May 16, 2025
Trump's “Big Beautiful Bill” Could Be In BIG Trouble
Sen. Ron Johnson and other notable Republicans are speaking up against President Trump’s "big beautiful bill."
- 15 minutes
Senator, what do you need to see
in this bill to be on board?
The problem is,
is it's asking conservatives like myself
to raise the debt ceiling $5 trillion.
That's a that's historic.
No one has ever raised
the debt ceiling that much.
It's not beautiful. I'm sorry.
[00:00:16]
It's not a big, beautiful bill.
That's called rhetoric.
There's one thing mislabeling.
There's one thing
that really started rising.
So right there, you have two
Republican senators who are, at least
as of right now, against Donald Trump's
big, beautiful bill, although at least one
of them seems to be a little bit confused.
[00:00:33]
Paul right there was talking about how
they shouldn't raise the national debt.
He seems to think Democrats are in charge
because that's generally the only time
they actually care about that.
But I appreciate
the consistency in this case.
In any event,
the bill faced a major hurdle today.
Conversation on it is done for the week,
and both senators and some
[00:00:52]
Republican representatives seem to have
some major misgivings about this bill.
Jake, we're going to dive into all of it.
But what do you think is leading
to the fact that they're so willing
to push back against him.
Yeah.
So there's something
super strange going on.
We'll solve it over the next couple of
weeks, but I've literally never seen this.
[00:01:10]
Those are two Republican senators
arguing against a tax cut for the rich.
Kind of for the moment being.
But again, over 25 years
of covering American politics,
I have never, ever seen a Republican
be against a tax cut for Rich.
[00:01:27]
So in this case, they're this is
unresolvable because they want to give
away at least 5 trillion to the rich, but
they don't have that much money to cut.
So that means they're going
to put a huge hole in the debt
and they're going to make it much worse.
Normally what Republicans do is,
oh, there is no debt.
[00:01:47]
Not when we're in charge.
And the tax cuts
will magically create revenue.
They won't take away revenue.
They just lie through their teeth.
They don't actually care
about balancing budgets or anything.
So in this situation,
we've got something super weird going on,
which is where Republicans are saying,
yeah, this will add to the debt.
[00:02:06]
And so are we.
Sure we should do massive
multi-trillion-dollar tax cuts?
I've never seen it before,
so I can't explain it.
- This is a new phenomenon.
- Yeah, yeah.
And so their problem seems
to be on the it costing too much side.
And then we will get to there are
some Republicans that are on the we're
[00:02:22]
cutting too much side in terms of Medicaid
and others who grotesquely
actually want to cut more.
So we're going to get to all of that.
But before we jump to the house,
let's have a little bit more
from the senators about their problem.
It will be a record for Congress
to raise the debt $5 trillion,
[00:02:37]
but also it indicates that this year, the
debt, the deficit will be over 2 trillion.
But it means they're anticipating
close to 3 trillion for the next year.
It's really a slap in the face that those
of us who are excited about Elon Musk and
Doge and all the cuts, where are the cuts?
[00:02:53]
If the cuts are real,
why are we going to borrow 5 trillion?
If you raise it 5 trillion for two years,
you just put it on the back burner.
But we're going to coast through that
money and we're going to spend it all.
And that's not what the people want.
That's not what our supporters want.
This is not serious.
It's exacerbating the problem.
[00:03:09]
It's not solving it.
I've got a great video on my page,
all our Republican leaders saying
we don't have a revenue problem,
we have a spending problem.
And this bill is primarily about tax cuts.
We can't afford to cut taxes
when we're running over $2 trillion a year
[00:03:24]
deficits for the next ten years.
As far as the eye can see.
The only correction I would make to that
is that they also are likely
to have a major revenue problem,
because some estimates say
that the massive cuts to the IRS could
generate up to $500 billion less in taxes.
[00:03:40]
That's the estimates that I've seen.
That remains to be seen.
We need to figure out
what actually happens.
But that's the Senate over in the House.
They did their first vote at the committee
level on this bill, and it actually failed
in the House Budget Committee.
Republicans Chip Roy, Ralph Norman,
Andrew Clyde, Josh Brecheen joined
[00:03:58]
the Democrats to vote down the bill.
And so, at least for now,
it has actually failed.
Now, there are some Republicans who've
been saying this cuts Medicaid too much.
We're worried about
the political ramifications of that.
Cuts to Medicaid,
by the way, are universally reviled.
A majority of Republicans
are against them,
[00:04:15]
let alone independents and Democrats.
But that's not actually why these
particular Republicans voted against it.
This really, I think, crystallizes
the problem that Mike Johnson has,
that you have those
who are worried about it going too far,
and then you have this group
that think that it doesn't go far enough.
[00:04:30]
And they have a variety
of different concerns.
But here are a few of them.
One says they want to speed up
the phaseout of clean energy tax credits
enacted under Joe Biden,
because we want to really cook
this planet as fast as possible.
Immediately remove immigrants
in the country illegally from any Medicaid
[00:04:48]
access, rather than allowing states
several years to comply and moving up the
Medicaid work requirement start date.
So rather than giving states
four years to phase this in,
make it immediate so that the estimated
9 to 14.5 million people who will be
[00:05:04]
thrown off of Medicaid thanks to this,
can be thrown off as soon as possible.
Don't let them suck off the teat
of the government for a couple more years.
Throw them out in the streets immediately.
Let them start to get sick.
Let them start to die.
Millions and millions of them
being Trump voters.
[00:05:19]
Make that immediate.
Really make the cruelty
as fast as possible.
Anyway, you can see I'm not
a big fan of the bill,
but anyway, it is suffering a little bit.
- What do you think?
- Yeah.
So the polling is going to show you here
why the Republicans
[00:05:35]
have an unsolvable riddle.
Okay.
So we're going to get to that in a second.
First of all,
is this really cutting Medicaid?
Yeah. 10 million people
are going to be cut off the rolls.
Now, think about the paradox
they're setting up here.
[00:05:51]
They're saying, well, we understand
you might need Medicaid sometimes.
And so that's that's
why we have the program.
But you know what?
We've got to make sure, though,
that you're, you know, going to work
and trying your hardest
because we don't want any giveaways.
All right.
Maybe that sounds reasonable to you.
Right.
[00:06:07]
And I think in some circumstances,
you know, I would say, yeah,
after a certain amount of time, etc.,
on some government programs,
but on Medicaid, the whole point is,
if you can't afford health care,
we don't want you to die.
Right.
So that's about healthcare.
It's not about anything else.
[00:06:24]
So and that's that's absolutely critical.
They say now you've got to go get a job.
Now the thing is, in one of the provisions
here, if you get over $15,000,
they start cutting your Medicaid
$15,000 a year is minimum wage.
So if you get a job,
they kick you off Medicaid.
[00:06:39]
If you don't have a job,
they kick you off Medicaid.
- It's a perfect system.
- Yeah.
You know, because you know why?
Because they don't give a damn about you.
They just care about the rich.
So that's why that what Ron Johnson,
Rand Paul did
this similar line that they usually do.
[00:06:55]
Well, the real problem is the cuts we
haven't cut from the American people
enough to give to my rich donors yet.
They're still, you know,
stuffing their mouths.
And we need to give them
a nice big buffet.
So we're going to take it
from the, you know, most needy.
So Rand Paul is like,
he's complaining about the debt,
[00:07:10]
but he'll shut up later and he'll pretend
that the tax cuts don't create debt.
That's my guess. That's what they do.
Like literally 100%
of the time until today.
Ron Johnson,
maybe he's just a knucklehead.
You know, he's not that bright.
Maybe he slipped up and said,
oh, the tax cuts are too large.
He's not supposed to say that.
[00:07:26]
He's supposed to say,
oh, no, the tax cuts are great.
They will create revenue magically.
They will trickle on you later. Ha ha.
Okay. But he's not saying that.
So that's why I'm
totally surprised by that.
But the rest of the Republicans,
as usual, they didn't change at all.
You think they're more populist?
No, they're not populist.
[00:07:44]
You think that they're like,
it made any difference at all?
No. Like so for Trump,
you can make an argument that he is really
trying for peace negotiations.
You can make a counterargument. Right.
But it's debatable
on Republicans in Congress.
[00:08:01]
In my lifetime, including now, with the
exception of that one Ron Johnson clip,
it has been 100% of the time where they
say, yeah, no, everything for the rich,
the biggest tax cuts you can imagine.
And how do we get to the $37 trillion
in debt, largely through tax cuts
[00:08:16]
for the rich and for corporations?
That was the number one reason
spending was number two.
Number one is we just keep
giving them massive,
massive multi-trillion dollar tax cuts.
You know how much Trump put
on the debt last time he was in office.
[00:08:31]
Just four years, $8 trillion,
the most of any president in history.
Now, does the American people know
that it gets so frustrated because both
mainstream media and the Democratic Party.
Why didn't you talk about how Trump
added 8 trillion to the debt?
[00:08:46]
Why didn't you say that every single time
this idiot added 8 trillion to the debt,
eight out of the 37
out of our entire history
by this Like moron who can't do math,
and who's so greedy
he gave himself a whole bunch of tax cuts
[00:09:03]
and all of his rich friends, a whole bunch
of tax cuts and just piled onto the debt.
The Democrats instead went, and why?
Because secretly,
that goes to our donors, too.
Otherwise you'd fight back.
[00:09:20]
And mainstream media is like,
well, Republicans say this, that,
$5 trillion in tax cuts magically creates
revenue instead of costing revenue.
And the Democrats say so.
The Republicans are right.
No, there are actual facts.
So we're going to get to more here
in a second,
[00:09:36]
including the polling that's so important.
But is it a medicaid cut? Yes.
And my guess is what they're going to do
is what they do every single time,
which is they'll get to the finish line.
There'll be a lot of fighting,
some will be real and some will be fake.
And then at the end,
they'll go, screw the deficit.
[00:09:53]
Let's give the rich everything.
They're not going to cut, cut, cut.
They're going to make the deficit lower.
No way.
They're going to make
the deficit much higher.
And that's because they can't wait
to pay back the bribes that all
[00:10:10]
the rich people gave them to get elected.
Mus.
Well, Jake, tariffs are going
to pay for all this.
What are you talking about?
All the tariffs that have been canceled.
Right.
Exactly.
You know, first of all,
the national debt, $37 trillion.
And I like it. I like the national.
[00:10:27]
I love the national debt because it
makes me feel good about my own debt.
So that's one thing to keep in mind.
Like, why should we get
rid of the national debt?
Every time I get my credit card bill
end of the month and I'm like,
how much did I spend?
And I go, well, this is not 37 trillion.
So there's that if you're looking
for silver lining, but it's amazing
[00:10:44]
how much they're bending over backwards
to find ways to be able to excuse this tax
cut they're about to give themselves.
And it's interesting how the word cut is
used for poor for the poor to cut their
programs and benefits, and for the rich.
[00:11:01]
It's used to cut their taxes.
And it's crazy where they're
saying with the tariffs,
they're going to bring money in.
Doge was supposed to cut money.
Remember Elon Musk famously said,
I'm going to cut 2 or $3 trillion
in that rally that he was on stage with.
I'm going to cut trillions of dollars.
They're not.
[00:11:17]
They're nowhere close
to cutting that much.
And the programs they cut
are programs that benefit us.
And we need, like USAID
and other programs that were helping us.
And they never look at,
for example, defense.
They never look at defense
because they can't because to your point,
[00:11:33]
there's way too much money going in their
pockets from the defense contractors
and from the defense lobbyists.
And just it's just unbelievable
that anyone that is on their side,
any constituent that is on their side,
that is not a very wealthy person,
[00:11:49]
is not seeing that they're getting taken
to the cleaners
and that they're coming up with all
of these excuses and all of these,
smoke all this smoke and mirror to make
it look like we have money coming in.
He goes to the Middle East and says,
oh, I'm bringing in whatever $12 trillion
he's throwing these numbers around
so that his constituents will be like,
[00:12:06]
well, he's bringing in money that way.
So, yeah, let's give the rich
another tax break.
It is just unbelievable.
So they're working on the details
of the exact plan now.
But in the first cut of the outline
of the bill, they they did an analysis on
the top 1% was getting what percentage of,
[00:12:25]
of the tax cuts,
let alone the corporate tax cuts, which
goes exclusive to corporate corporations.
Right. Was it like 10%?
Well, maybe because the top 1%
is wealthier, I get it.
If it's 10%, 20%,
well, that would be a pretty
disproportionate 30% would be ridiculous.
[00:12:41]
Yeah, it was 56%. 56% of the cuts
go to the top 1%.
The rich that don't need it at all at all.
And they're going to rob real Americans,
okay, that desperately need health care
when their kids are sick,
they're going to rob them
[00:12:57]
to pay the richest people in the world.
And so this is the great American robbery.
Now, here's a problem.
They have the polling on.
This is disastrous on the Medicaid part
and on the taxes part.
But I'll get back to taxes in a second.
I want to show you, Harry Enten.
And then I'm going to show you a hilarious
Republican, faux pas because of this.
[00:13:16]
But first, look at the polling
that he's pointing out here on CNN.
Major spending cuts to Medicaid.
Look at this. 76% opposed.
You get 95% of Democrats opposed,
79% of independents, and you
even get a majority of Republicans, 55%
[00:13:33]
oppose major spending cuts to Medicaid.
This, simply put, is not popular
on any part of the aisle.
Do you know somebody or you yourself have
ever been on Medicaid or on it currently?
And this I think, basically says
it all has been or is on Medicaid.
Me or someone else close to me.
[00:13:49]
Look at this. 62% of Democrats,
62% of Republicans.
Medicaid is something that touches people
from across the political spectrum,
from the left to the right.
So that's them going after
the average American.
And that's why the average American
is dead set against this three quarters
[00:14:05]
of the country saying don't cut Medicaid.
That's why it was important
for the Republicans
to rebrand this as Medicaid reform.
So let's go to video B3
of Congressman Jason Smith and see
how that rebranding is coming along.
You can look at Medicaid cuts,
Medicaid reforms, I should say.
[00:14:27]
Cut Medicaid reform.
We're just reforming Medicaid.
You know what I'm saying?
We're going to cut, like, at least
10 million people out of the rolls, and
they'll be reformed into probably massive
illnesses and maybe their kids dying.
But hey, to be fair,
the top 1% needed another $5 trillion.
[00:14:43]
So that's the sick thing
that's going on here.
So, at the end of the day,
this is unresolvable.
There is no way to cut that much in taxes
and to balance the budget.
There just isn't enough money.
There isn't 5 trillion
in the budget to cut.
[00:15:00]
And you can't.
Just trying to take it
out of Medicaid is unpopular.
Oh, and last poll for you guys.
You know, at least you know,
tax cuts are very popular.
I've been told by mainstream media my
whole life how popular tax cuts are, and
that's why the Democrats have to go along.
They don't have a choice.
There was nothing they could do.
[00:15:16]
There was nothing they could do. Right.
So let's see if that's true.
Oh, this is from Politico.
So that sounds right. 76% of registered
voters believe the wealthiest Americans
should pay more in taxes.
More so reviewing 76% of Americans say
you should not cut Medicaid,
[00:15:37]
and 76% of Americans say you should tax
the wealthy more so instead, the populist
Republicans will do the exact opposite.
Enjoy.
Every time you ring the bell below,
an angel gets his wings.
Totally not true, but it does
keep you updated on our live shows.
Now Playing (Clips)
Episode
Podcast
The Young Turks
- 25 minutes
- 15 minutes
- 19 minutes
- 18 minutes
- 10 minutes
- 7 minutes