Oct 25, 2023
Former MLB Player Set Up In Assault Accusation Case, Allegedly
Former MLB Player Set Up In Assault Accusation Case, Allegedly
- 11 minutes
Hell of a thing, all right?
Hell of a thing.
An ex-Major League Baseball player,
he gets accused of something.
Looks like it's a setup.
It's an assault accusation,
it's convoluted.
We have actual interview
testimony provided.
[00:00:18]
Let me put up the picture full mass here.
Okay, so former Dodgers pitcher,
Trevor Bauer, is speaking out
after lawsuit involving himself and
his accuser, Lindsay Hill.
This lawsuit has now been settled,
he could talk about it.
[00:00:34]
Bauer was actually placed on
administrative leave by the MLB.
This happened in 2021 after
the allegations were made by Lindsay Hill.
Who said Bauer assaulted her
on two different occasions,
[00:00:51]
at his home during what she
said began as consensual sex or
sexual encounters between them both.
So here's what Bauer
said about the situation.
>> Speaker 2: Next victim,
star pitcher for the Dodgers.
[00:01:08]
A text Lindsay Hill sent to a friend
before she ever even met me.
What should I steal?
She asked another in reference to
visiting my house for the first time.
The answer, take his money.
So how might that work?
I'm going to his house Wednesday,
she said.
I already have my hooks in,
you know how I roll.
[00:01:24]
Then, after the first time we met,
net worth is 51 mil, she said.
Bitch, you better secure the bag,
was the response.
But how was she gonna do that?
Need daddy to choke me out, she said.
Being an absolute whore to try to get in
on his 51 million, read another text.
[00:01:40]
Then, after the second time we met, former
Padres pitcher, Jacob Nix, told her,
you gotta get this bag.
I'll give you 50,000, Lindsay replied.
Her AA sponsor asked her at one point,
do you feel a tiny bit guilty?
Not really, she replied.
Since then, her legal team has approached
me multiple times about coming to
[00:01:57]
a financial settlement.
But as I have done since day one,
I refused to pay her even a single cent.
In August of 2021,
Lindsay Hill's claims were heard in court,
and during those legal proceedings,
critical information was deliberately and
unlawfully concealed from me and
my legal team.
[00:02:13]
Information like this video, which was
taken by Lindsay Hill herself the morning
after she claimed she was brutally
attacked, emotionally traumatized, and
desperate to get away from me.
And now we have the metadata,
so there can be no dispute.
It was taken mere minutes before she left
my house on the morning of May 16th,
[00:02:31]
2021, without my knowledge or
consent, of course.
In it, you can see her lying in
bed next to me while I'm sleeping,
smirking at the camera without a care
in the world or any marks on her face.
I think it paints a pretty clear picture
of what actually happened the evening
[00:02:46]
of May 15th and why the video was
originally concealed from us.
Yeah, after hearing
the evidence available to her,
Judge Diana Gold Saltman found that
Lindsay Hill had misled the court.
She found her claims to
be materially misleading.
She denied her request for
a domestic violence restraining order, and
[00:03:04]
she found that no sexual assault or
non-consensual conduct took place.
>> Speaker 1: Actually,
I have more information,
let's put up the picture full mass.
Now, the individual,
Who conducts the interview,
I really don't rock with her.
[00:03:24]
But because of who she's interviewing and
the information provided, or
lack thereof, it is important for context.
So Sara Gonzalez interviewed Lindsay Hill
following Bauer's release of the video,
[00:03:40]
so we're talking about a direct response.
So here's Hill's response when
questioned about the video you just saw.
>> You say this wasn't a setup,
how can you expect anyone to believe that?
[00:03:57]
>> Speaker 4: That's a great question,
I really appreciate you having me
on to even have this conversation.
Obviously, there's a lot
going on around this, so
I really appreciate people who
are asking questions about it.
The first thing I wanna say is I think
that Trevor did this intentionally with
[00:04:14]
the text messages and
how he framed this video,
there's several things in
it that are not correct.
And I just wanna start out
by saying it's so valid for
people to question those text messages.
But the root of the problem here is that
he is presenting this as one conversation,
[00:04:31]
when in reality, he had thousands of
messages to choose from, took those,
made it look sequential, which it was not.
There is no combined screenshot of those
things going on one after the other.
And as I said last night as well,
there's no text message that ever exists,
[00:04:49]
otherwise he would have put it out there,
combining anything about a setup
through rough sex, finances all in one.
Those were handpicked, and
they were from multiple different
conversations, all before we met up.
[00:05:04]
And I think that the video in general
doesn't even talk about what actually
happened between us two, which is what
would have come out during a jury trial.
These were all messages
that happened before.
And then of course, the video is so valid
as well for people to ask questions about,
[00:05:21]
but I do think that that video
was entirely misleading.
He also references
the restraining order hearing,
which people also have questions about.
He says that he was cleared of any
wrongdoing, which is actually incorrect.
In our civil case, the judge had actually
ruled that he had not been cleared of
[00:05:38]
any wrongdoing, and
that was a federal court judge.
>> Speaker 3: Okay, so
I wanna get to the domestic violence
restraining order hearing as well.
So you're saying that it's misleading
because you're admitting that you did
talk about rough sex and
wanting rough sex, you did talk about
[00:05:57]
him needing to choke you out,
you did talk about stealing his money.
But it's misleading because he put them
together in the same video as if you had
said it in the same conversation, when
in fact, it was separate conversations,
correct?
That's why it's misleading?
>> Correct, and as well as not showing
the messages that occurred after, where it
[00:06:15]
discusses it strictly in the term of being
a baseball wife or something like that.
>> Speaker 3: Or something like that.
Okay, I'm just curious if you know the
statistical likelihood of you texting your
friend premeditated texts.
Saying you wanted him to choke you out and
steal his money, take his money, and
[00:06:33]
him actually choking you out, and
those two things not being related.
>> Speaker 1: I think
those are fair questions.
Her answers do not make much sense,
I do believe some of this was
glossed over by the anchor.
[00:06:48]
However, she was trying.
So Gonzalez would actually
grill about specific text and
actions during the incident, here it is.
>> Speaker 4: But
it does cause a lot of questions as to why
I was seeking Trevor out.
[00:07:06]
But at the end of the day, there was
nothing about a set up with violence and
all of this stuff and
getting financial game.
It was strictly a 25 or however old I
was at the time, girl, trying to get
attention from those things and phrasing
it in a sarcastic way before we met.
[00:07:22]
>> Speaker 3: Okay, so
I've got a couple other questions on that.
So you said in court that he sexually
assaulted you on two different encounters,
and you say the first time that
you say he choked you unconscious.
Clearly the insinuation is you didn't like
it cuz now you're calling it an assault,
[00:07:39]
but why did you make the drive back to LA
to meet back up with him a second time if
this man had just assaulted
you by your own account?
>> Speaker 4: I think that's
a really good question.
>> I agree.
How I phrased it and how [INAUDIBLE]
in the past is that I was so
embarrassed by the first encounter that
I felt something deep in me to go and
[00:07:59]
take the power back and to be better and
to be what he wanted, in a sense.
And so I don't know,
there's been a lot of,
through all the processes, expert witness,
experts on the psychology of what
happens when you are assaulted, X, Y, Z.
[00:08:17]
But there was something in me that
felt like I needed to make it better,
in a sense.
>> Speaker 3: Okay, but
you texted Trevor before you met him,
telling him you liked rough sex.
Then you texted him after your
first sexual encounter with him,
which you now call an assault.
[00:08:33]
And according to court records, you told
him after that sexual encounter that you
had, quote,
never been more turned on in your life.
That's not [INAUDIBLE]
>> Speaker 1: Yeah, all right,
the result of the suit in question
is important to highlight.
So the former major league pitcher,
Trevor Bauer,
[00:08:53]
and the woman who accused him
of sexual assault and assault.
In 2021, they settled their legal dispute.
Bauer's attorney said,
and this was October 2nd,
both of their respective claims have been
withdrawn with prejudice, effective today.
[00:09:09]
So attorneys Jon Fetterolf and
Shawn Holley said in a statement.
Now, I wanna say this I don't believe her,
okay?
Personally, I don't believe her story,
I don't believe her explanation.
[00:09:25]
I actually believe Bauer.
Now that's not common.
Typically, I do actually believe
people who claim they've been victims
because it takes a lot to go through
the barrier of doubt that will permeate,
[00:09:41]
especially in this kind
of culture in America.
I highlight this story for
one very specific reason.
As I said, I do not believe the woman and
her accusation in this story.
A lot of people don't believe her.
[00:09:58]
The judge did not believe her, okay?
It harms actual victims who have
to encounter real monsters.
And so because of the narrative
that can permeate from that,
[00:10:21]
many times it goes unreported.
There are some stats that show
over 90% of assaults like
this go completely unreported.
When an individual makes an accusation,
[00:10:37]
those accusations have
to be taken seriously.
When somebody does what I
believe this woman did,
she weakens the overall
requirement of belief that we need
in order to make sure more people
feel empowered to come forward.
[00:10:57]
This is a humanity aspect, okay?
I'm not sure if the authorities
are going to pick this up or not.
Naturally, there are many people
saying that she should be arrested for
the false accusation.
I'll let that be.
Now Playing (Clips)
Episode
Podcast
Indisputable with Dr. Rashad Richey: October 25, 2023
Hosts: Dr. Rashad Richey Guests: Cenk Uygur
- 4 minutes
- 3 minutes
- 5 minutes
- 6 minutes
- 3 minutes
- 18 minutes
- 11 minutes
- 10 minutes