Jul 1, 2025
Trump Tours Alligator Alcatraz
President Donald Trump visited a new immigration detention center in the Everglades dubbed, "Alligator Alcatraz ."
- 12 minutes
No one has gotten more heat from the left
for being in favor of law and order,
but at the same time, I will never,
ever be in favor of dehumanizing people
simply because they came to this country
with the hope of building
a better life for themselves.
The facility is in the heart of the
Everglades and will be informally known
[00:00:19]
as Alligator Alcatraz.
There is only one road leading in
and there is.
The only way out is a one way flight.
It is isolated and surrounded by dangerous
wildlife and unforgiving terrain.
The facility will have up to 5000 beds
to house, process and deport
[00:00:36]
criminal illegal aliens.
Because cruelty is the point.
Cruelty is the point. That was.
White House Press Secretary
Caroline Leavitt giddily,
giddily announcing that Trump
would be touring an intentionally inhumane
[00:00:52]
detention facility for migrants
that the administration
has dubbed Alligator Alcatraz.
Now, while she claims that it would hold
5000 criminal migrants.
Data that we've shared with you
on this show before,
in fact, we did so last week indicates
that the vast majority of immigrants,
[00:01:10]
undocumented individuals who have
been detained by the Trump administration,
have not been convicted
of or even accused of any crimes.
So calling them criminals is rich when
that's not actually what's happening here.
[00:01:25]
Now, before we get to more on this story,
just a reminder
of what Alligator Alcatraz is all about.
Alligator Alcatraz.
This 30 square mile area
is completely surrounded
by the Everglades, presents a efficient,
[00:01:42]
low cost opportunity to build a temporary
detention facility because you don't need
to invest that much in the perimeter.
People get out.
There's not much waiting for them
other than alligators and pythons.
Nowhere to go, nowhere to hide.
Now, Trump and Homeland
Security Secretary Kristi Noem
[00:02:00]
joined Florida Governor Ron DeSantis
for the opening of this controversial
immigrant detention facility.
It will cost about $450 million a year
to detain thousands of migrants
in this facility.
[00:02:15]
DeSantis administration used its emergency
powers to expedite 450 million per year
for this facility,
which DeSantis has said will be able to
hold up to 3000 undocumented immigrants.
Now, they're hoping that FEMA
will reimburse them for the $450 million
[00:02:36]
that it will cost each year to detain
undocumented immigrants in this facility.
The entire compound was constructed
in just seven days.
I'm sure that constructing something
in seven days
ensures that you know it's humanely.
[00:02:52]
It's going to treat
people humanely, right?
Human beings, look, at the end of the day,
these are human beings.
Like, I get that there are Republican
voters who, for whatever reason,
think that if someone is in the country
illegally, well, they're subhuman
and should be treated as such.
[00:03:07]
I disagree with that.
Yeah, I totally disagree with that.
But cruelty is the point here.
And the Trump administration
isn't even hiding that.
They think, okay, if we make this a
terrible place and undocumented immigrants
are fearful about ending up here,
maybe they'll self-deport.
[00:03:25]
That's the whole point.
Well, there's there's a second
political thing that they're doing,
which I think is a huge miscalculation.
So first, look,
what who's an undocumented immigrant?
So my family came over, with,
you know, in a documented fashion.
[00:03:43]
We did it, got a green card,
did everything right,
and then became citizens.
So it's easy for me to say,
like, hey, we waited in line.
They should wait in line.
Okay, sure they should.
And I don't think that they should
cross the border illegally.
And and I think we're right to to return
folks who are crossing illegally.
[00:04:01]
We're certainly right
if they're criminals.
And they came in here
and they committed crimes.
No, we don't have to house
criminals that came here.
No way. Right.
But that is that the average
undocumented immigrant?
No no no no no.
The way that the Trump and the Republicans
talk about it, it's like 98% of them are,
[00:04:20]
you know, from gangs.
That's not true at all.
It's a tiny percentage.
And as we've told you many times,
natural born citizens unfortunately
commit crime at a greater rate
than undocumented immigrants.
So proportionally they're
less likely to be criminals.
And it makes sense. You get why?
Because they're here.
They're worried about losing
their ability to stay here.
[00:04:37]
So they're a little bit more careful.
So who's the average guy
who's undocumented?
He's a guy who went through incredible
danger to get into this country.
Why?
To work his ass off for 80 hours a week
at much lower rates than you, so that he
could return money to his family at home.
[00:04:54]
Or maybe he brings his family here
to give opportunity to his kids.
You could say, hey,
he's doing it the wrong way.
Do you really want him eaten
by alligators?
No, but that's the thing.
Okay, so that's that's
what I want to talk about, right?
Because it's one thing to have a.
And by the way, if someone's been
in the country for decades,
[00:05:14]
they're undocumented, but they haven't
committed any crimes, and they're
like productive members of society.
We need to have a pathway
for citizenship for these people.
We do.
Right now,
you enter the country illegally,
even if you're here for decades.
There is no pathway
to citizenship for you.
It is insanely difficult and rare
for for that person to ever become
[00:05:34]
a citizen of this country.
So, I think we need to change that.
I think we desperately need
immigration reform.
But with that said, can we please not
dehumanize people simply because they're
in the country with undocumented status?
[00:05:51]
They're still human beings,
at the end of the day, treating them
as if they're again subhuman,
that they should be dehumanized,
that they should be put in a facility that
doesn't care about human rights at all.
That's inhumane.
I just think is wrong
and it doesn't speak well of the country.
[00:06:08]
I want to be proud
of the country I live in, I get it.
Law and order.
No one has gotten more heat from the left
for being in favor of law and order,
but at the same time, I will never,
ever be in favor of dehumanizing people
simply because they came to this country
[00:06:24]
with the hope of building
a better life for themselves.
Yeah.
So look, guys, we read
in civics class, history class.
We're all grown up
about indentured servants, right?
So there was slavery, and then there
was indentured servants, and they
would bring them over and they had
to serve seven years, for their master.
[00:06:39]
Right.
And but they would get the housing
and stuff and, and then at the end,
they would get to stay in America.
And we learned that as something cruel,
just just a tiny bit under slavery, right?
Well, not a tiny bit, because only seven
years versus your whole life and slavery
[00:06:56]
was just the worst thing in the world.
But still, it was
in that same sentence, right?
Now they tried Pathway to Citizenship or
a bunch of years ago, they were going to
make it so that you had to serve 14 years,
twice as long as indentured servants.
[00:07:11]
Right.
And in a similar way, yeah, you
get housing and you get some wages, etc.,
but it's much lower
than if you were a citizen, etc..
And then in the pathway to citizenship,
after twice as long, you'd get to stay
and be a US citizen, right?
[00:07:27]
And they said that was too lenient.
Twice indentured servitude.
Too lenient. Right?
No it's not it's not too lenient.
That's crazy.
You need to have if we're going
to bring these people in because we
need the cheap labor to keep it real.
That's why they're here, right?
[00:07:42]
Then let's make a rational,
conscious decision and say, okay, if you
serve this amount of time working your ass
off in the hardest jobs in the world.
Yes, you get a pathway to citizenship,
but you got to follow the rules
and all of that, right?
You serve in the military
like they're there.
[00:07:58]
Again, it's not saying, oh, you entered
the country illegally and you've
just been here for X number of years.
So we're just going to give you a pass.
No, we you pass legislation
that ensures that they contribute
something specific, right.
Whether it's serving in the military
doing community service,
[00:08:16]
I don't know and I don't care.
My point is it is not a good look
when we have a government that seems
very giddy about dehumanizing people.
Yeah. Okay.
That leads to the political calculation
point that I was going to make, Ana.
I think that they genuinely think
these MAGA guys, the Trump,
[00:08:34]
the Stephen Miller, etc., that they think
that the country overall is as cruel
as the radical right is and as they are.
So they really think
this is going to play well.
That's why they're hyping it up.
That's why they've been talking
about the videos he goes to.
[00:08:51]
You think it's an accident?
The president is visiting it.
No, they're trying to market it.
- They're marketing it.
- As aggressively as they can.
And what they're announcing to the
citizens is we're super sick, cruel people
who like to not just take care of problems
we have, but to dehumanize people,
[00:09:07]
belittle them, and maybe have them eaten
by alligators because, you know, Trump
is Nero, or some sort of, like, twisted
Roman emperor who's lost his frickin mind.
So they think that the country loves that.
I think they're going to see soon.
[00:09:22]
The country does not love
that your radical right loves that.
And that's what I voted for.
Immigrants eaten by alligators, right?
But no, 80% of the country
doesn't want that.
So he's kind of walking himself into
a disaster politically, if you ask me.
[00:09:38]
But at some point, those independents
who voted for him have got to go.
Oh, right.
No, this is not good for me.
This is terrible.
It's not good for anybody.
Okay, final thing I'm going to say
about this story.
There was a 75 year old Cuban man
that was detained by Ice.
[00:09:57]
He's been in the country
or was in the country for 60 years.
He died in Ice custody.
Tom Homan was asked about it.
Trump's border czar.
And he totally minimized it. Yeah.
People die. People die in prison.
[00:10:14]
People die in detention.
That was a human being. 75 year old man.
Really? That's our enemy.
That's the guy who needs to be detained
and thrown into detention.
He's been in the country for 60 years.
[00:10:30]
Guys, the Roman analogy
is a little like on the nose because the
Romans fed the Christians to the lions.
And are they going to take that poor Cuban
guy and feed him to the alligators?
I mean, they're literally talking about
feeding human beings to alligators.
[00:10:47]
There's this America. This is America.
- There's more.
- This is sick.
Former Trump administration official Ken
Cuccinelli told CNN anchor Jake Tapper,
quote, we're all going to die.
And that was in response to a question
about the death
of the 75 year old Cuban man.
[00:11:06]
All right.
If this is the cruelty you signed up for.
- Okay.
- Cruelty is the point.
Yeah, well, look yourself
in the mirror, man.
And are you the moral one?
You're the moral one.
I don't think so.
By the way, Cuban Americans
are a huge, huge part of the MAGA base
[00:11:24]
and Republican base.
I don't know if the Republican Party
really wants to brand themselves this way,
but I do think that there will be
political consequences.
Back in the day, the Republicans would be
like, oh no, the Cubans, the Venezuelans,
the North Koreans,
anyone escaping communism is welcome here.
[00:11:41]
Now they changed their mind on that. Yeah.
So and by the way, if you're a Venezuelan
that escaped from Venezuela
or Cuban or whatever, and you thought
you were safe, brother, they still think
you're not the same as them.
Yeah. And so.
And you're about to find out.
[00:11:56]
And so. Okay.
You know, if you're MAGA.
Enjoy the alligators.
I hope soon you're going
to be the only ones.
Right.
And if if you're not MAGA
and you're the rest of the country,
we got to get these guys out of here.
I mean,
is this what we're going to become?
[00:12:12]
Are we okay with this?
That other countries think, oh, yeah,
if you go to America, they'll feed you
to the alligators because they're nuts.
There are sick people who like to feed
people to the lions or gators or whatever.
And in fact, Trump was talking about
bringing crocodiles and alligators back
into the Rio Grande so that they could
eat people trying to cross the river.
[00:12:31]
I mean, what is he, Doctor evil?
This is so maniacal, so stupid.
Every time you ring the bell below,
an angel gets his wings.
Totally not true.
But it does keep you updated
on our live shows.
Now Playing (Clips)
Episode
Podcast
The Young Turks: July 1, 2025
- 17 minutes
- 13 minutes
- 13 minutes
- 12 minutes
- 9 minutes
- 6 minutes
- 4 minutes