Oct 16, 2024
Here's What Ana Thinks About Trump's Mental Fitness
Former President Donald Trump's mental fitness can appear concerning depending on what clip of him you are watching.
- 23 minutes
That you thought Trump
was showing signs of mental decline.
That's a pretty serious accusation.
The reason Donald Trump
is canceling these interviews is that when
he starts to stumble, he starts to pivot.
He cannot repeat consistently his position
on key issues like the economy,
[00:00:17]
like crime or like immigration
that are key issues to voters.
And that's what you're seeing
in his decline.
We are used to seeing.
Him have a discursive speaking style, but
it has gotten more rambling, it has gotten
more incoherent, and it's gotten longer.
No, I'm just telling you basic.
It's called the weave.
[00:00:34]
I think calling it the weave is PR to try
to explain why he's talking this way.
Is Donald Trump really suffering
from mental decline?
It appears that is the dominant narrative
currently on the left side
[00:00:50]
of the political aisle,
while conservative media is actually
telling a completely different story.
And I really do think
that this is a perfect example of how it
is that Americans, depending on how they
identify politically, really do live in
[00:01:06]
two completely different realities.
This also gives us an opportunity
to look into Donald Trump's
hour long interview just yesterday
with Bloomberg's news editor in chief.
His name is John Micklethwait,
before the Chicago Economics Club.
[00:01:24]
Now, look, one can certainly make
Trump appear as an ADHD addled boomer
who makes little sense, who seems
to be experiencing some cognitive decline.
But it really depends on which portions
of the hour long conversation you pick.
[00:01:41]
And so if you look at this compilation,
he seems unhinged.
He seems like he's suffering
from mental decline.
Take a look.
Should Google be broken up?
I just haven't gotten over something
the Justice Department did yesterday.
[00:01:57]
Where Virginia cleaned up its voter rolls
and got rid of thousands
and thousands of bad votes.
The question is about Google,
President Trump.
Yeah, look, Google's got a lot of power.
They're very bad to me.
If I can finish
yeah I'll go longer if you want.
[00:02:13]
It helps because you got to be able
to you move to the Federal Reserve.
No. You got to be able to finish a thought
because it's very important.
You know, this is big stuff
we're talking about.
You can't go that quickly from the dollar.
So let me just tell you.
So I said no I'm just telling you basic.
[00:02:28]
It's called the weave.
It's all these different things happen.
Gavin Newsom,
he's the governor of California.
Newsom. He signed News.com, I call him.
Yeah.
- But do you do you think?
- No, he corrected me.
He corrected me.
I said,
that's the first time I've been corrected.
There are CEOs out here.
[00:02:44]
If they said those sort of things about a
rival CEO, they would be they'd be sacked.
Do you think it's.
- But they don't.
- Have to survive like me.
They don't have to go through
what I have to go through.
The Mercedes-Benz will start
building in the United States,
and they have a little bit.
But you know what?
They really are Assembly line in South
Carolina, but they build everything
[00:03:02]
in Germany and then they assemble it here.
They get away with murder because they
say, oh yes, we're building cars.
They don't build cars.
They take them out of a box
and they assemble them.
We could have our child do it.
So I watched the entirety of the
interview, and in my opinion, those are
[00:03:18]
the highlights of Trump's worst moments.
I don't think that he comes across as
someone suffering from cognitive decline.
I think he comes across
as someone who is self-absorbed,
obsessed with himself and his grievances,
and he had an opportunity there to talk
about an important potential policy.
[00:03:38]
When he was asked whether he believes
it's a good idea to break up Google
instead of answering the question,
obviously he immediately pivoted to,
you know, election related BS
about how he's being wronged and
how the election is rigged against him.
And quite frankly, I am so sick of him
airing his grievances day in and day out.
[00:03:58]
I get it, There are instances
of people being unfair to him.
There are also instances
of people telling the truth about him
and he doesn't like it.
And so he gets upset about that.
And so what could have actually
been a great interview he managed
[00:04:13]
to destroy by again indulging in his own,
his own personal grievances.
But I don't really get a sense
that he's suffering cognitive decline,
certainly not in the way that Joe Biden
has been suffering cognitive decline.
[00:04:28]
And that's the reason
why he was replaced with Kamala Harris.
Now you have the left side
of the political aisle,
you know, making this argument that,
oh, Trump is old and he is old.
He's four years younger than Biden,
but that's still pretty up there in age.
But you have the left,
like making it seem as though,
[00:04:44]
you know, his cognitive function
is almost synonymous with Biden's.
I don't think that's true.
Then you look at the right side
of the political aisle and you get
a completely different picture.
And we all know that, you know, based
on how algorithms work, based on the type
[00:05:00]
of media that gets recommended to people.
That's really based
on what they've been watching.
Americans really live
in two different bubbles, right?
And so let's check in on the right.
What did Sean Hannity have to say
about Donald Trump's performance?
Former President Donald Trump
absolutely schooled Bloomberg's editor
[00:05:19]
in chief today during a live appearance
at the Economic Club of Chicago.
Despite things getting a little heated
at times, Trump frankly masterfully
navigated the situation, laid out what was
a clear vision for American prosperity.
[00:05:36]
To say that Donald Trump
schooled the individual interviewing him,
I think is a bit much.
However, to be fair, there were some
moments in this conversation
where I feel that Trump did well,
namely on questions about the US economy
and specifically on the issue of tariffs.
[00:05:53]
In fact, he actually surprised me
at how disciplined he was
at these portions of the interview,
and it seems it's because of the fact that
this is an issue he actually cares about.
I mean, I don't think he really cares
about possibly breaking up Google,
which is why he immediately
pivoted to something.
[00:06:08]
He does care about his grievances
in this case, when it comes to tariffs.
He really, really loves tariffs.
I don't think he's
fibbing about that at all.
He pursued the tariffs against China
during his administration.
And so he did weigh in on that
in a detailed way, even with pushback
[00:06:27]
from the Bloomberg News editor in chief.
- So let's take a look at that portion.
- Because I'm a believer in tariffs.
I'm not sure that you are
I don't think you are.
But I congratulate you on your career.
But to me, the most beautiful word
in the dictionary is tariff.
[00:06:45]
And it's my favorite word.
It needs a public relations firm.
The higher the tariff, the more likely it
is to have them come into the country.
Via the tariff, the more you're going to
put on the value of that those goods, the
higher people are going to pay in shops.
[00:07:03]
Ready, the higher the tariff,
the more likely it is that the company
will come into the United States
and build a factory in the United States,
so it doesn't have to pay the tariff.
If I have.
- That will take many, many.
- No. Oh, it will go quickly.
So there's two ways
of looking at a tariff.
[00:07:19]
You can do it as a money making
instrument, or you can do it as something
to get the companies.
Now if you want the companies to come in,
the tariff has to be a lot higher
than 10%, because 10% is not enough.
They're not going to do it for ten,
but you make a 50% tariff,
[00:07:35]
they're going to come in.
So if you notice his demeanor
and the way he's answering the questions
in these portions of the interview,
make clear that, you know,
he's just behaving differently, right?
Like he cares about this issue.
[00:07:51]
He's able to message
about where he stands on this issue.
And, you know, we have talked
about tariffs on this show before.
I'm a little more open toward tariffs.
To be quite frank.
Jonke is not as open as I am on tariffs.
I think that certain tariffs could
actually be beneficial to the US economy.
[00:08:10]
But it's also very true that in the short
term, tariffs could lead to inflation
because the costs will be transferred
over to the consumers.
Now as Trump's theory on tariffs true.
Well look the US has a population
of 333 million people.
[00:08:25]
And that's a lot of consumers
that companies are going
to want to sell products to.
If tariffs are too high,
meaning if companies are exploiting cheap
labor abroad and then as they are,
you know, importing the products here in
the United States, they're forced to pay
[00:08:41]
these super high tariffs.
That could potentially, incentivize plants
and factories to just produce the products
here in the United States,
especially if the US consumers
are not willing to carry the cost
of the increased tariffs.
[00:08:57]
Right.
And so, even Brookings, which is actually
a liberal organization, confessed
that Donald Trump's tariffs in his term,
the ones that he actually implemented,
spurred both job creation
in the United States and it also increased
federal government revenue.
[00:09:16]
So let's take a look at this chart
and I'll explain what we're looking at.
So if you look at the final year
represented in the chart that's 2019.
Brookings states that Trump increased
tariffs on solar panels, washing machines,
steel and aluminum, as well as on
a broad range of products from China.
[00:09:33]
Overall, in 2019, the US government
brought in $79 billion in tariffs, which
is twice the value from two years earlier.
So if you listen to his answer,
he talks about how tariffs can be
thought of as generating revenue.
So that's what happened here when it came
to Trump's tariffs in his first term.
[00:09:53]
But there is a caveat right.
Because keep in mind that the
federal government collects the revenue
from the higher tariffs and then
the costs associated with tariffs, like,
let's say, the company,
you know, making products or manufacturing
products abroad brings those products here
in the United States pays high tariffs.
[00:10:11]
As a result of that, those companies
are going to transfer those costs,
usually to the consumers.
But if the consumers are refusing to pay
for the higher prices, companies are then
going to look for ways to cut their costs
so they can transfer lower prices
to consumers and sell the products.
[00:10:27]
And so Trump's theory is
that the higher tariffs will eventually
persuade these companies to manufacture,
in the United States,
and that that would lead to more
manufacturing jobs here in the US. Now,
when it comes to spurring job creation,
Brookings also had to concede
[00:10:45]
that Trump was correct
in implementing tariffs on imported steel,
because that did increase
manufacturing jobs in the US,
that specific tariff, they write.
The tariffs on steel products appear to
have helped create several thousand jobs
[00:11:01]
in the steel industry.
Similarly, tariffs on washing machines
are associated with approximately
1800 new jobs at whirlpool, Samsung
and LG factories in the United States.
In these specific industries,
then, tariffs have
[00:11:16]
probably been good for workers.
Now, the problem with Trump
is his form of communication,
because he really is all over the place.
He goes off on tangents as he's
in the middle of talking about something,
or trying to make a concise statement
about something related to the economy.
[00:11:33]
And honestly, when it came to the portion
of the interview where he's talking
about steel, that's kind of what happened.
Let's take a look.
I had a lot to do with steel.
We were going to lose all our steel
companies because China, as you remember,
was dumping steel at levels
that nobody's ever seen before.
And I put a 50% tax on that
and a tariff on that.
[00:11:53]
All dumped steel.
And it was also bad steel.
It was what they call dirty steel.
It wasn't good steel, which is a bad thing
for structural components of buildings
and planes and things like that.
They were dumping crap
into our country and I put a 50% tariff.
[00:12:09]
I started at 25. I raised it to 50
because the 25 didn't quite do it.
I raised it to 50 and that did it.
They stopped dumping steel
and I saved our steel mills.
By having that. We saved it.
We saved our steel.
Now what was left?
Because we've lost so much.
[00:12:25]
But there are certain companies
you have to have.
There are certain things
you have to have steel.
You have to have.
If you go to war, you know there's
a possibility you go to war.
I kept us out of war.
I was the only president in 82 years
that kept you out of a war.
Except I defeated ISIS,
but I inherited that one.
[00:12:42]
There's no wars.
And by the way, by the way.
And I think it's very important we can go.
You know, I call it the weave.
You can call it.
It's got you have the weave.
As long as you end up
in the right location at the end.
No, no. Stop weaving, stop weaving.
You were talking about steel,
and he was about to make a point
[00:13:01]
about how it's important for the United
States to manufacture steel products
here on, on our soil
because of national security concerns.
That was the argument
he was about to make.
But before he even made that argument,
his mind immediately wandered off
[00:13:16]
to I didn't start any new wars.
I didn't start any new wars, even though I
ripped up the Iran nuclear deal.
You know, I moved the US embassy
to Jerusalem,
which could have at that moment led to a
war between Israelis and Palestinians.
[00:13:32]
Obviously, the Iran nuclear deal
being destroyed by Trump led to Iran being
able to continue with a nuclear program.
Like, now.
I'm going off on a tangent,
but my point is,
he's not a good communicator
because his mind wanders and it's almost
[00:13:48]
like this stream of consciousness
that's Hindered by wanting to put out
like a concise, clear message.
And so I think that's what he's getting
hit by in terms of his detractors, I don't
[00:14:05]
think it's a sign of cognitive decline.
Obviously, you know,
he's able to reference things that he did
accomplish during his term in office.
He sometimes gets very specific
and detail oriented with it
during the same interview.
So I don't think it's cognitive decline.
I just think he's a poor communicator.
[00:14:23]
But in regard to Trump's tariffs,
Brookings also argues that many workers
employed in factories used imported goods
in their production processes,
and when these imports increase in cost
due to tariffs, it harms their production,
often leading to job losses.
[00:14:40]
That actually is a legitimate
concern of high tariffs.
But we also need to be fair
because jobs actually rose under Trump
prior to the coronavirus pandemic,
leading to shutdowns and job losses.
Right?
So the rise prior to the coronavirus
pandemic, in terms of manufacturing jobs
[00:14:59]
was about 450,000 manufacturing jobs.
So the way he implemented the tariffs
in his term wasn't as disastrous
as everyone predicted they would be.
He's now throwing out some pretty crazy
numbers in regard to the types of tariffs
[00:15:16]
that he would add on
that do sound a bit much,
but I just wanted to point out
that portion of the conversation,
because I think it was a good example
of him showing that he's not necessarily
suffering cognitive decline.
It's just that he's a poor communicator.
[00:15:32]
Now, what did the Biden administration do
once Biden was elected, inaugurated
and able to lead the country?
Did he do away with the tariffs?
No. In fact, by the end of 2022, the Biden
administration was blocking exports
of advanced manufacturing equipment
and semiconductors to Beijing
[00:15:50]
while revving up US manufacturing,
Facturing, which, by the way,
I gave Biden a lot of credit for.
I thought that was a good move.
You know, when it comes to the Chips act,
developing and manufacturing the chips
here in the United States
is important and a good thing to do.
[00:16:07]
Foreign policy
continues to write that in many ways.
That was a continuation of the Trump
policy of seeking to deny advanced chips
to Chinese companies blocking Huawei
technologies
from cornering the global market
for 5G telecommunications and wooing
Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co,
[00:16:26]
a global leader in the technology
industry, to build semiconductor factories
in the United States.
And then finally, Biden won congressional
approval to spend as much as $600 billion
in the coming years to subsidize companies
that build factories domestically
[00:16:43]
to make semiconductors,
electric vehicles, electric batteries
and other green technologies.
I give you this information because Biden
saw that Trump did something that was
actually working, and he expanded on it.
And Biden deserves credit for that.
He absolutely does.
Finally, Trump bragged about
how he negotiated with Boeing
[00:17:03]
to significantly lower the price of
remodeling two planes that were supposed
to serve as the new Air Force One.
So let's take a look
at that portion of the interview.
When I first sat down,
a general came into my office
and he said, sir, it's nice to meet you.
[00:17:20]
Would you please sign this?
I said, what is it?
It's a contract for a new Air Force One,
which is actually two planes,
not one two Boeing 747.
And I said, how much is it? $5.7 billion.
It's a hell of an expensive plane.
But there's reasons for that.
[00:17:35]
And he said, nope, I'm not signing it.
I met with the head of Boeing.
Wait, Dennis.
I said, Dennis, you've got to have
a three. 5.7 is too much. 5.7 billion.
He said the most I'll take off
is $400 million.
I said, well,
that's not bad for one conversation.
[00:17:51]
So he Got it down.
I said, nope, I'm not accepting.
Then he took off two more.
Then he took off.
Anyway, two months went by.
Three months went by.
I thought we blew the deal
and I was okay with me.
I didn't care calls back said sir.
3,999,000,009.9999
[00:18:10]
and $0.99.
One penny above below $4 billion.
So I said, you got yourself a deal.
And when I heard that portion
of the interview, I'm going
to just be honest about my own biases.
I didn't believe him. I'm like that.
[00:18:26]
He loves to brag about being
a great deal maker.
There's no way this happened.
I'm not buying it at all.
So I did fact check it and was pretty
shocked to find Boeing's deal for Air
Force One, which was cut by then CEO.
He remembered the guy's name.
Dennis Muilenburg requires the company,
not the federal government, to eat
[00:18:46]
the cost of any overruns on the contract.
Boeing reported a net loss of $1.2 billion
for the first quarter of 2022, when a
charge of 660 $660 million associated with
delays and higher costs for Air Force,
[00:19:01]
for the Air Force One program.
So not only did Trump cut the cost to the
US taxpayer for remodeling these planes,
he also cut a deal to ensure
that if there are any delays,
Boeing pays for those delays rather than
the US taxpayer or the US government.
[00:19:20]
So he deserves credit there.
But I give you that example,
because what he just relayed to the public
is not, in my opinion, an example of
someone suffering from cognitive decline.
So I just think media that's true.
[00:19:35]
Look, political figures obviously
are going to try to find some narrative.
They're going to orchestrate it
in order to hurt him politically.
But I think it's far more effective
to hit Trump on things that are real.
Okay.
Donald Trump talking about,
you know, retaliation
[00:19:52]
against his political opponents,
what Donald Trump has done
in regard to overturning Roe v Wade
and the real world impacts that has had
on real human beings across this country.
Okay.
The fact that he still today refuses
to drop the fact that he did lose
[00:20:13]
the 2020 presidential election,
and he did try to overturn the election,
not simply with a Capitol riot,
but with a fake electors plot.
He is a target rich environment,
and what the media is doing when they put
out these false narratives is they
end up losing trust among the public.
[00:20:33]
Gallup just put out their latest poll
on media Trust in America,
and it is literally at an all time low.
The last time it hit a record was in 2016,
when about 36% of Americans
said that they trust the media.
Now it's down to 32%,
and that's a problem, because if you have
[00:20:50]
a voter base that doesn't trust the press,
well, then that creates openings
for nefarious actors to put out all
sorts of disinformation misinformation.
You can't have a well-functioning
democracy if a the media isn't doing its
[00:21:05]
job in accurately informing the public
about the candidates and what they're
offering and what their downfalls are.
And it's also going to lead to, you know,
conspiracy theories and all sorts
of nefarious so-called news sources being
[00:21:23]
more trusted by the public than sources
that would actually do a better job
because they have resources
and the ability to do a better job
in covering the news.
And the other thing that drives me
crazy is, and by the way, that's not
just a comment on left wing media.
That's a comment on media.
[00:21:39]
Overall, the right wing
provides cover for his foibles.
The left wing sometimes makes things up
when they don't really need to.
There's a lot of real world things
that they can attack him on.
And my biggest issue is, since you have
these two sides and you have
[00:21:55]
this media bubble situation happening, you
have an electorate that's totally split.
Because everyone lives
in a completely different reality.
Everyone's getting different information.
That's not necessarily accurate at all.
[00:22:10]
Now, I should also note, while Trump saved
the federal government a little bit of
money when it came to remodeling Air Force
One, let's not forget that he increased
this country's debt by 33%.
Okay.
[00:22:25]
He increased the debt
to the tune of $8.4 trillion.
He borrowed $8.4 trillion
during his administration.
So $1,000,000,000,000 trillion,
that's a lot of money.
So for the deficit hawks,
for those who are concerned about debt,
[00:22:42]
he wasn't really great when it came
to lowering debt or doing anything about
the deficit here in the US. But again,
the fact that Trump remembered
the minute details of a deal that he made
with Boeing over Air Force One,
to me provides an example
that he's not suffering from
[00:23:00]
the same cognitive decline that Biden was,
but he is suffering from all sorts of
declines when it comes to quality of life
for Americans as a result of his policies,
some of his policies.
And I think that is where Democrats
should be focusing.
[00:23:16]
They're going to lose trust among
the electorate if they make things up.
And so, again, the cognitive decline
thing, I think is a pretty weak argument.
But I do think that if you want to focus
on some of the terrible things he's done,
there's a lot to choose from.
So just be honest about it
and report accurately about what he
[00:23:34]
did right and what he did wrong.
It's that simple.
If you enjoyed this video,
that's because of our members.
They make us independent.
They make us strong,
and they make us honest.
Become a member today
by hitting the join button below.
Now Playing (Clips)
Episode
Podcast
The Young Turks: October 16, 2024
Hosts: Cenk UygurAna Kasparian
- 23 minutes
- 14 minutes
- 14 minutes
- 10 minutes
- 12 minutes
- 10 minutes
- 12 minutes