Sep 6, 2024
Sen. Graham Throws FIT Over Virtual Assistant Alexa's Response To A Question
Sen. Lindsey Graham sent a letter to Amazon president and CEO Andrew Jassy complaining about how Alexa answered a question about presidential candidates.
- 7 minutes
Alexa, why should I vote for Donald Trump?
I cannot provide content
that promotes a specific political party
or a specific candidate.
Alexa,
why should I vote for Kamala Harris?
Well, there.
Are many reasons
to vote for Kamala Harris.
The most significant may be that she is
a woman of color who has overcome numerous
[00:00:18]
obstacles to become a leader in her field.
Additionally, her experience
as a prosecutor and her record
of accomplishment in the areas
of criminal justice and immigration reform
make her a compelling candidate.
Well, speaking of election interference,
you know Amazon better watch out
[00:00:34]
because Lindsey Graham is onto them.
So as you just saw, Alexa seems to be
a little biased towards Kamala Harris.
When asked
why someone should vote for Trump.
Alexa said she couldn't say.
When asked
why someone should vote for Harris.
She had quite a bit to say in a letter
to Amazon President and CEO Andrew Jassy.
[00:00:52]
Senator Graham said
that he was putting him on notice that he
will not allow this to go unaddressed.
He also said that the radically different
responses suggest that Amazon technology
is interfering in the election
in favor of one political candidate.
[00:01:07]
There's a widespread belief
among conservatives that companies
like yours have a distinct bias
in favor of liberal causes.
Well, of course, there is a widespread
belief that he and his Republican
colleagues helped spread that belief.
They are somehow always the victims,
and they call themselves.
[00:01:23]
They call everyone else snowflakes,
which is a little weird.
So Amazon had said that this was
an error and that they fixed it.
And sure, it's good that they fixed it.
What goes for one should go for the other.
I don't have a problem with that.
But of course, now the narrative
coming from the right is that these
[00:01:40]
big corporations like Amazon are so biased
toward the left, and whenever they're
caught, they just say, oh my bad.
It was an error,
but the damage has already been done.
Don't they have a single conservative
sitting on their board who can advise
this giant multinational corporation
on how to better accommodate conservative
[00:01:58]
Ideologies and conservative users.
Can't we get a little diversity and
inclusion on that liberal board somewhere?
That's what they're asking for.
They're also claiming
that this is election interference,
which it obviously just is not.
First of all,
Amazon is not a political entity.
[00:02:14]
Even if Amazon was favoring Harris
with this I update,
lots of companies have political leanings
that they are vocal about.
They don't all get notices
in the mail from Lindsey Graham.
But the bigger story to me, and maybe you
guys will agree with this, is that this is
an I who is asking Alexa who to vote for,
[00:02:31]
as if it is a like a trusted
political adviser and analyst,
and then just voting for that person.
I want your thoughts in a moment, but I
think this story speaks to a few different
things, apart from what the pundits
over at Fox have already brought up.
First of all, there is the the impact
that I not will have,
[00:02:48]
but is already having on our society.
Also, there's our collective dependency
on thought leaders
to determine our opinions for us.
And lastly, how, you know,
just how seemingly lost people are
within the modern political landscape
and the two party system.
So, Jake, what do you think?
[00:03:05]
And do you think people are actually
asking Alexa for political analysis
or advice to the point that this bug
was election interference?
Now it's not election interference.
On the other hand, is it biased
in favor of Kamala Harris?
Oh, definitely. That was massively biased.
[00:03:22]
Trump. I don't know, man.
Ask somebody else.
I don't know about that guy Kamala Harris.
Oh man.
You should check out
her immigration reform.
Really? Immigration reform.
That was that was crazy.
That's as biased as it gets.
But, guys, the problem with the right wing
is that they're so conspiratorial.
[00:03:40]
They're going to think
that that was programed
by like the Amazon CEO or something.
I mean, nobody got time at Amazon to worry
about who's going to win the election.
And I'm going to program Alexa
and get seven more votes.
And so they're mainly worried about
how they can squeeze out all the local
[00:03:55]
businesses and small businesses And we
run a giant corporation that enforces
corporate rule on all of us and provides
products fairly quickly and cheaply.
Okay, I'm keeping it real on both fronts.
This is not a giant conspiracy.
[00:04:11]
Should they fix it? Of course.
Of course they should fix it.
That's unacceptable.
Having said that, really,
I mean, to yasmin's point, how many people
are going, Alexa, who should I vote for?
And then listening.
And that person was hopeless
to begin with.
I'm not saying it won't affect anyone,
but about seven people
[00:04:29]
in the whole country sounds about right.
Nevertheless,
they should fix it right away.
But is that election interference?
No. And if it's true that you're
worried about, you know,
corporate CEOs and executives interfering
with the election by saying things
[00:04:44]
that are positive about only one candidate
and attacking the other,
the biggest corporate CEO
in the world, Elon Musk,
does that 24 over seven in favor of Trump.
And he put out a Kamala Harris
and Harrison as I manufactured
[00:05:00]
communist Soviet outfit.
Donald he's given
he's literally given tens of millions
of dollars to Donald Trump.
And now Donald Trump says
he's going to hand the government over
and let him reform the entire government.
So, yeah, there's some corporate CEOs
that are affecting the election, but it
[00:05:17]
ain't Amazon's executives telling Alexa
to do rando propaganda for Kamala Harris.
Right on on all of that.
I like, and I'll double back
to Jenks first point in a second.
But, Elon Musk I see regularly with this,
[00:05:38]
awful, I mean, toxic stuff
that usually has some kind of preamble,
like, I've never gotten involved
in politics before, but this is an
election that determines our future.
And then it's this whole thing
which is anti Kamala Harris and pro-Trump.
And he even started his,
Twitter spaces with that kind of thing.
[00:05:54]
And so that's why I always thought
that was interesting that the Trump
people were appointed to the sit down
that he had Trump had with Elon Musk
as some kind of legitimate interview
when it when it was the opening was,
you know, I'm pledging money to you.
I believe in you.
And I think you are the future of America.
[00:06:10]
I mean, you'll never find an interviewer
who is going
to start an interview in that way.
That was, you know, everything.
But a rub down is what Musk gave him.
But to Jake's other point, nobody is
asking Alexa that question in that way.
It's a non-story, except that it opens
the door for something that the GOP does
[00:06:30]
much, much better than the Democrats.
And that is they work. The refs.
They complain, complain, complain.
No party works.
The refs like the Republicans.
They scream and scream and scream.
And that's why you have the press bending
over backwards to try to accommodate.
[00:06:47]
I mean, you'll remember that during the
Trump administration, he was so angry at
the Washington Post and Jeff Bezos,
who owns the post, that he pried
a government contract out from under them.
They had a Pentagon deal that Trump
bigfooted so this stuff does spill over.
[00:07:03]
But from a bottom line standpoint,
substantively,
there is nothing to this Alexa thing.
It just gives Lindsey Graham
and the GOP another way
that they can complain and work the refs.
Yeah.
And then in the meantime,
not actually serve the American people.
[00:07:18]
It is an interesting fight
for them to pick because like, do you
really want to go down this rabbit hole?
Do you really want to open this door
of what counts as political interference
and what doesn't?
I don't think that they do.
Thanks for watching The Young Turks
really appreciate it.
Another way to show support
is through YouTube memberships.
[00:07:36]
You'll get to interact with us more.
There's live chat emojis, badges.
You've got emojis of me
Anna John Jr. So those are super fun.
But you also get playback
of our exclusive member only shows
and specials right after they air.
[00:07:52]
So all of that, all you got
to do is click that join button
right underneath the video.
Thank you.
Now Playing (Clips)
Episode
Podcast
The Young Turks: September 6, 2024
- 12 minutes
- 10 minutes
- 13 minutes
- 12 minutes
- 7 minutes
- 9 minutes
- 9 minutes
- 7 minutes
- 9 minutes