Dec 13, 2023
Black Man Wrongfully Convicted Of Murder EXONERATED After 20 Years Behind Bars
Black Man Wrongfully Convicted Of Murder EXONERATED After 20 Years Behind Bars
- 6 minutes
Wrongfully convicted man exonerated
after damn near 20 years behind bars.
Crime never committed it.
Let's put it up full mass.
Marvin Haynes,
36-years of age, do the math.
[00:00:17]
A Minnesota man went to
prison as a teenager.
He was 16.
He has been released almost
two decades after his
wrongful murder conviction was vacated.
[00:00:36]
Haynes has always maintained
his innocence in the deadly
2004 robbery that took
place in a flower shop and
killed 55-year-old Randy Sherer,
according to The Associated Press.
[00:00:51]
In May of that year,
a man walked into the store and
brandished a revolver at Sherer's sister,
Cynthia McDermid,
who was working there at the time,
and ordered her to hand over money and
security footage, the outlet reported.
[00:01:09]
McDermid has since passed away,
but Sherer's family
still maintains she identified
the correct suspect, KARE 11 reported.
Sherer came out from the back and
said they had no money on them and
[00:01:26]
the intruder fired two shots as McDermid
escaped, according to the outlet.
She later picked a man from a lineup that
did not include Haynes as the assailant.
The man had an alibi,
prompting police to look elsewhere.
[00:01:44]
Police followed up on the tip
that pointed toward the young,
teenage Haynes and
then showed McDermid a photo of Haynes
from two years prior,
when he had shorter hair that
[00:02:01]
resembled the shooters,
according to the outlet.
McDermid claimed Haynes was the shooter,
even though he was shorter
than the alleged robber.
Put up prosecutor here.
Hennepin County Attorney Mary Moriarty
said that Haynes'
[00:02:21]
conviction was based almost
exclusively on eyewitness accounts and
the trial lacked any forensic evidence.
At trial, prosecutors also did not present
any videos connecting him to the crime,
[00:02:36]
and authorities never found
a murder weapon at all.
Okay, prosecutors said in a statement,
quote,
that should have made any prosecutor
hesitant to bring charges
because eyewitness identifications
are often unreliable and
[00:02:54]
one of the leading causes
of wrongful convictions.
We inflicted harm on Mr.
Haynes and his family, and
also on Harry Sherer,
the victim, his family and
the community, she said in a statement,
and apologized for
[00:03:13]
all the life experiences Haynes
missed during his time in prison.
We cannot undo the trauma experienced
by those impacted by this prosecution,
but today we have taken a step toward
right this wrong, the prosecutor said.
[00:03:29]
Let's put up the family.
The young man is smiling, okay?
But he went through 20 years of extreme,
unbelievable anxiety, anger, all of it.
[00:03:49]
Haynes spoke outside of
the prison after being released,
thanking the current personnel in the DA's
office, his lawyers, his family members.
Quote, it took 19 years, but I'm here.
[00:04:06]
I just want to move forward and
get my life back, that's it.
He gave a special recognition
to his sister, saying,
and I quote, my sister lost so
much fighting for my innocence.
[00:04:24]
Words cannot describe what she
means to me and my family.
There's a GoFundme.
We want to help them.
[00:04:43]
Maybe the government does
the right thing at some point,
three, four years,
maybe five years later, okay?
But we have a right now opportunity.
There's a GoFundme that's been set up.
We are delighted to see Marvin
finally regain his freedom for
[00:05:03]
the truth of his innocence to win out.
Exonerated after 19 years, support Marvin
Haynes, I want you to make a contribution.
Do the very best you can.
Christmas is coming up.
I want them to have a great Christmas,
right?
[00:05:19]
Professor, thoughts?
>> Speaker 2: I love
that you just did that.
I think that, how can you take 19 years?
I mean, just think how formative that
is for people, for their families, for
everything.
So I love that you ended
that story with support.
Honestly, I think that's what
needs to happen and support for
[00:05:38]
people who are in these
horrible situations.
But also, I wish there were more resources
for things like the Innocence project that
make sure, I mean, some people are in
prison because they committed a crime, and
some people are there because it's an easy
prosecution or because of the system.
[00:05:55]
And so I wish we had more
resources also just to give people
support who are in prison for
the wrong reason.
>> Speaker 1: Yeah, and
I want to echo something.
The police, they broke their own protocol
by showing a photo two years earlier.
[00:06:14]
So what does that mean?
That means they showed a photo of
a 14-year-old child in order to convict
a 16-year-old child for
a crime that the child never committed.
Which means also, whoever killed
this person got away with it.
[00:06:30]
Victims received no justice.
As a matter of fact, it simply created
another injustice and by proximity,
another injustice, because the family has
to endure this, and it goes on and on.
[00:06:46]
It's an ecosystem.
We're glad that exoneration happened
in this case 19 years later.
Do the very best you can with
the GoFundme, all right?
Now Playing (Clips)
Episode
Podcast
Indisputable with Dr. Rashad Richey: December 13, 2023
- 9 minutes
- 10 minutes
- 19 minutes
- 6 minutes
- 7 minutes
- 3 minutes
- 5 minutes
- 6 minutes