Sep 18, 2025
Harris Reveals Why She Didn't Pick Buttigieg As VP
Former Vice President Kamala Harris really wanted Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg as her running mate.
- 8 minutes
To his former high school
football players.
He was coach. And in 91 days.
The nation will know Coach Walt
by another name.
[00:00:15]
Vice president of the United States.
You know, when they write these books,
after performing like that
and having people believe them,
why would I ever believe them again?
Here's what's going on.
In her upcoming book, Kamala Harris
reveals that Minnesota Governor Tim Walz
[00:00:32]
was not her first choice for running mate,
but ultimately she went with Tim
because he was a safer option.
Her first choice former Department of
Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg.
Buttigieg would have been an ideal partner
if I were a straight white man,
[00:00:51]
but we were already asking a lot of
America to accept a woman, a black woman,
a black woman married to a Jewish man.
Part of me wanted to say,
screw it, let's just do it.
But knowing what was at stake.
It was too big of a risk.
[00:01:08]
And I think Pete also knew
that to our mutual sadness, Harris
goes on to explain how close the two were,
stating he was, quote,
a sincere public servant with the rare
talent of being able to frame
liberal arguments in a way that makes it
possible for conservatives to hear them,
[00:01:28]
especially during the pandemic.
Buttigieg did become sort of a household
name and spokesperson for the Democratic
Party, going on right wing networks like
Fox News to tout Biden and his agenda.
After Biden dropped out of the race,
Buttigieg was suggested
[00:01:45]
as a possible running mate by allies
who touted his high name recognition
and ability to act as an attack dog.
They also noted his age, just 42,
would help Harris make the race
about generational change and distance
herself from the 81 year old Biden.
[00:02:05]
Harris wrote about how her life was
upended when she became Biden's running
mate in 2020, and her awareness
that she was about to cause the
same sudden swerve in someone else's life.
But yet, she ultimately went with walls.
Minnesota governor had burst onto the
national stage weeks earlier with a series
[00:02:24]
of buzzy national cable interviews,
and Harris has said that she liked his mix
of Midwest folksiness
and progressive bona fides.
But after a well-received
convention address, Walz became something
of a non-entity on the campaign trail
and turned into a middling performance
[00:02:44]
in his one debate with J.D.
Vance.
Buttigieg did seem to be
a favorite among voters.
According to ABC News Ipsos poll released
in July of last year, Buttigieg was
viewed favorably by 29% of respondents,
with Mark Kelly coming in second at 22%.
[00:03:02]
Following them Governor Gavin Newsom,
California 21% and Governor Whitmer, 20%.
Shapiro came in at 17%.
Tim Walz only had 6% favorability.
Regardless what things have been
different, if she'd chosen Buttigieg
[00:03:21]
over Walz, probably not, according to some
Democrats ahead of the 2020 election.
Harris moved to the left,
along with most presidential hopefuls.
Many primary voters, a shift that included
an embrace of progressive policies on
issues such as policing and immigration.
[00:03:38]
The party debated gender politics
such as pronouns, transgender rights, and
there was a heavy focus on the backgrounds
and identities of its candidates.
By 2024, Democrats seemed out of step
with a country that appeared more focused
on kitchen table issues.
[00:03:56]
The Atlantic filling
in some of the details on this one.
I think I learned something
I didn't realize, Michael,
how close she and Buttigieg were.
But as I was chronicling
that for for the For the audience.
I started thinking about something.
Just the way my mind works.
[00:04:14]
Do you think there's a possibility
that she didn't go with Buttigieg,
regardless of what's written here?
Because when you're picking a vice
president and maybe it's geography, but
it's also I don't want you to upstage me.
I don't want that.
[00:04:30]
Is that, do you think, possibility
of what could have also been behind this?
And when you are a sitting vice president,
anyone you select, because of the,
you know, the sort of nothing
image of that job as vice president,
[00:04:46]
anyone you select,
you run the risk of being upstaged when
when al Gore, a vice president, because
the nature of that job is so is so dull.
He selected Joe Lieberman.
That was even Joe Lieberman was
electric compared to al Gore at the time.
[00:05:03]
So, you know, when Walter Mondale
selected Geraldine Ferraro,
the same thing happened.
You're actually looking for someone
to upstage you in a way,
because your position is so dull
that you do want something.
And the same thing. George H.W.
[00:05:19]
Bush selected Dan Quayle
because Dan Quayle was young and handsome
and much more vibrant and vital.
It would seem so. I don't think that.
And I think this is kind of a nothing
story, which is not to disparage us
talking about it or selecting it,
because it's an interesting conversation.
Nonetheless.
There are 25, 30 people that that Kamala
Harris could have selected to run with
[00:05:38]
when she was vice president,
and each one of them knew
that the other could be selected.
I would imagine the governor Walz knew
that Secretary Buttigieg
could have been selected
and may have been the first choice.
The calculation you make when you were
doing this is that it's your first
decision, it's the first thing you do.
[00:05:55]
And if there's anyone in America
who thinks that Kamala Harris
lost the presidency
because she selected Tim Walz, they they
don't know enough about politics.
It doesn't matter.
People don't vote for the vice president.
He was perfectly acceptable
to a lot of the progressives in the party.
[00:06:12]
She lost because of what you just talked
about, which was kitchen table issues
and the ability of Donald Trump to say,
your gas prices are going to come down and
your egg prices are going to come down,
and all they care about are gays
and lesbians and transgender people.
[00:06:27]
He said it, they bought it,
and that was that.
He may have, you know,
it may have been different.
We'll never know.
Had had President Biden bowed out earlier,
perhaps it would have been.
Perhaps it would have made no difference.
Perhaps it would have made the loss
even more devastating
if they went through a primary, selected
a candidate in the traditional ways,
[00:06:45]
and that candidate also lost.
Who knows?
At least the Democrats can say,
well, we had a truncated election here.
We weren't able to get our ideas around.
Let's let's try and do it again next time.
So I don't that's why I think
this is a a nothing story.
I don't think ever that the vice president
matters unless they totally screw up.
[00:07:03]
Had John Edwards,
had we known about John Edwards
that he had a family out of wedlock?
That would have been a bad choice, right?
When when when, you know,
those sorts of things.
But I don't see this at all in that way.
We're going to move on, but quickly.
Do you believe that?
You know, why is she writing the book
besides the money?
[00:07:21]
Perhaps relevancy?
Will the book do enough
to distance her from what she knew
about an aging president?
Competency?
I don't know what's the reason.
I think what's interesting about it
is the 107 days.
It's a it was a unique
presidential campaign.
[00:07:38]
I'll read anything,
anything by a former candidate.
I, I think that there's some candor here.
Most likely, she lost
and she's a vice president.
I don't think she will be president.
I don't think that she's
a viable candidate because of the fact
she's from California,
and Gavin Newsom is from California, and
[00:07:55]
they go to the same places to get money.
And those people are have already given
to to Vice President Harris.
And I think now they're going
to give Governor Newsom.
But I look I think it's interesting
I think it's part of political history.
And I as someone who likes politics
and likes history, I'm interested.
[00:08:11]
But it's nothing more than that to me.
Every time you ring the bell below,
an angel gets its wings.
Totally not true.
But it does keep you updated
on our live shows.
Now Playing (Clips)
Episode
Podcast
