Dec 11, 2025
Judge SMACKS DOWN Trump, Orders Abrego Garcia’s Release
Kilmar Abrego Garcia has been set free after a judge ordered his release.
- 8 minutes
And a judge has ordered Kilmer
Abrego Garcia be immediately released
from immigration detention.
The administration is trying to send him
to Liberia after first deporting him
to El Salvador against the judge's order.
Now, federal judge says the absence
of a removal order prevents the government
from deporting him at all.
[00:00:18]
Well, after a saga that has gone on
for way longer than it ever should have,
a federal judge has ordered the immediate
release of Kilmer Abrego Garcia,
citing Abrego Garcia's initial
wrongful detention in El Salvador
and then his second detention,
which was done without lawful authority.
[00:00:37]
So the deadline for release
was set as no later than 5 p.m.
Eastern time today,
so he should be out by now.
Jake, before we get into the details,
though, your $0.02 on all this.
Yeah.
So there's one piece
of spectacular news here.
[00:00:52]
The good news is about justice
in this particular case.
The better news
is about the precedent overall.
But I do want to note here
real quick Liberia, we're going
to send the brother to Liberia.
Why? This is just absolutely absurd.
[00:01:09]
And then my favorite is
the judge's reason for denying it.
So let's get into it
and then I'll do the comments.
Right.
So just to quickly recap for our audience,
Kilmer Abrego.
Garcia was taken
from his wife and children.
He was living in Maryland, and then
he was deported to the secret prison
[00:01:27]
in El Salvador in March of this year.
The Trump administration said
that he was a member of Ms. 13,
which has never been proven.
In June, he was finally brought back
to the United States,
but only to stand trial
for human trafficking charges
that had been brought against him
as part of this big PR campaign that
[00:01:46]
the Trump administration was running
to justify the fact that they detained and
deported Abrego Garcia in the first place.
He was later detained a second time
by immigration officers.
The federal government tried
to deport him, then to Liberia this time,
[00:02:03]
but they were blocked from doing so.
They also tried unsuccessfully to deport
him to Uganda, Eswatini and Ghana.
Even though Abrego Garcia's preferred
country of removal was Costa Rica,
and Costa Rica was actually offering him
residence and refugee status.
[00:02:19]
Of course, the Trump administration
is not happy about this order.
Tricia McLaughlin, the spokesperson
for the Department of Homeland Security,
had this to say about the ruling.
She said this is naked judicial activism
by an Obama appointed judge.
[00:02:35]
This order lacks any valid legal basis,
and we will continue to fight
this tooth and nail in the courts.
And, Jake, I have an update
from our producers.
Abrego.
Garcia's legal team has said that he has
been released, so that is good to hear.
[00:02:50]
- What are your thoughts?
- All right.
Excellent. They follow the judge's orders.
That's amazing. Okay, so first of all,
Uganda, Eswatini, Ghana.
The judge said, basically
common sense here is going going Ghana.
[00:03:12]
No, we're not gonna send him
to Ghana or Liberia for no reason at all.
That's ludicrous. Right.
But my favorite is the judge saying, well,
but the core of the ruling is because
there is an absence of a removal order.
Well, how are you going to remove
the brother if there's no removal order?
[00:03:29]
Like, do we have any like,
does the Trump administration think
that any laws apply at all to them,
to their actions to the government?
Or is the government
just like anarchy now?
Who cares what the laws of America are,
what the Constitution are?
Okay, yeah. We don't have a removal order.
[00:03:46]
So what?
What do we need your stinking laws for?
We want to send them to our. Where?
We're here.
Throw a dart. Yeah.
Ghana. Yeah.
That's it. So. But now the good news.
Hey, look at that. The system's working.
And the judge is saying,
no, you don't get to make up rules.
[00:04:04]
You don't get to make up removal orders
or make up countries
you're going to send them to.
Do you have evidence?
What's your evidence?
What? Forget the evidence, do you not?
No one even asked to remove him.
There's no order to remove him.
So what is this?
What are you guys doing?
[00:04:19]
And now there's been
a stunning number of cases
where the judges, you know, Democratic.
Republican.
Trump appointed doesn't matter.
Are coming back and going.
This is not a thing.
So like get your act in order and come
back in with at least some sort of
[00:04:36]
argument based in the law, you buffoons.
So and they released him
as we just told you.
That's breaking news happening right now.
And so look, what we were concerned about
is not whether Donald Trump would try
to stretch the law, the Constitution, etc.
[00:04:52]
He's a guy who said we should terminate
the Constitution after he lost in 2020,
so that was never in doubt.
And Trump is constantly testing boundaries
for how far he can go,
how much power he can seize for himself,
extrajudicially, extralegally, etc..
[00:05:08]
So the question was twofold.
One was, are the courts going to hold?
And so far so good, by the way, they're
not always going to rule in our favor.
And oftentimes they're going
to stretch, stretch, stretch
to go to Trump's direction.
That isn't the question.
The question is, yes, but are they going
to roughly be within the scope of the law
[00:05:24]
and the Constitution?
And so far,
the courts have been number two is yes.
But when the courts order Trump
to do something, is he going to create
a constitutional crisis and go,
I don't need no stinking courts.
I'm the guy with the guns
because we're the executive branch.
And so far he has not done that.
[00:05:40]
I mean, he he fights it all the way to
the end and then he complies at the end.
And that's that's super important because
if he crossed that Rubicon, we'd be having
a completely different conversation.
You know what TYT has always been about?
Taking on the corrupt,
greedy establishment.
[00:05:57]
For us, it's the corporate media.
We've been fighting that fight
for over 20 years.
For the cell phone industry,
it's the same story, a handful
of massive corporations ripping you off.
That's why we're partnering
with Noble Mobile.
They're the only wireless company with
the same mission as ours to fight back.
[00:06:14]
Their no bull plan offers unlimited data
for just $50 a month.
But here's the best part for any
data you don't use, you get cash back.
Real money you can spend however you want.
Stop letting your unused data
pad the pockets of billionaires.
[00:06:30]
With noble.
You take control over your data,
and by switching to noble, you're directly
supporting tight and our mission
of bringing you honest, independent news.
So give noble a try
and make the switch today.
Scan the QR code on the screen now
or visit gold.com.
[00:06:50]
That's go.
So those are two things that are great.
And then lastly there's you know, one of
the questions we had because media makes
such a big difference in swinging, public
opinion and hence politics and elections.
[00:07:07]
How would the Trump supporters
that were independent,
broadcasters, podcasters, etc.
React to abuses like this?
And so far they've been terrific
with Rogan and Dylan
and so many others going, no, no, no,
nobody asks for these mass deportations
and for you to pick up grandma
[00:07:24]
and for you to make up laws
and for you to send this guy to Timbuktu.
It's just none of that makes sense.
So cut the crap out.
So both the independent media
and the courts have held
and that that's definitely great news.
Yeah.
And I do think it's sad that whenever they
actually did follow the court ruling,
[00:07:45]
that was a victory for us
because you never know.
There's there have been plenty of times
when this administration has just
disregarded court rulings in the past,
and now they're going to continue
fighting it, saying that they're going
to fight this in the courts
and they really have no legal basis.
[00:08:01]
Like there's no way
that they can win this.
And they must know that because this whole
thing was fabricated in the first place.
As as I said, a PR campaign
because they screwed up.
They sent a guy away
that they should not have sent away.
And then they had to justify it,
saying, yeah, we may have accidentally
[00:08:17]
sent him to El Salvador,
but he was a bad guy anyway, so it's fine.
So every time you ring the bell below,
an angel gets his wings.
Totally not true.
But it does keep you updated
on our live shows.
Now Playing (Clips)
Episode
Podcast
