May 19, 2025
Trump's 'BEAUTIFUL' Bill Passes Its First Hurdle
President Trump's tax and immigration hurdle overcame opposition from hard-line conservatives over spending.
- 15 minutes
The ayes have it. The motion is agreed to.
The One Big Beautiful Bill act,
as ordered, reported favorably
to the House of Representatives
with a favorable recommendation.
Mr. Chair, on the vote there were 17 ayes,
16 noes, and four present.
And we count that as a big win tonight.
There's a lot more work to do.
[00:00:17]
We've always acknowledged
that towards the end
there will be more details to iron out.
We have several more to take care of,
but I'm looking forward
to very thoughtful discussions,
very productive discussions
over the next few days,
and I am absolutely convinced we're going
to get this in final form and pass it.
The rare Sunday night vote that took place
in the Budget Committee in the House,
[00:00:37]
you heard from first Jodey Arrington,
who is the chairman.
He's of Texas, the chairman
of the budget committee there.
So after a weekend jank of all these late
night negotiations between the Republican
leadership and the holdouts that they had,
those are the, you know,
the 4 or 5 hardliners that held
[00:00:54]
out in this in this big, beautiful bill,
as they're calling it.
It's clear that major hurdle
of getting out of the the committee.
Then the next step would be
on to the floor, then on to the Senate,
and presumably chop
to pieces there and then back.
[00:01:10]
The four holdouts
on the House Budget Committee, though,
agreed to vote present instead of no.
So they went from no to present,
not no to yes on this bill.
What they're calling
the Big Beautiful Bill act.
And that's what the president called it,
allowing the legislative package to be
[00:01:25]
recommended favorably to the House floor.
And before we give you and we go into
the details there, tell me what you think.
So I think that everybody's distracted
by 100 different flying squirrels
that Trump is throwing out every day.
When this is the real deal,
this is the most important thing.
[00:01:43]
This is where they're going
to blow up the budget.
They're going to put
like $5 trillion extra on the debt.
And at the end, after Michael gives you
the details of what's going on, I'm going
to explain what the real story is, okay?
The real story,
it is something that we've seen
in our lifetimes over and over again.
[00:02:00]
Is there a chance that this story ends
a little differently
than it has in the past?
A small chance, but they'll probably run
the same exact playbook.
So let's tell you what's happening now,
and then I'll tell you what.
- The playbook.
- Okay.
So one of the the major sticking
points here that had these four
[00:02:16]
members of Congress hold out
and then come back with present votes,
and those those members of Congress
are Ralph Norman of South Carolina,
Rasheen of Oklahoma.
Andrew Clyde, you see there.
I'm not reading them in order, but they're
coming from the top of my head.
Andrew Clyde of Georgia
and Chip Roy of Texas.
[00:02:33]
There was also Lloyd Smucker of
Pennsylvania, who voted no the other day.
So they came around these four
so they could get out of committee.
But one of the major sticking points
that that have held this back
for these guys is, is our Medicare cuts.
[00:02:49]
Currently, the Energy and Commerce
Committee's Medicaid provisions
are expected to reduce spending
by $625 billion, but leave 7.6 million
more people uninsured by 2034.
That's according to preliminary estimates
from the Congressional Budget Office.
[00:03:05]
But the hardliners here that we
talked about, they want even more cuts.
So as the legislation
is currently written,
work requirements take effect in 2029,
but they're pushing for the requirements
to start as soon as 2027, which would kick
even more people off of their insurance.
[00:03:23]
They also want to reduce the amount of
money the federal government pays to state
run Medicaid programs Sunday night,
though, in agreeing to change
their votes to present,
Roy wrote on social media after that vote.
This the bill does not yet meet the moment
I joined with three of my colleagues
[00:03:40]
to vote present out of respect
for the Republican Conference and the
president to move the bill forward.
It gives us the opportunity to work
together this week to get the job done.
Their concession, though, came
after public pressure from Donald Trump,
who wrote on Truth Social on Friday.
[00:03:57]
And this is before that vote.
I believe Republicans must unite
behind the one big, beautiful bill.
The country will suffer greatly
without the legislation
and their taxes going up 65%.
We don't need grandstanders
in the Republican Party.
Stop talking and get it done.
[00:04:13]
And on Friday,
when that other vote happened, the vote
that didn't get it out of committee,
where they where they voted against it,
they were defying the president here.
So they were saying,
you can call us what you want,
but we're going to vote this way today.
Carolyn Leavitt doubled down on that push
and made a blatantly false claim.
[00:04:30]
In so doing, have a listen
to the press secretary.
It is absolutely essential
that Republicans unite behind the one big,
beautiful bill
and deliver on President Trump's agenda.
There is no time to waste.
Americans gave Republicans
a once in a generation opportunity
[00:04:45]
to course correct our country
over many wrongs over the past four years,
and Americans are counting on Republicans
to work as hard as President Trump is
in this white House every day on Capitol
Hill, send this legislation to his desk
as soon as possible for his signature.
Is the president okay
with this bill adding to the deficit?
[00:05:05]
This bill does not add to the deficit.
In fact, according to the Council
of Economic Advisers,
this bill will save $1.6 trillion.
And the president absolutely understands
and hears the concerns
of fiscal conservatives and of Americans
who want to get our fiscal house in order.
[00:05:22]
That's what the intention
of this bill is, right.
But let's tell you the truth
about this bill.
Between the new spending and the lost
tax revenue, the measure would increase
the nation's $36.2 trillion debt by at
least 2.5 trillion over the next decade.
[00:05:40]
Well, now, this big, beautiful bill
that is not yet ready to pass
heads to the Rules Committee,
which is where more changes can be made
before it goes to the full caucus.
Speaker Johnson, for his part,
set a deadline this week of this week
for the House to take a floor vote.
[00:05:56]
But as of right now,
the bill still lacks support.
In order to pass.
And it won't go to the floor until it
does, they can only lose two votes
on the floor of Congress.
Of all the lawmakers
are present and voting.
And to boot, Andrew Clyde of Georgia,
who was one of those four?
[00:06:14]
He is, you know, he's against these
Medicaid cuts and not going far enough,
but he also has, is holding out so that he
can get a, less regulation on silencers,
on guns, and that in the, in the firearms
bill, and he's holding his vote here
[00:06:33]
hostage so that they stop the regulations
on the suppressors or silencers for guns.
- Oh, good.
- Good, good.
So we're going to have
massive trillions of dollars in tax cuts
for the rich and help assassins.
Okay.
All right. Great.
[00:06:48]
That's a relief, by the way.
Blue lives matter.
Silencers are My police friends.
Okay, anyway, random side issue here.
Okay, now let.
Not random because that's part of this
bill and part of what's holding it up.
[00:07:04]
- And what you said is absolutely true.
- So yeah.
Okay.
So now let's get to the major playbook.
So how is this going to play out
if its history is any guide?
This is what happened.
So the far right in Congress,
always in the House in the beginning,
[00:07:20]
whether they're called a Freedom Caucus
or the Tea Party
or whatever other moniker they put on,
it will huff and puff and go,
oh my God, the deficit, the deficit,
the deficit is the most important thing.
And you're like, okay, then
why are you doing 5 trillion in tax cuts?
No no no. Cut, cut cut from the poor.
[00:07:37]
Give it to the rich. Cut from the poor.
Give it to the rich.
You haven't cut from the poor enough.
You haven't cut
from the middle class enough.
Make it more regressive. Right.
And then they'll have a fake drama like.
Oh, is it going to pass?
Is it not going to pass? Oh my God.
And they're so worried about the deficit.
Meanwhile no one will talk
about the tax cuts in this case.
[00:07:53]
I just want to clarify a couple of things.
She had that massive lie about how I
was going to save $1.7 trillion.
That lie is ubiquitous.
It happens every single time.
It's part of the playbook.
Well, it looks like that it's going
to cost 5 trillion,
but really it's going to save upwards.
[00:08:09]
Pull something out of here. Oh look.
It's going to save a trillion.
2 trillion. 20 trillion.
It doesn't matter what number they use
because it's not true.
Yeah.
It's not even it's
and it's based on nothing.
Okay. Okay.
So then in the Washington Post
you already see a concession.
We quoted the post there, but every other,
article has it at around 5 trillion.
[00:08:28]
I don't know why they magically cut
it down to two and one half trillion.
Right? That's not real.
So they started at 4.5 trillion.
Then they added another
trillion in tax cuts.
Got it up to five and a half.
But as I'm seeing these stories
and it changes because they're going
through committee and it goes through
another revision and another revision.
[00:08:46]
Right.
So I'm saying the collection
of the stories that I've seen is about 5
trillion, that it adds to the deficit
and the debt over ten years.
Okay, so that's real.
That's the real number.
So how does this, end?
[00:09:02]
In the,
in terms of what actually gets passed?
Right.
Well, at the end, they'll make a big show
of doing a concession like.
All right, well, we didn't want to do it.
I mean, the Republicans love Medicaid,
an average guy.
We do. Our hearts go out to you.
[00:09:18]
But we didn't have a choice because
of these Freedom Caucus, party folks.
We had to cut from the average guy more.
Okay, so now your kids
won't have Medicaid,
and if they have cancer, they'll die.
But no big deal. Don't worry.
[00:09:33]
The rich and the corporations
got all of the tax cuts that they wanted.
Now, remember that thing
we were going to tell you about?
Taking away the loopholes and stuff?
We're not doing any of that.
Okay, so and then none of the press
will ask, well, what about the deficit?
You guys claimed it was a deficit problem
and you didn't make
[00:09:50]
the deficit situation any better.
You cut in.
Let's say you cut another 200 billion
from Medicaid, which would be devastating
to the people who get Medicaid.
But then you're left with $4.8
trillion hole in the deficit.
So what difference does it make?
And it makes no difference.
And you can't square that math.
[00:10:05]
There isn't 5 trillion to cut right.
So that's why they play this soap opera
every single time.
No one tells you how it's going to end.
I'm telling you how it's going to end.
The only reason why this one might be
a little bit different is because things
are so crazy now, with Trump proposing
tax cuts that aren't just for the rich.
[00:10:25]
So that's a little bit of a curve ball.
And my guess is that one of
the concessions at the end to the Freedom
Caucus that just won't vote for it,
there's nothing we can do
is they'll take away one of the tax cuts
[00:10:40]
for the middle class and keep ones
for the rich and for corporations.
And nobody's talking about what it was
that moved these people over the weekend
to, to change their vote to present.
Right. And they don't have to.
I mean, there could have been promises
made on bills in in the future, right?
[00:10:58]
We'll definitely build that base
in your district or we'll definitely
open this, you know, this research
facility in your district, but
this doesn't seem like it's about that.
Obviously, this seems like
it is really about further cuts.
And, you know, one of the one
of the dangers here
[00:11:14]
is that there are moderate Republicans.
I love that it's an oxymoron.
It's like morning
starting the ending the day.
Moderate Republicans are
are saying that they don't want these.
They want a larger cap on salt,
which in salt are state and local taxes.
[00:11:32]
So it's a deduction that you can take
on state and local taxes that that goes
back to the 2017 Trump tax bill.
And so that those deductions
are capped at 10,000.
This bill has them at 30,000.
And there are Republicans
in New York and California
[00:11:48]
who are saying that's not enough.
We need to be able to deduct more
than 30,000, or we're not going
to be on board with this bill too.
So there are other changes
that are being required of people who are
not on the committee, but but rank and
file Republicans who are going to end up
voting on this when it gets to the floor.
[00:12:03]
The speaker has a lot of work to do
on both ends of the spectrum with with his
party, not to mention Moody's cutting the,
the, the, the credit rating
of the United States from Triple-A to Aa1
because there's too much debt.
[00:12:19]
So if this creates even more deficit here,
it's bad for the markets.
The markets are are are
struggling now because of that.
Yeah. Well yes and no.
So yes. So that part is true Michael.
But two things can be true
at the same time.
At the same time,
those corporations are like, ooh,
[00:12:36]
our taxes are going to cut down to 15%.
That's literally
the bare minimum worldwide, right?
There's a worldwide rule
that all the countries agree to,
or 15% is the bare, bare minimum
for corporate for corporate taxes.
So the corporations and Wall Street
are like, yummy for my tummy.
[00:12:55]
We're going to steal from the middle class
and give it
to corporate executives like me.
Well, they love that part.
So on the other hand, yeah, if you're
running a 36, $37 trillion dollar debt
and you're going to add 5 trillion
on top of that, that's not good news.
[00:13:11]
Yeah, right.
The cost of it
increases the cost of doing business.
Yes.
So now last things are telling you
about how full of crap each wing
of the Republican Party is.
So the so-called moderates,
which means just means
that they're in purple districts.
[00:13:26]
It doesn't mean
that they're moderate at all.
They do the play acting
of huffing and puffing about, Medicaid.
They mean it on salt
because that affects their donor class
who will have nice houses.
But on Medicaid they're like,
oh golly gee, do not cut Medicaid.
I am such a moderate.
[00:13:42]
Wink. And why do I say that?
Because it's literally
in the news stories they say, although
they have signaled already that they are
willing to go along with those cuts.
So then it's totally fake.
100% fake, right?
Now go to the, Freedom Caucus, guys.
Oh, we are the true principled
conservatives.
[00:13:58]
- Wow.
- Dat dat dat dat dat dat dat.
- We always talk about debt and deficits.
- You're so full of crap.
They're all going to vote
for the $5 trillion hole in the debt.
And then they're going to say,
oh, well, we thought we were going
to trickle all over you.
And then magically, it would sprout out
trillions of extra dollars in revenue.
[00:14:15]
That's what we've been lying about.
I've been saying for the last 50 years,
it's never been true.
It's empirically not true.
It's the worst economic model there is.
But, hey, all of our donors want it.
Oops. Did I let that slip out?
I'm a principled conservative.
I'm really worried
about debt and deficits.
My ass, you are.
[00:14:31]
I have never seen them
care about the debt.
Ever, ever, ever.
All of those so-called conservative,
principled Republicans,
all they ever do is vote for those taxes.
They're the ones that created
this deficit in the first place.
They're the ones who created
this debt in the first place,
with their earlier trillions of dollars
in tax cuts for the rich.
[00:14:48]
I don't know when Republican voters
are going to figure out
these are the most fake populists
you'll ever meet in your life.
They're all just sophisticated actors
who are just working for the donor class.
If any of them meant it,
they would obviously vote no on this bill
[00:15:04]
that is going to create a massive deficit.
Massive. But they don't care.
Not one of them. Maybe.
Massie. Maybe.
But I don't even believe him. Okay.
Not on this one.
Every Republican at the end goes.
Of course, sir, the donor class
must get all the money.
[00:15:21]
Corporations must get all the money.
I'm a populist, my ass. You are?
Well, they're populists
are the corporations.
So in their minds,
they're populist among the corporations,
which is their populists.
I can't wait for that one of them
to make that point.
[00:15:36]
No, no, no, no, I was real populist.
I was so popular
among all of the corporate CEOs.
They love me.
Every time you ring the bell below,
an angel gets his wings.
Totally not true.
But it does keep you updated
on our live shows.
Now Playing (Clips)
Episode
Podcast
The Young Turks: May 19, 2025
- 21 minutes
- 19 minutes
- 7 minutes
- 9 minutes
- 15 minutes
- 10 minutes
- 7 minutes
- 26 minutes