May 21, 2025
There's ONE Major Issue That Americans Really Don't Care About
Polling reveals that the majority of Americans don't really care about the deficit.
- 16 minutes
Cut taxes even if the deficit increases.
Look at this 60% overall.
Say cut those taxes, baby.
What about Republicans?
You know, they're the ones who are
supposedly so concerned over the deficit,
but even there, 74% say cut taxes
even if the deficit increases.
[00:00:19]
That's amazing.
Most Americans are not worried
about the deficit.
And honestly, who can blame them?
Because the deficit hasn't
really hurt us too much yet.
Now,
yet is an interesting way of putting it.
Of course, Moody's just recently came out
and lowered America's
[00:00:39]
Triple-A credit rating, meaning that they
have less confidence that the United
States government will pay its debts.
They're worried that there's
a higher risk that the U.S.
Could default on its debt.
That's pretty terrifying.
Now, to be fair, this is the third time
[00:00:58]
the US credit rating has dropped and the
past two times it was mostly symbolic.
It didn't end up being a disaster.
I believe 2011 was the previous,
more recent time
that our credit rating was lowered,
but it doesn't really inspire confidence.
[00:01:18]
Moody's did this in response
to Trump's big, beautiful bill.
They're worried that because of how much
debt it will add to the ballooning U.S.
Debt, which is at $36 trillion, it's going
to make it more and more expensive
for the United States to service its debt.
[00:01:35]
Last year,
we paid close to $1 trillion to do so.
That's a problem, and it's not something
that most Americans are feeling yet.
But it could balloon to a point
where they're going to feel it.
So with that in mind, look, they're not
worried about the deficit because what's
[00:01:53]
hurting them in the immediate environment
is, the fact that they don't have
a lot of money in their pockets.
This economy
is crushing a lot of Americans.
And they want they want
a little bit of relief.
So the idea of paying a little less
in taxes is exciting for Americans.
[00:02:10]
And so I want to get into that.
So, here's how Americans
felt like 30 years ago.
Americans
might have felt a little differently.
So Harry Enten decided to delve
into that polling from last December
that showed how voters want the tax cuts,
regardless of how it impacts the deficit.
[00:02:28]
And that is a massive change
from how Americans felt about
the deficit only 30 years ago.
All right.
So things do change.
And here's what I mean.
Cut taxes even at the deficit increases.
Now, you know,
it's that 60% we spoke about.
But back in 1996, the real last time
where there really was a movement to bring
[00:02:47]
that deficit down, bring that debt down,
it was just 23% who said cut taxes
even if the deficit increases.
So we've clearly seen a tripling, far more
than doubling of the percentage of
Americans who say that we should cut those
taxes, even if the deficit increases.
[00:03:04]
And that's where we're standing right now.
Basically, amongst the American public.
Who says 996 instead of 1996?
Harry Enten does.
Look, I think Harry Enten
does a great job with broadcasting,
and I love that he delves into these polls
and shows like the historical context,
[00:03:23]
because, yeah, things have changed.
I suspect that things have changed because
Americans are feeling more crushed by the
economy today than they did in the past.
I and look, this is all speculation.
I don't have evidence to back what I'm
about to say up, but just based on my own
[00:03:39]
personal feelings lately about taxes.
Look, no one likes to pay taxes
like everyone would like to keep more of
their money in their pockets, obviously.
However, I'm also very much open
to paying more in taxes.
[00:03:54]
If the money specifically goes towards
social programs, that improves the lives
of my fellow Americans.
I want to improve this country.
I want the lives of Americans
to be better.
Now, if there is a program, it's detailed.
You know it's going to be well run.
[00:04:13]
You know that there isn't a grift
associated with it where nonprofits
are going to leech off that money
and pad their own pockets with it.
I'm all for it.
But where where have our taxes been going?
Really?
I'm happy that there's a specific line
in my pay stub
[00:04:31]
that shows how much of my paycheck
went specifically to Social Security.
Love Social Security.
It's a great universal program.
We need to increase
that cap on taxing income
so Social Security can remain solvent.
[00:04:48]
But Social Security, great. Medicaid?
Great.
But a lot of our tax dollars
go toward pork barrel spending
that I ain't got any interest in, that the
American people ain't got any interest in.
But those programs or those little pork
barrel things like keep getting funded.
[00:05:07]
We keep seeing our money go toward defense
contractors, weapons manufacturers,
you know, the Pentagon,
which can't pass a single audit, not one.
They haven't passed a single audit, guys.
And then compounding this issue for me
personally, is living in the state
[00:05:26]
of California, where we pay the highest
taxes, highest tax state in LA. It's the
highest tax city in the highest tax state.
And our governor,
Gavin Newsom just announced we have
a $12 billion budget deficit.
[00:05:43]
And unlike the federal government, states
actually have to balance the budget.
They have no other choice.
How is the highest tax state
facing a $12 billion budget deficit?
You want to know
what Gavin Newsom wants to do.
[00:06:00]
He's going to get
the state Medicaid program.
This is his proposal.
If you are so poor that you qualify
for the state Medicaid program
known as Medi-Cal, he wants the recipients
to pay a $100 a month premium.
[00:06:19]
You mismanaged the state's resources,
and you're going to take it out
on the poorest people in the state.
Just absolute scumbag.
So look, Americans would like to keep
more of their money, likely because it
[00:06:35]
will help them with their own finances,
of course, but also because they look at
the government, they see where their money
is going, and they're not happy by it.
They're not happy about it.
And I don't blame them.
Who can? Who can blame them?
Americans keep paying
more and more in taxes.
They see their quality of life diminish.
Who can blame them?
[00:06:53]
Now, obviously here I'm talking
about working class Americans
when it comes to corporations.
When it comes to the wealthiest among us,
they get to enjoy all sorts of little tax
breaks and deductions that ordinary
working class people don't get to enjoy.
[00:07:08]
And I think it's unfair
that if we're going to pay taxes,
oftentimes they pay a far smaller
percentage of their income in federal
taxes compared to working class Americans.
That unfairness needs
to something needs to be done about that.
[00:07:24]
Now, obviously, you have lawmakers
heeding the warning that fear mongering
about the deficit is not going
to play well with the American people.
So I want to give you a sense
of how their messaging
and what their priorities happen to be.
[00:07:40]
So while Republicans want
to cut Medicaid to lower the deficit,
Bernie Sanders doesn't.
This is what he wrote on X.
There are 85 million Americans
who are uninsured or underinsured.
So embarrassing that that's the case.
Republicans want to make a bad situation
worse by slashing Medicaid in order to
[00:07:58]
give massive tax breaks to billionaires.
Wrong.
We should do what other major countries do
and guarantee health care for all.
Now look, there were various analyzes
done in regard to Medicare for all when
Bernie Sanders was running for president.
[00:08:15]
And I remember when a libertarian think
tank came out with their analysis
and it showed that a Medicare
for all system was actually going to save
like $2 trillion in ten years.
So, I mean, we pay more
than any other developed country
[00:08:31]
for our health care, and we get less.
We have a higher percentage
of our population
that is underinsured or uninsured.
Hakeem Jeffries didn't go nearly as far,
but still honed in on the issue of
Medicaid cuts, saying Donald Trump is on
the hill to demand that House Republicans
[00:08:49]
end Medicaid as we know it in America.
They can all get lost. Oh, yeah.
You really you really showed him.
Now, look, there are other reports.
I want to be fair here indicating
that Trump told Republicans in the House,
don't f around with Medicaid.
[00:09:06]
We'll see what ends up happening, right?
I don't know who to believe,
especially when it's anonymous sources
telling reporters that that's
what Trump is saying behind the scenes.
We also heard that Biden was pressuring
Israel to do a cease fire, and that turned
out to be complete and utter lies.
[00:09:23]
So I'll believe it when I see it.
However, Alyssa Farah Griffin
and Republican strategist
Shermichael Singleton
think that messaging is a dud as well.
Why? Well, let's take a look.
There's kind of been so much posturing.
If they're going to slash this, they're
going to slash this until people feel it.
[00:09:40]
I feel like it can kind of feel
like empty noise from the.
I agree 150%.
And if you're Democrats, I think you have
to be careful here because from
Republicans, I would argue we could frame
this as if you're an able bodied person,
should that person go out and work?
Most people would say,
well, hell yeah, they should work.
[00:09:56]
We're not saying that if you don't
make enough beyond a certain threshold,
that you shouldn't still be able
to tap into a safety net.
Got millions of people
are going to lose benefits.
- They can lean on that.
- They can.
But I just don't know how effective that's
going to be when the average person
is saying, I'm working my butt off.
Everybody else should
also be out there working.
[00:10:12]
You know?
That statement from Shermichael Singleton
is pretty accurate, actually, right?
I think that there's a lot of resentment
right now among working class Americans
who are barely getting by.
And unfortunately,
there's a lot of propaganda out there
[00:10:28]
that makes it appear as though people are
getting paid to be lazy bums and not work.
It's important to know
what the reality is, though,
because that resentment, unfortunately
comes from a place of being misinformed.
You know, of course you're always going
to have bad people take advantage.
[00:10:46]
And but the important thing is
you have to take a step back
and look at what the trends are.
Is this a wide scale issue
when it comes to Medicaid recipients?
And the fact of the matter is, it's not.
Now, unfortunately, more than 60%
of voters, including 47% of Democrats,
[00:11:04]
support the idea of a work requirement
in order to receive Medicaid.
Work requirements are significantly more
popular than straight up cuts to Medicaid,
which is good, right?
I mean, it's not good that people
are like, look, I'm not
[00:11:20]
against work requirements necessarily.
I'm against the idea that Medicaid
recipients are all like lazy bums
who don't want to work
and are taking advantage of the system.
Like, I find that so offensive,
especially because of what I know
[00:11:36]
and what the data shows.
And Americans are really
hard working people.
Generally speaking.
Americans want to feel
they have a purpose in life.
They don't want to sit around
and do nothing all day.
Yes, you're going to find examples
of people who do fall under that category.
[00:11:52]
But I'm talking about generally Americans
want to, you know, have a purpose in life.
So let's get to the work environment.
Work work requirements and how they fare
compared to straight up cuts to Medicaid.
So just 17% of respondents said
they supported cuts to Medicaid, 40% said
[00:12:13]
they wanted to keep spending unchanged,
and 42% said they would like it increased.
So that might be due to misconceptions
about the program.
That's why I get irritated
by this conversation or this whole debate,
because guess what?
A majority, 62% of the public incorrectly
[00:12:31]
believe that most working age adults on
Medicaid are unemployed, but they're not.
So like about 40, I'm sorry,
64% of Medicaid recipients are either
working full time jobs or part time jobs.
[00:12:47]
The rest of the individuals who are
not working are either going to school,
or they are caretakers for elderly
or elderly family members or individuals
who have fallen ill in their family.
So the way that the work requirements
are currently being proposed for
[00:13:06]
this reconciliation reconciliation bill.
You work, what, 40 hours?
I believe it was for the whole month.
And you would qualify for Medicaid.
Well, nothing would change.
The only thing that would change if the
bill passes with those work requirements,
[00:13:22]
is that there would be extra paperwork
for recipients to have to file to get
approved for Medicaid, and some people
might have difficulty with that paperwork.
Some people might have
a difficult time navigating.
However, their state sets
up the bureaucracy in order to carry
[00:13:38]
out that program in order to check
to make sure they're working.
And if it's too difficult, it might serve
as an obstacle between them and getting
the health care that they're entitled to
and that health care that they need.
And that is what happens technically
or typically, I should say some states,
[00:13:55]
by the way, don't want to do
the work requirements because guess what?
You have to prop up a bureaucratic system
to process applications and do the checks
to make sure these people are working,
and that cost tens of millions
of dollars in Georgia cost $40 million,
[00:14:11]
according to one analysis.
So it ends up actually costing more
in taxpayer money to do
this work requirement program than not.
So let's get to seven years ago,
where the state of Arkansas tried
to implement Medicaid work requirements.
[00:14:28]
And here's how it turned out.
The state used the requirements
to remove 18,000 adults from the Medicaid
rolls in just four months.
Yet subsequent studies found
that it had no positive employment effect.
And when you take a look
at who received Medicaid in 2022,
[00:14:47]
let's take a look at that.
Look at that. 46% were either children
or 65 years old and up,
meaning they were elderly.
Of the remaining 54%,
only 6% were not working long term.
[00:15:02]
That's just 3% of all Medicaid recipients.
So that was an analysis that was done
using Census Bureau
information back in 2022.
We'll see how this whole bill ends up,
but it's definitely not going
[00:15:19]
to balance the budget, that's for sure.
But on top of that, I think what's being
targeted by the Republican Party kind
of shows you what their priorities are.
I mean, there are definitely areas
where we can save a lot of money.
Maybe we stop, you know,
funding foreign wars.
[00:15:35]
That's one possibility.
Maybe we allow our Medicaid Medicare
system to negotiate pharmaceutical drug
prices so American taxpayers aren't
getting fleeced on pharmaceutical drugs.
But notice how those are the areas
that are totally being neglected
[00:15:52]
when it comes to balancing the budget.
Nickel and diming the American people
on health care programs is pretty sick,
but that's what they're focusing on.
And Americans don't
care about the deficit.
Every time you ring the bell below,
an angel gets its wings.
[00:16:07]
Totally not true, but it does
keep you updated on our live shows.
Now Playing (Clips)
Episode
Podcast
The Young Turks: May 21, 2025
- 10 minutes
- 18 minutes
- 10 minutes
- 16 minutes
- 19 minutes
- 5 minutes
- 9 minutes