:08:51]
Yeah.
And I think that that's something
that's kind of happening now
where, again, we're not even a year
into this Trump administration,
but a lot of his old tricks he's learning
are not working as well
as they did the first time around, because
there's only so much you can say to people
before they're like, you know what?
[00:09:07]
This isn't even what we asked for.
He promised America first
on a lot of things.
He promised,
less involvement in places like Israel.
His own base does not like the things
that he is doing.
And they're asking him to stop.
And now they're realizing
that he's not even listening to us.
[00:09:23]
It's not just like he's trying
to stick it to the libs or to the left.
He's not even listening to us.
We're his people,
and he's not helping us the way that he
said that he wanted to help us.
So there's a lot of disconnect, I think,
now between this Trump administration
and the Trump voters, that is much more,
[00:09:42]
just like, just more tangibly felt than it
was during his first administration.
They're seeing the things that he's doing.
They're asking him to stop doing it.
They're asking him for help.
Even just recently, he did a rally
where he was touting how good the economy
is doing, and his own supporters turned up
to that rally with signs saying,
[00:10:00]
we want higher wages
and we want lower prices,
and that is not what he offered them,
and that is not what he is offering them.
And even if he does manage to somehow
manage grocery prices right now,
it will only be to compensate for the fact
that he inflated them in the first place
with a lot of his tariffs
and a lot of his, economic policies.
[00:10:19]
Even his old trick of trying
to blame the last guy for the bad economy
is not working, because as soon as he
got into office, he enacted several very,
very strong economic measures.
And so it's very hard to, to separate him
and this economy from, I'm sorry.
[00:10:38]
It's very hard to separate this economy
from his administration
and from him specifically.
So hopefully this will continue.
Every time you ring the bell below,
an angel gets his wings.
Totally not true.
But it does keep you updated
on our live shows.
Now Playing (Clips)
Episode
Podcast
