Nov 5, 2025
Libertarian Backs Tucker Carlson In WAR Against The Neocon Right
Libertarian Institute director Scott Horton gives his take on Tucker Carlson.
- 10 minutes
I do want to talk a little bit about the
Tucker thing, because, you know, I did a
lot of I watched a lot of Tucker's content
prior to agreeing to go on his podcast,
because prior to that, you know,
I had all these ideas in my head
about who Tucker is because I remember him
from his Neo-con days.
[00:00:17]
I remember him from, you know, his Fox
News days where he said all sorts of
things that I vehemently disagreed with,
and I didn't know if it made sense
for me to have a conversation with him.
So I started listening
to his podcast daily and realized he's
super remorseful about his neocon days.
[00:00:35]
He apologizes for it on a regular basis,
and he speaks to and I think it's sincere.
He speaks to the real struggles
of Americans, particularly young Americans
who can't afford houses, don't think they
can afford to get married and have kids.
[00:00:52]
It is leading to a level of despair
in this country that has been completely
neglected by our political elite.
And let's also keep it real
by our corporate media
and mainstream legacy media.
So, when he decided to have Nick
Fuentes on, I kept an open mind.
[00:01:11]
Even though I know about all all
the things that Nick Fuentes has said.
I know that he has,
you know, celebrated Hitler.
I know all that stuff.
But I wanted to see, okay, what's going
to come out of this conversation.
And I feel that there has been
this misconception about how Tucker didn't
[00:01:29]
push back against Nick Fuentes at all,
when he very clearly did,
and drew a distinction between what Tucker
Carlson believes and what Nick Fuentes
believes Nick Fuentes still believes.
And he said it during this podcast
interview that the problem is this global,
[00:01:45]
like organized jewelry.
Tucker Carlson pushed back on that
and said, no, I totally disagree.
And in fact, when you pin this on
the Jews, all you do is discredit everyone
who is specifically critical of Israel.
And so this effort to cancel him, I don't
think, is really just about Nick Fuentes.
[00:02:05]
I think it's about everything
that Tucker has been saying
in pushing back against the foreign policy
that now several administrations
in this country have engaged in,
including the fact that we've supported
Israel, regardless of who's in power
[00:02:21]
there, regardless of what they have done
in that region of the world.
That's my take.
It doesn't mean that you have
to defend Nick Fuentes,
but I am defending the idea that two
consenting adults sit down and have a
conversation without having this organized
campaign meant to destroy the interviewer,
[00:02:40]
in this case, Tucker Carlson.
- But you know, what are your thoughts?
- Well, I totally agree with you.
And you're especially on the point
about, well, on all of it.
But especially the thing to focus on here
is think about how they don't mean it.
This isn't about Nick Fuentes at all.
This is about Tucker Carlson's
turn against Israel
[00:02:58]
and against the war party overall.
And they've decided they have something
that they think that they can
use against him, which parentheses
ain't going to work anyway, Jack.
Tough luck.
But that's what they're trying to do.
And of course, anyone who watched the
interview saw the same interview you did
[00:03:16]
where, you know, all this talk
about platforming is so ridiculous.
The guy's a journalist.
The guy's interviewed ayatollahs
and God knows who.
Right.
That's his job, is to interview people
who are important in the news.
And this guy, this young guy Fuentes,
is now it's undeniable.
[00:03:33]
If you look at his audience size,
he is a force to be reckoned with
one way or another on the right.
And Tucker clearly has been struggling
to figure out how to deal with him.
And I saw a clip where Fuentes said,
sounds believable.
I didn't ask Tucker, but seemed like maybe
Tucker had asked Max Blumenthal and his
[00:03:50]
wife to write this thing against him
back years ago, kind of thing.
Tucker is really trying
to figure out a way
to do like a mark Levin and cancel him.
And he said in his interview with
Candace Owens, I think this guy's a plant,
like he's Cointelpro.
[00:04:05]
He sent to make all of us look bad,
like him, for sidling up and agreeing
with most of what we say and then also
saying a bunch of crazy stuff, you know.
And so but the problem with that was
he had no real evidence for that.
And so Tucker from on high
now Mr. Fox News big shot guy.
[00:04:25]
He even said in his criticism
he lives in his mom's basement.
So it was a big guy swinging
at a little guy, and then he missed and he
actually made a baseless accusation.
So then he was in the position
where he kind of had to eat a little crow.
I think, he didn't tell me
this or anything, but I think this is sort
[00:04:42]
of the way I read the situation.
After swinging and missing,
he kind of had to go ahead
and have him on and let the kid, you know,
define himself, as he would.
And of course, as you say, Tucker.
And all anyone has to do
is just watch this.
People are like, they got a screenshot
in their head of, oh, no, a platforming,
[00:05:01]
happened or something.
Watch what happened in the conversation.
And as you say, it's Tucker explaining
over and over and over again.
Well, you say you have
the same religion as me, but our religion
teaches opposite of what you're you're
saying your conclusions are here.
And then it is true that Tucker
didn't say as like,
[00:05:22]
I don't know how this is supposed to work.
He brings the guy out to the middle
of main, you know what I mean?
He's not just going to sit there
and beat him over the head,
but perhaps he could have said, hey, man,
you really have crossed the line
in some of this stuff you've said
about blacks and Jews and Hitler and this
and that, like, this is some pretty.
[00:05:37]
And he didn't hit him that hard on that.
But the way I read that
was that he was leaving Fuentes space to
back down a little bit in a way, and say,
because in fact, like, check
out the difference between the Jews are
all a bunch of traitors serving Israel.
[00:05:54]
And, well, Sheldon Adelson wasn't
a neoconservative, just a Jewish Zionist.
And so his Jewishness obviously
informs his Zionism somehow.
Okay, well, that's true for a lot
of Jewish Zionists that Jewishness
and Zionism seem to go together to them.
[00:06:11]
Okay, but what does that say
about the millions and millions
and millions of American Jews?
Doesn't say anything
about them at all does.
- It is.
- Exactly.
A different way of framing it.
And so when Tucker said, okay, well,
let's just draw our lines here and see,
Fuentes seemed to back down
from his own position quite a way.
[00:06:30]
Now you're right.
Yeah, you're right about that.
And and one more thing there is.
Sure, I've actually kind of been mulling
this over because I think it represents
a real crisis for the right and especially
the antiwar and anti-Zionist right,
that what are we going
to do with this guy?
Before he made sure
that he was so beyond the pale that, like,
[00:06:46]
fine, he has his corner over there,
but now he's going, yeah, it's me and
Tucker and Candace against the war party.
And it's like, now listen, man,
you're still an avowed hitlerian
and whatever to whatever degree.
Look, I'm not the greatest connoisseur
of the guy, but I've seen
some pretty astounding clips before.
[00:07:02]
Okay?
I've not watched hours and hours,
but I know about him.
That, and I know the origin story
that Ben Shapiro's.
What did this to him
when he was just a kid.
So it's almost a comic book movie.
Like,
this is where your villain came from.
Was he was so mistreated unfairly
when he was too young.
Whatever.
[00:07:17]
But, now what does
what does the entire anti-war right.
And you see, there's a giant faction
fight on the right
with a war party is going after, you know,
and not just the war party, but like,
you know, more mainstream Republican types
are really going after Tucker
[00:07:35]
and everyone anti-Zionist and hanging
Fuentes around all of our necks.
And and it represents a real conundrum
of what we're going to do here.
He's trying to soften and sort
of join up with a larger movement,
but in a way that can really
only cause them nothing but grief.
[00:07:52]
Right?
To me, it seems like what he should do
is he should just go full Cointelpro
against Israel
and say, yes, he's a National Socialist.
He shares the ideology of the Likud party,
which is ethno religious nationalism
and exclusivism and collectivism
at the expense of the other,
[00:08:08]
which is what he believes in and which is
what Benjamin Netanyahu believes in.
You know, Richard Spencer, who they
previously made poster boy for the
so-called alt right back ten years ago.
He said, well,
I don't see a problem with Zionism.
I just want Zionism
for white people here, that's all.
[00:08:23]
And at one time,
he challenged a rabbi at Texas A&M.
I think it was a rabbi.
It might have been a professor, I forget,
but he challenged, I think it was
a rabbi at Texas A&M and said, well,
do you support open immigration to Israel?
And he goes, well, of course.
Oh, in fact, what he did
was he sat there silent
[00:08:39]
and he couldn't think of a thing to say.
And then he just turned around and walked
away, handing the point to the Nazi
to an avowed National Socialist.
And so if if Nick Fuentes really resents
Israel, he ought to sidle up to them
instead of to Tucker Carlson and friends.
[00:08:55]
I just think, you know, especially
as someone who was very much part
of the cancel culture left at one point,
especially after the 2016 election,
attempting to silence people
or censor people
or punish people for having conversations.
[00:09:10]
It doesn't work.
In fact, all it does is help the
very individual you are trying to crush
become more and more popular.
The only thing that works
is engaging in debate.
Engaging in discussion.
And you know,
sunlight really is the best disinfectant.
[00:09:26]
And I just. I'm sorry.
How many shows agreed to do sit down
interviews with a literal war criminal?
Benjamin Netanyahu, who was wanted
by the International Criminal Court,
gave softball interviews.
[00:09:42]
And this is a guy who has literally
slaughtered, engaged in mass slaughter,
including of children.
There's no campaign to cancel those shows,
and I wouldn't want a campaign
to cancel those shows.
I covered some of those interviews.
I critiqued those interviews.
You know it substantively,
and then you just get to push in.
[00:10:01]
You move on. Right?
But this idea that it is beyond the pale
for Tucker Carlson to sit down with,
you know, Nick Fuentes.
And again, I have huge issues
with things that Nick Fuentes has said.
But compare him to, again, Netanyahu,
who's actually killed people,
[00:10:18]
wiped out entire bloodlines.
No pushback on that. It's kind of amazing.
Every time you ring the bell below,
an angel gets his wings.
Totally not true.
But it does keep you updated
on our live shows.
Now Playing (Clips)
Episode
Podcast
