Aug 8, 2025
The Excruciating Conditions At Alligator Alcatraz
A judge has ordered a temporary halt to construction at “Alligator Alcatraz."
- 15 minutes
They're.
Torturing human beings.
They're ruining the environment.
They're enriching their donors
by giving them these contracts.
I mean, what's next?
They're going to start robbing old ladies.
Like, who are these people?
- And how does anybody support this?
- I go to, I go to, I go, this is.
[00:00:18]
This is sad, sad, hopeless.
It's a type of torture.
CNN spoke with eight detainees
to hear firsthand accounts
of what conditions are like on the inside.
Because of the way
that we have been treated,
it has been a very terrible experience.
[00:00:34]
All of the toilets,
when it rains, they overflow and the cells
we're in fill up with sewage.
Every time it does rain and storm,
the toilets clog up.
I no longer know when it's daytime
or when it's nighttime.
[00:00:50]
I don't sleep.
It's affecting me mentally and physically.
More and more details about the horrible
conditions that immigrants are being
subjected to inside Alligator Alcatraz
are starting to come out,
and it's worse than we could have
imagined, because of course it is.
[00:01:07]
First of all, sorry to the audience.
I feel like I teased good news.
That was not the good news.
Part of this story.
There is actually good news coming,
regarding the Florida facility.
But, Jake, what's your initial reaction
to what we just heard
from detainees in that clip?
It's horrifying
that this is happening in America.
[00:01:26]
Look, there's a couple of pieces
of good news.
The rest is all bad.
Like, we're going to give you terrible
details here because that's what's
actually happening inside America now.
And now, by the way, the right wingers
in different states are thinking of like,
different horrible torture chambers
they can set up in their own states.
[00:01:43]
Right?
So for those on the radical right,
they love this kind of cruelty.
But the American people
do not like this kind of cruelty.
This isn't what America.
If you think this is what America stands
for, you got the wrong country, brother.
Okay, so.
But now good people are going to there
to deliver people food and comfort and aid
[00:02:04]
because they've heard
the horrific stories.
So we'll talk about that a little bit more
in a minute as well.
Okay.
So let let's get
into the good news for once.
It was reported yesterday
that a federal judge ordered a halt
to any construction at Alligator Alcatraz
for environmental reasons.
[00:02:21]
So this is a reporting it says
that Florida must must stop construction
at an immigration detention center
in the Everglades for 14 days,
a federal judge ruled on Thursday,
granting at least a temporary victory
to environmentalists, who say the facility
[00:02:37]
has the potential to cause serious harm to
sensitive wetlands and endangered species.
So this means that the state cannot
install any more lighting, paving, fencing
or any other infrastructure for two weeks.
So here's more.
Thursday's order was issued by U.S.
[00:02:54]
District Judge Kathleen Williams with the
Southern District of Florida in a lawsuit
filed by friends of the Everglades and
Centers for Biological Diversity in June.
The Miccosukee Tribe's request
to intervene was granted a month later.
[00:03:10]
The complaint argued
that the detention center threatens
the fragile ecosystem of the Everglades,
including endangered species.
Violated federal law by failing
to pass an environmental review.
Did not allow
the public opportunity to comment.
[00:03:25]
Threatens to undermine or reverse
billions of dollars worth
of Everglades restoration work
and improperly converted county preserve
land into a federal detention facility.
So while DeSantis has insisted
that there wouldn't be any
[00:03:42]
sort of environmental impact,
environmental groups have stated
that that was obviously impossible
because of vehicle traffic bringing
in food and water and machinery
and construction and numerous generators
running and waste collection.
Granted, it doesn't seem like the first
and last bullet that I just mentioned
[00:04:01]
are actually being done.
So the increased light pollution
from a rarely used airstrip
to an operational detention facility,
with thousands of detainees
and staff present, is another concern,
as it can disrupt local species
used to used to natural daylight
[00:04:19]
and night time cycles like the nocturnal
Florida panther, an endangered species
known to be present in the area.
Now the facility will still remain open
and operational, but it's at least a small
step in the right direction in an effort
to shut down the facility eventually.
[00:04:37]
So now I have to tell you the bad news.
We're going to get into more details about
what is coming out from the detainees
who are currently in Alligator Alcatraz.
Here is what is going on inside the walls,
one detainee,
who is a Cuban national, told reporters.
[00:04:54]
It's only a matter of time
before people begin dying in custody
at the hands of experienced,
racist and power inexperienced.
I'm sorry, racist and power hungry guards.
They said this has to come out
one way or another
because they're going to kill us here.
[00:05:10]
Little by little,
no one pays attention to us.
I've been here for 30 days
seeing injustice and mistreatment.
It doesn't stop.
They abuse us in every way.
With the food,
in the bathroom, everything.
Everything. They touch us.
[00:05:25]
All our groins, our rears
to see if we've brought cookies.
A little piece of fries. And they take it.
They search us, they touch us a lot.
They search and touch our whole bodies.
In a weird way,
we feel violated, I feel violated.
[00:05:42]
So he's not the only person this week
to speak out about the conditions either.
Earlier this week, NBC six Miami spoke to
Lindsay, who is a former employee at the
facility, who described it as inhumane.
She said it's inhumane the way
that they're keeping the residents at.
[00:05:58]
Lindsay, who provided NBC six paperwork
showing she had started work on July 6th,
her state certification
as a corrections officer,
and her contract with Gardaworld
Federal Services, a security company that
was awarded a contract worth nearly $38
million for staffing at the Ice facility.
[00:06:17]
They have no sunlight.
There is no clock in there.
They don't even know
what time of day it is.
They have no access to showers.
They shower every other day
or every four days.
The bathrooms are backed up
because you got so many people using them.
So while she explained,
the conditions for the staff were also
[00:06:36]
very rough, she expressed extreme empathy
for the detainees, who noted many of them
were not even criminals.
Right.
These are just normal people
that the Trump administration
has decided to lock up in this facility.
Lindsay was fired pretty quickly
after catching Covid one week into the job
[00:06:53]
and having to isolate.
She says they accused her
of altering medical paperwork submitted
to the company, which she denies.
But she also said
these people are still human.
They pulled them from their livelihood.
They're scared.
They don't speak our language.
I was fired and yeah, I'm pissed off,
but more so than ever,
[00:07:12]
like they're doing wrong.
Okay.
And yet, despite all of this,
a disaster like a sister facility
to alligator Alcatraz is about to open.
So Kristi Noem just posted
this on X saying coming soon to Indiana,
[00:07:28]
the Speedway slammer.
Today we're announcing a new partnership
with the state of Indiana to expand
detention bed space by 1000 beds.
Thanks to Governor Braun
for his partnership to help remove
the worst of the worst out of our country.
[00:07:43]
If you are in America illegally,
you could find yourself
in Indiana's Speedway Slammer.
Avoid arrests
and self-deport now using our app.
And I also noticed there
that she changed her profile picture
to the South Park version of her.
Really trying to lean into the criticism
and, you know,
[00:07:59]
pretend like it doesn't bother them.
Maz, we'll start with you.
That was a lot that we just covered.
There is some good stuff
that happened there.
They're pausing any further construction
because obviously it's going
to disrupt the Everglades.
[00:08:15]
That is a very sensitive ecosystem there.
It's it's unique in this country
and probably maybe even around the world.
And you can't build a giant facility like
that in the middle of the Everglades and
then pretend that it's not going to have
any kind of adverse effects on the water,
[00:08:30]
on the wetlands,
on the animals that live there.
And, you know, the way
that they're treating the people
is already so inhumane.
Then obviously they don't care about
things like the trees or the Panthers.
You know, so like, of course they're going
to fight back and they're going to say,
you know, like, this isn't a real problem.
[00:08:47]
DeSantis already said
that it wasn't going to affect that, which
like it just none of it makes any sense.
But then on top of that,
this the revelations that have just come
out about like the inappropriate touching
and everything going on
inside of alligator Alcatraz right now,
[00:09:02]
I don't even like saying that
because it sounds like such a stupid name,
but you know everything.
It is just so much worse
than what we thought was going on
and could have been happening,
just like the access to people's bodies.
It's hard to wrap your head around
and you don't want to.
And then on top of everything, you
remember that your tax dollars are funding
[00:09:21]
this thing and it is all so infuriating.
Maz, what are your thoughts?
Oh, I think it's great.
No, I mean, who are these people?
Like, how bad of a human being
do you have to be?
I mean, the irony is you've got guys like
DeSantis claiming that he's a Christian.
[00:09:39]
So, yeah, sure, Christians do
this kind of stuff to other people.
These are the worst of the worst.
And I'm talking about Trump on down.
Think about it.
They're torturing human beings.
They're ruining the environment.
They're enriching their donors
by giving them these contracts.
[00:09:56]
I mean, what's next?
They're going to start robbing old ladies.
Like, who are these people?
And how do how does anybody support this?
And I know how people support this is
because they've been lying from day one.
Donald Trump famously during the campaign,
kept saying there's 10 million violent
[00:10:14]
criminals, then there's 20 million.
He just kept saying,
all these violent criminals, violent
criminals find out there aren't that many
violent criminals that are not citizens.
We probably have more.
We have more citizen violent criminals.
And, even if they are criminals,
they are not getting their due process.
[00:10:32]
They shouldn't be in this kind of I mean,
America is supposed
to be standing for something.
This is like the Abu Ghraib of of Florida
rather than alligator Alcatraz.
How about Abu Ghraib?
Because that's what it is.
Or Abu Ghraib.
It's just it's it's it's embarrassing.
[00:10:50]
It's inhumane. We've lost our compass.
Like where, where where we're like, what
is America become when you when you see
this stuff and the fact that nobody on the
right is following the money and going,
oh, they're enriching their donors
and themselves by creating this.
[00:11:08]
Because, again, going back
to the campaign,
we're going to deport this money.
We're going to deport that many never
talked about what's actually going to have
to happen, which is we're gonna have
to send Ice agents into the streets.
And then where are we going
to keep these people?
He's going to just put them
on a plane and send them.
Know you're going to put them
into these concentration camps.
[00:11:24]
And now you got your speedway.
What is she calling it? Speedway.
Something or other. Glamor.
Glamor.
- The speedway slammer in Indiana.
- Speedway slammer like they.
Oh, they got great names.
You know, this is the the jail
of La Jolla or whatever.
[00:11:40]
Just. Just idiotic.
Stupid. And they bask in it.
And I hope Kristi Noem does put that
picture of herself on her Twitter, because
it actually looks better than she is.
Yeah.
So, guys, you know, Maz asked them,
what are they going to do next?
[00:11:57]
Like, rob little old ladies
or maybe shoot puppies?
Oh, right. Kristi Noem did shoot puppies.
And then she got the Department
of Homeland Security job afterwards,
after we all knew.
Well, why do you hire someone
like that for the cruelty?
[00:12:12]
Not despite the cruelty,
but because of the cruelty.
Oh, she's willing to shoot
innocent little puppies.
Perfect.
We'll get her to brutalize human beings.
The cruelty is growing and growing.
And this isn't cute.
So now five other states are going
to do it, and they're all.
[00:12:29]
I'm sure they're all going
to have stupid, goofy names.
Like Maz was saying.
The Texas, Mississippi, South Carolina
are among the states.
The Carolina catastrophe,
the Texas torture chamber, by the way,
those haven't come out yet,
and I'm afraid of giving them ideas.
[00:12:46]
And if you get right, if you think
if you're in the part of MAGA that thinks
that, oh, my God, the Texas torture
chamber sounds so amazing, you have
no idea what kind of bubble you're in.
The rest of the country
does not think torture chambers
[00:13:01]
sound awesome or American.
Okay.
And the polling seems to be indicating
that we are asking you guys, do you think
this cruelty towards immigrants
is going to backfire on Donald Trump?
We're asking that in the live chat shows,
live 6 to 8 p.m.
Monday through Friday, and 67% think it's
going to backfire in the polling so far.
[00:13:21]
It is backfiring.
They the American people,
just like look, Rogan said it.
A lot of people are saying it,
but I think that he nailed it on this one.
And as he's one of those podcasters
that went to Trump but had earlier
supported Bernie, so they are actually,
in my opinion, independent.
[00:13:37]
They lean right for sure. Right?
But when it comes to this issue,
he said, look, we signed up for getting
rid of undocumented criminals.
As Mars was talking about.
We signed up for closing the border.
We didn't sign up for gratuitous cruelty
and make us all look like jerks
[00:13:54]
and terrible people and abuse folks, etc.
And since they don't have due process,
we don't even know how many of them
are actually criminals.
So to do this to innocent people,
let alone guilty people,
it's just a nightmare in every way.
All right, finally,
I promised a little bit of good news.
[00:14:11]
So some of our staff
went to netroots recently.
That's a good progressive conference
that's put together every year.
And, and one of them ran into this woman.
I don't want to say her name
without getting permission.
But she found out.
Found out that you could actually
deliver food to Alligator Alcatraz.
[00:14:29]
So she started driving in,
to give them food over and over again,
because she heard that they were
getting food with maggots in it.
Right.
So there are a lot of people with
beautiful, open hearts in this country.
We want to do the right thing because this
is a good country, but this is not us.
[00:14:45]
And if you think this is
what America should be, I think you have
a really dark image of America.
And most Americans
don't share that dark image.
So there's got to be
political ramifications for this.
If you don't throw them out, they're going
to get encouraged and they're going to do
[00:15:01]
all of the things that we talked about,
and they're going to set up new torture
chambers, and they're going to say
to the rest of the world, yeah,
this is what America is now like this,
this force for darkness.
Don't do that.
Don't do that to this country.
And I think the great majority of us agree
that's not the right way to go.
[00:15:17]
Every time you ring the bell below,
an angel gets his wings.
Totally not true.
But it does keep you updated
on our live shows.
Now Playing (Clips)
Episode
Podcast
