Skip to content

GOP Chair Who Used Fake Voter ID Defended Racist Voter Maps to Supreme Court

Republican official told the Supreme Court that Alabama law is no obstacle to voting while at the same time he was using his political clout to surmount those obstacles

Alabama Republican Party Chair John Wahl in a Facebook photo he posted on May 24, 2022, after voting in the primaries weeks after getting a poll worker removed.


(Uncredited Facebook photo)

The Alabama Republican Party chair who made his own voter ID and tried to circumvent state voting laws also filed a brief in the Supreme Court case heard yesterday supporting the state’s allegedly racist congressional map, court records show.

State GOP Executive Committee Chair John Wahl argued that Alabama law doesn’t create any obstacles to voting, even though recent reports show he personally faced such obstacles both before and after filing his brief – and only overcame them by throwing his political weight around.

Wahl allegedly pressured poll workers to let him vote with a fake ID in 2020 and then, less than a week before defending state law to the Supreme Court, got a poll worker bounced for enforcing it. Voter ID laws have been found to suppress Black votes disproportionately.

Despite Wahl’s documented use of a fake ID card to vote, no legal action has been initiated against him. Black officials convicted of voter fraud in the state, however, have been prosecuted and as recently as 2019 sentenced to prison.

The power of Black voters is at stake in the case of Merrill v. Milligan, which the Supreme Court heard yesterday. As SCOTUSblog reported, the court appears inclined to side with Alabama and remove one of the remaining pillars of the landmark Voting Rights Act (VRA). The right-wing court has previously concluded, despite all the evidence to the contrary, that racism has largely been purged from America’s political systems, rendering the VRA unnecessary.

In this case, the state of Alabama is accused of packing a single district with far more Black voters (who make up more than a quarter of the state population) than are needed to ensure they have a voice there. That leaves far fewer Black voters in other districts – where the new GOP lines have chopped up their communities to leave them virtually voiceless in six out of the state’s seven districts.

The state argues that it should be allowed to be “race-blind” when drawing districts – meaning if the outcome of drawing lines for partisan reasons happens to dilute Black voting strength, that’s okay because it’s correlation, not causation. In a May 2 amicus curiae filing, Wahl agreed.

Wahl’s argument was twofold. He defended the new map to the Supreme Court, claiming it doesn’t abridge the right to vote. He also wrote that Alabama election results are due not to racial gerrymandering, but to the “partisan effect of equal voter participation.”

Wahl claims that, “It is well-established that the official obstacles to voter registration and turnout by blacks in Alabama have ended.” Wahl argues that similar registration rates for Black and White voters imply there are no obstacles to Black voting, eliding the possibility that Black people in Alabama might register in greater numbers than White people if there were fewer obstacles to voting.

One such obstacle is Alabama’s voter ID law. And Wahl would know that the law requiring voter ID can be an obstacle to voters because in 2020, Wahl himself was challenged over his voter ID. He and his family pressured poll workers to let them vote despite not having a legitimate ID, or in some case any ostensible ID at all.

Unlike most Black voters lacking proper ID, however, Wahl was able to vote because he had something they didn’t. It wasn’t just his fake ID, it was his position in the Republican Party.

Alabama Media Group State Political Columnist Kyle Whitmire has chronicled both Wahl’s run-ins with voting obstacles there, but also Wahl’s use of his power to overcome them.

Earlier this week, Whitmire reported that Wahl not only attempted to vote – and succeeded – with a voter ID he made himself, but also falsely claimed to poll workers that the ID had been officially issued.

That news came after Whitmire previously revealed that Wahl used his clout to have a retiree dismissed as a poll worker. Clyde Martin had volunteered to work the polling sites because he cared about election integrity. Too much, as it turned out.

After Wahl pressured Martin to let him and his family vote in 2020 despite their lack of valid IDs, Martin wrote to Wahl to let him know they would need to bring proper ID for the next election. Whitmire obtained public documents showing that on April 28, just four days before telling the Supreme Court that Alabama law has no voting obstacles, Wahl complained about Martin enforcing that law. County officials then bounced Martin from his post.

Wahl voted again without legal ID in Alabama’s primaries later in May.

But while Wahl has been willing to use his political clout to facilitate his ability to vote, he’s been more restrained on issues where race is an obvious factor.

When a local politician used the n-word in a public meeting, Wahl condemned it, but reportedly did not call for their resignation. In another incident, one writer characterized Wahl as “blindingly” silent when a county party official shared a drawing intertwining imagery of the GOP and the KKK.

The reason Wahl’s family members didn’t have IDs, Whitmire also revealed, is that they consider the requisite, digitized photos to be related to the Bible’s prophecies about the number of The Beast.

Reportedly, Alabama Secretary of State John Merrill – as in Merrill v. Milligansaid yesterday that Wahl’s actions were “not legal.” Merrill said that “certain people are having [a] conversation” about potential repercussions for Wahl.

In the recent past, repercussions for voter fraud in Alabama have included criminal prosecution. But a database maintained by the right-wing Heritage Foundation of voter fraud cases suggests that those prosecuted in Alabama are disproportionately non-White. And it suggests that even Black defendants who have some measure of political power face more serious repercussions than Wahl has in the days since his “not legal” actions were revealed.

In 2019, the Black former mayor of Gordon, AL, Elbert Melton, was sentenced to a year in prison for falsifying election documents. In 2016, another Black man, Daniel Reynolds, got two years probation for falsifying absentee ballots.

Heritage’s database of identifiable lawbreakers includes Black people and one Hispanic person, but the most recent White person listed as being convicted of voter fraud was ten years ago. She didn’t go to jail, but she also didn’t make a fake ID.

Jonathan Larsen is TYT's managing editor. You can find him on Twitter @JTLarsen.


Want to put your two cents in? We want to hear it! Posting comments is only available for TYT community members.

Click here to sign up for free.

Welcome to the new commenting experience

We're laying the foundation for exciting new commenting features, coming soon. We're still working out the kinks, so if you are running into trouble you can switch back to OpenWeb, but this option won't be around forever! Note that we are working on migrating older comments into the new system.

What's new?


New page: GOP Chair Who Used Fake Voter ID Defended Racist Voter Maps to Supreme Court -