Nov 7, 2023
Roger Waters played fast and loose with the facts about the October 7 attack on Israel when he was stating his case with Glenn Greenwald.
- 9 minutes
When the attack on October 7th
in Israel happened from Hamas.
What was your reaction to that?
Let's wait and see what happened.
Well, it was my first reaction.
My second reaction was,
how the hell did the Israelis not know
[00:00:15]
this was going to happen?
And I'm still a little bit down
that rabbit hole.
I mean, didn't didn't the Israeli army
in those 11, 10 or 11 camps
hear the bangs when they blew up?
Whatever they had to blow up
to get across the border?
[00:00:31]
There's something very fishy about that.
Last week, Glenn Greenwald
hosted Pink Floyd's Roger waters
on his Rumble show System Update, and
during the context of that conversation,
waters questioned whether Hamas
even conducted a terrorist attack.
[00:00:47]
Waters floated the theory that Hamas
is deadly terrorist attack on October 7th,
which killed over 1400 Israelis,
according to the Israeli government,
was actually a false flag operation.
Let's watch more of what he has to say
and then obviously give you the reality.
[00:01:05]
What we do know is whether it was
a false flag operation or not or whatever
or whatever happened and whatever story
we're going to get to, and we don't know
if we will ever get much of a real story.
It's very it's always hard to tell
what actually happened.
[00:01:22]
They're calling it their 9/11.
What the hell happened
on the American 9/11?
Nobody knows.
Clearly, the official narrative
has huge holes in it.
So, look, I can understand why there are
so many questions in regard to the IDF
[00:01:40]
and how it took them six hours
to respond to Hamas terrorist attack,
but unfortunately, the answer is pretty
easy once you look into what happened.
Right.
So Netanyahu had been so hyper focused
on the West Bank
[00:01:57]
and protecting the settlers who had built
illegal settlements in the West Bank,
that the IDF, all of the attention
of the IDF was there in that in that area,
not at the border with the Gaza Strip.
And so once the terrorist attacks
happened, it took a long time
[00:02:14]
for IDF soldiers to get to them.
They were too busy providing protection
for settlers, Israeli settlers in the
occupied West Bank as they were helping
them guard their illegal settlements.
So that was what was going on.
I mean, we have some answers.
[00:02:30]
We could talk about it.
I'm actually surprised
that he doesn't know that.
And he's not talking about the failure
of the Israeli government.
Yeah.
So I think guys like this are not helpful
because we're trying to bring attention
to the plight of the people of Gaza
who are being slaughtered right now.
[00:02:45]
And so for the average layman and people
in media, they look at Roger waters
and they think, oh, he's on the left
and he's criticizing Israel.
So he must be part of the critique of,
of Israel.
And so we'll judge the critique based on
what he says, you know, is that exclusive?
[00:03:01]
No, of course not.
But is it partially that.
Yes.
And it makes the critique easier
to dismiss when you say crackpot things
like it's a false flag operation.
Now, there's 1400 dead Israelis.
I think Bibi Netanyahu is a monster,
but there's no way that the rest
[00:03:19]
of the IDF and the Israeli government,
even if Netanyahu was that monstrous,
which I don't think he would do
to his own Israeli citizens.
But even if you thought, okay, Netanyahu
is willing to kill anybody, okay, how is
he going to get everybody else to to
participate and then kill fellow Israelis?
[00:03:36]
It's inconceivable.
Totally, utterly inconceivable. Right.
So and then the idea that that Hamas
only killed Israeli soldiers
but left all the Israeli citizens alone.
Come on.
Absurd, absurd.
So this doesn't help anyone.
All you're doing is muddying the waters,
if you will, and, and and kind
[00:03:56]
of putting a stain on the legitimate
critique of the Israeli government.
Yeah, that's that's exactly right.
And this has been
the most frustrating thing because there
are good honest actors on the left.
Okay.
I think, you know, Crystal ball has
been doing a great job with this story.
[00:04:12]
Kyle Kulinski has been doing
a good job with this story.
And I mention them because they don't make
any, you know, exception when it comes
to civilians on the Israeli side.
Okay?
Innocent civilians should be protected,
should never be targeted.
And what Hamas did
was absolutely brutal, disgusting,
[00:04:30]
and they should be brought to justice.
And I hate when you have the Roger
waters types who say this nonsense
trash, garbage.
Because then well-meaning individuals
who are engaging in accurate critique
of Israel's response to what Hamas did
get lumped in with lunatics who seem
[00:04:51]
to continuously make these points that
devalue the lives of Israeli civilians.
I do not agree with any of that. Okay.
And I do not agree with what Roger
waters says in the next clip.
So let's watch that
and we'll talk about it.
Do you think what Hamas did
on October 7th can be justified?
[00:05:12]
Well, we don't a we don't know
what they did do, but do.
Was it justified for them
to resist the occupation?
Yeah. But again, it's what you said.
It's the Geneva Conventions.
They're absolutely legally and morally
[00:05:28]
bound to resist the occupation since 1967.
It's an obligation.
But are there limits on the way
in which they can resist?
As I said in the in the statement
that I put out after it, I said if war
crimes were committed, I condemn them.
[00:05:44]
But what about targeting civilians
or abducting them?
No, of course, no, of course not.
No, of course I don't condone that.
But that is what Hamas did.
That's exactly what Hamas did.
They targeted civilians.
He knows it. He knows it.
[00:06:00]
He knows it.
You can't pick the facts you like and say,
I'm only going to go and emphasize these,
and I'm just going to either ignore
or lie about the other facts.
So even if you thought Hamas has a right
to resist and, and hence attack
[00:06:15]
the Israeli soldiers that they attacked
and killed you, certainly he claims he
doesn't want them killing the civilians.
Good. I'm happy to hear that.
But then for you to ignore the fact
that they did kill the civilians, that's
awfully convenient for your position.
[00:06:30]
So nobody's angels here and pretending
that they're angels is absurd.
But a lot of Hamas
is fundamentalist Muslims.
And you could say, hey, you know,
after being occupied for 56 years,
blah, blah, blah.
I wouldn't make any excuse for them.
But killing civilians is wrong.
[00:06:45]
And did they do it?
Yes, they definitely did it.
So that doesn't justify
the 10,000 innocent civilians that have
been brutally killed by Israel in Gaza.
And you're not helping, again, our cause
in trying to protect those civilians,
because you make our arguments
easier to dismiss when you come in with
[00:07:04]
outlandish ideas like false flag operation
and no Israeli civilians were killed,
those the fact that Israeli civilians were
killed is an inconvenient fact for you.
- But it's still a fact.
- It is a fact.
And also, this form of resistance
has done what it has led to the slaughter
[00:07:21]
of at least 10,000 innocent civilians,
4000 of whom happened to be children.
How exactly was this
a successful resistance?
Yeah, and.
There's no way to, by the way,
there is no way to justify what Hamas did,
even if this led to some success,
which obviously it didn't.
[00:07:38]
You don't slaughter innocent people, okay.
And this notion that everyone in Israel,
including the civilians,
including children, are by default guilty
because they're all considered settlers?
[00:07:54]
No, we do not.
I mean,
I definitely don't subscribe to it.
I don't think Jenk subscribes to it.
Innocent civilians
should not be targeted on either side.
And what Hamas did led to, again,
the worst possible situation for those
Palestinian civilians in Gaza right now.
[00:08:10]
So people making excuses
for killing others is not helpful.
So and because remember,
everyone has an excuse in their mind.
They're right.
You remember the terrorists who actually
has unfortunately, the most successful
terrorists probably in my lifetime was an
Israeli settler who killed Yitzhak Rabin.
[00:08:28]
Rabin was about to do a peace deal
with the Palestinians,
and that could have actually alleviated
this entire situation for decades on end.
Right? It could have fixed everything.
And Yitzhak Rabin was an imperfect person.
There's no question about that.
[00:08:44]
And by the way, he committed terrorism
before the state of Israel was created,
but he was going to do a peace deal.
And and an Israeli radical fundamentalist
murdered him and,
and prevented the peace deal.
So and but for that guy, I guarantee
you you he thought I'm doing God's work.
[00:09:02]
I'm doing amazing, important work
on behalf of my people.
And I'm going to kill this guy
so that I because I am morally righteous.
That's where you get into a lot of danger.
When people justify
the killing of innocents, when they think
they are morally righteous,
almost never is that the case.
[00:09:20]
And so and none of this excuses
what Israel has done in Gaza.
And so as we criticize Hamas
very forcefully here, I criticize Israel
just as forcefully for the slaughter
that they have unleashed upon Gaza.
[00:09:36]
Thanks for watching the video, guys.
We also love it if you hit the join button
below, because that makes you a member.
And members
allow us to be independent, honest.
We can be as progressive as we want,
no corporate media influence.
And that's all because of you guys.
We love doing the show with our members.
Hit the join button.
Become one of the Young Turks.
Now Playing (Clips)
Episode
Podcast
The Young Turks: November 7, 2023
Hosts: Cenk UygurAna Kasparian
- 13 minutes
- 13 minutes
- 12 minutes
- 9 minutes
- 15 minutes
- 12 minutes
- 10 minutes