May 15, 2025
Rep. Tlaib Makes EMOTIONAL Plea For Gaza In Floor Speech
Rep. Rashida Tlaib broke down in tears on the House floor over the "genocide" in Gaza.
- 36 minutes
There are days that I feel so alone
in this chamber as the only
Palestinian American serving in Congress.
The dehumanization and the
anti-palestinian racism here is painful,
especially when my colleagues remain
silent on the starvation of children
[00:00:15]
and vote to send more bombs
to the Israeli government while they
commit war crimes with impunity.
I pray that the ongoing Nakba
against the Palestinians will end.
[00:00:30]
And one day they will be free.
Representative Rashida Tlaib,
the first Palestinian American woman to
serve in Congress, broke down in tears on
the House floor on Thursday as she talked
about the plight of Palestinians in Gaza.
[00:00:45]
She called out Netanyahu
and her fellow Congress members for
refusing to put an end to the genocide.
Take a look.
Israeli forces have killed
more than 52,000 Palestinians, and nearly
70% of them were women and children.
[00:01:02]
Babies who will not.
Did not live to see their first birthday.
There are thousands more
who are dismembered.
Unrecognizable. Burned alive.
Buried beneath the rubble
and presumed dead.
Each year, our country sends billions of
dollars to maintain this apartheid state
[00:01:18]
and support the ongoing ethnic cleansing
of the Palestinian people.
Our country is complicit, Mr. Speaker,
because our nation
is funding this genocide.
The Israeli government will not stop
until we place an arms embargo.
Majority of Americans support it.
[00:01:34]
We must save lives,
no matter faith or ethnicity.
A child is a child.
Despite her pleas and the wishes of most
Americans, we will continue to aid Israel.
And Donald Trump is now
once again signaling
[00:01:51]
that the US is going to participate
in ethnically cleansing Palestinians.
- But before we get to that Jank.
- Yeah, it's a huge caveat there.
There's actually three different options
for what they could do with Gaza.
One's a disaster. One is fantastic.
[00:02:07]
And then the third one is frustrating
and will not get to the right result.
I'm afraid they're going
to do the third one.
But after Jordan gives you
all the details here and oh my God,
the genocide here is unreal.
Now 72 days of starvation.
So world going to do anything.
[00:02:24]
It's it's the cruelty of this
current Israeli government is unbearable.
And so those three options are going
to determine everything.
And which way does Trump go.
And Trump's going to decide
this thing not Netanyahu.
[00:02:41]
Trump is and he's a giant wild card.
So let's tell you about the current state
of the disaster in Gaza.
And it's as bad as it as it has ever been.
And then let's talk about
is it going to get better or worse?
And like I said, don't lose hope
because there is one alternative
[00:02:58]
where this thing turns positive
in a totally unexpected way.
Now, Donald Trump's messaging
on what his intentions are for Gaza
have been all over the place.
But during a meeting with Netanyahu
in April, he said this.
[00:03:13]
Having a peace force
like the United States there,
controlling and owning the Gaza Strip
would be a good thing, because right now,
all it is, is for years and years.
All I hear about is killing
and Hamas and problems.
And if you take the people,
the Palestinians, and move them around
[00:03:30]
to different countries, and you have
plenty of countries that will do that,
and you really have a freedom,
a freedom zone, you call it the freedom
zone, a free zone, a zone where people
aren't going to be killed every day.
That's a hell of a place.
It's a, you know what I call it a great
location that nobody wants to live in.
[00:03:52]
And yesterday, he doubled down
during a meeting with business leaders
in Qatar, he told the press.
Gaza has been a territory
of death and destruction for many years.
I have concepts for Gaza
and I think are very good.
Make it a freedom zone.
[00:04:08]
Let the United States get involved
and make it just a freedom zone.
I'd be proud to have
the United States have it.
Take it. Make it a freedom zone.
He described aerial images he'd seen
of the widespread destruction
from Israeli airstrikes on Gaza, and said
there's practically no building standing.
[00:04:29]
It's not like you're trying
to save something.
His comments come
as the death toll surpasses 53,000,
and that is just an estimate.
And the Israeli military
is intensifying operations across Gaza.
They killed more than 100
people just today and are pledging
[00:04:47]
to continue the bombings.
And now Netanyahu is just outright saying
that his goal is
to drive the Palestinians out.
He said this earlier this week.
We are destroying more and more homes.
They have nowhere to return to.
[00:05:02]
The only inevitable outcome
will be the desire of Gazans
to emigrate outside of the Gaza Strip.
You hear Netanyahu's intent
just completely destroy it.
Drive everyone out.
[00:05:18]
I don't know how I could look at Trump's,
you know, freedom zone proposal
and find any room for encouragement.
- So what are we missing here?
- Yeah, yeah.
First of all,
let me discourage you further,
and then I'll get to the encouragement.
Okay.
So option number one is we do what Israel
orders us to do, which is Americans go
[00:05:37]
in there and push the Palestinians out.
That's the original Netanyahu plan.
So God forbid an Israeli should get hurt
during the ethnic cleansing.
And he was trying to hey, he's like,
hey, Miriam gave you all this money
over $300 million.
Now you pay us back by Americans dying
and and being guilty of the genocide
[00:05:57]
and the ethnic cleansing,
and then the two places
that they would push them to
is either the ruins of Rafah or completely
out of Gaza into other countries.
Now, if you think that that's hyperbole,
they're not really going to I mean,
that's literally the textbook
definition of ethnic cleansing.
[00:06:13]
Yeah.
So let me share with you a reporting from
drop Site News, Jeremy Scahill reporting
here that shows you that is definitively
what they're planning to do.
And in fact, they actually say it
and brag about it.
And then I'll get you
to the two other options, okay.
Scahill reports Hamas will lay
down its weapons, its leaders.
[00:06:31]
This is a Netanyahu statement
to his cabinet.
Hamas will lay down its weapons.
Its leaders will be allowed to leave.
We will see to the general security
in the Gaza Strip
and will allow the realization
of the Trump plan for voluntary migration,
[00:06:46]
he told his cabinet,
referring to Trump's threat to seize Gaza
and remove Palestinians from their land.
And he said, quote, this is the plan.
We are not hiding this.
So they first say, look,
we want the hostages back.
[00:07:02]
Wink.
Our own envoy, Steve Witkoff, said,
no, they don't want the hostages back.
Israel is delaying peace.
They're the ones
who want to continue the war.
Okay, so he says, yeah, well, we,
you know, we want the hostages back,
but that's not good enough.
[00:07:18]
We also want everyone in Hamas
who we don't know who they are,
to come out somehow and surrender.
And presumably they'll be either sent
to prison or executed.
And so they're going
to all voluntarily do that.
And then Israel is going to say,
okay, we are satisfied enough that all
[00:07:35]
of Hamas has come out and said this,
and Palestine will never be allowed to
exist as a state, and we will occupy Gaza.
So if Hamas agrees to all of that,
then we can get to a peace deal.
Who would agree to a permanent occupation
and give away their land?
[00:07:53]
By definition, that is not at all
possible, because that's just saying,
okay, we'll give you 100% on what you want
and because we're what otherwise.
And you know what Netanyahu is saying.
Otherwise we'll kill you all
or just drive you out militarily anyway.
[00:08:10]
And he says, this is the plan.
We're not hiding this.
But if you're not convinced,
hold on, hold on.
There's a lot more.
Scahill says on May 4th,
the Israeli cabinet approved a plan,
codenamed Operation Gideon's Chariot,
that it threatened to implement
if Hamas did not capitulate
to Israel's demands by the time Trump
finished his tour of the Gulf.
[00:08:28]
Its explicit aim would be, quote,
the conquest of the Gaza Strip, an
open ended occupation enforced by, quote,
wide scale attacks and the destruction
of Gaza's remaining infrastructure.
Palestinians
would be herded into the wasteland
[00:08:43]
of what was once Rafah in southern Gaza.
So they're saying if you don't agree
to everything Israel wants,
including your own subjugation
and the theft of your own land,
we're going to drive you into the ruins
of Rafah and ethnically cleanse
[00:09:03]
the rest of Gaza Strip and take it.
And it is a conquest.
So we told you that
that was their intention.
And when we said that,
what did people say?
Anti-semite.
How dare you talk about Israel
potentially taking Gaza Strip?
[00:09:19]
They are the most moral army in the world.
They would never do that.
This is only because of self-defense
from an attack from years and years ago.
And so we had to murder 53,000 civilians.
Sorry. There's a couple of Hamas in there.
[00:09:35]
They've never proven that anyone outside
of Hamas leadership was ever killed.
But okay, let's assume
there's some Hamas in there.
But the overwhelming
majority of civilians.
Two thirds are women and children.
Approximately 18,000 children
killed by the IDF.
[00:09:52]
Pretending this is about self-defense.
I wouldn't kill one child, let alone
18,000 children for self-defense, I'd say.
You know what? Kill me instead.
If the choice is between me
and 18,000 children.
Really? That's a hard choice for me.
I guess it is.
[00:10:08]
I guess for a lot of people
who have no morality at all.
None whatsoever.
They go, yeah, who cares?
It's just Palestinian children.
Just keep murdering them.
We'll just blame it on Hamas.
Okay, so they're not done
with their confessions.
So if you're an Israeli supporter,
I'm expecting an apology.
[00:10:26]
I told you they were going to try to take
Gaza, and you pretended that they weren't.
Not pretending to be fair.
A lot of Israeli supporters,
they genuinely believe it.
They really believe it.
And even as they see with their own eyes
and hear with their own ears
that Netanyahu is saying,
yeah, it's a goddamn conquest.
[00:10:41]
- Of course we're going to take the land.
- They're like, no.
It can't be, it can't be.
Israel is the most moral nation that's
ever been created, so it can't be that.
My. My eyes must be lying to me.
Or it's all Hamas numbers. It's all Hamas.
It's all human shields. It's all property.
[00:10:58]
What?
What's the next propaganda line?
I have no.
They're taking the goddamn land!
We were right.
Every supporter of Israel
that pretended that again.
Sorry.
Not pretended they genuinely
believed that they weren't.
You were wrong.
So are you ever going to say it?
No, no.
Israel's the one country
that can never be criticized.
[00:11:15]
Jesus, man.
All right, they can continue.
Here's Netanyahu quote.
There will be no situation
where we stop the war.
I don't know how it could
be clearer than that.
He says the situation has changed.
In the coming days, we will go in with
full force to complete the operation.
[00:11:34]
Completing the operation
means subduing Hamas.
It means destroying Hamas.
When he says subduing
and destroying Hamas, he explained earlier
that means the conquest of Gaza.
That means the ethnic cleansing of Gaza.
And that means Israel declaring
Gaza their own
[00:11:52]
after they drive the Palestinians out.
This is a sick terrorist running a nation,
and we're funding him endlessly.
Blank check. After blank check.
Mr.. Terrorists, what would you like?
Oh, you're going to murder more children,
or are you going to do genocide
and ethnic cleansing?
[00:12:08]
Oh, yes. Right away, sir.
Biden. Yes.
Kamala Harris. Yes.
Donald Trump, yes.
So far. But hold.
Okay.
Last quote here from Scahill,
a drop site news.
Netanyahu added that Israel has set
up a mechanism to coordinate the removal
of Palestinians from Gaza, saying,
quote, the main issue is this we need
[00:12:27]
host countries willing to absorb them.
That's what we're working on right now.
So in other words, we're going
to drive them all out of Gaza,
and we're going to push them
either into the Sinai desert
or whichever other Arab country
is willing to take them, and we're just
[00:12:44]
going to steal all of their land in Gaza.
And yes, it is stealing.
It is definitely stealing the land.
And and then. And who cares?
Kill him, kill him.
Drive him out, ethnically. Cleanse them.
[00:12:59]
This is genocide 101.
So now, Rashida Tlaib, before, if she
had said genocide, apartheid, ethnic
cleansing, she would have been sanctioned.
They would have said,
oh, that is terrible anti-Semitism.
You're not allowed to say things
that are true about Israel.
Sanctioned.
[00:13:15]
Sanctioned. Right.
But she wasn't sanctioned.
That's interesting.
Why?
Well, a couple of things have happened.
Number one,
now the genocide is utterly indisputable.
If you're disputing
that it's a genocide, okay.
I mean, you could dispute that the sky
is blue and the grass is green,
[00:13:30]
but you sound like a lunatic.
I mean, if this isn't a genocide,
what the hell is?
They're declaring it.
They're like saying, yeah,
we will drive them all out and we'll kill
as many as we need to to take their land.
How much clearer does it have to be?
[00:13:46]
Okay, so what is it? It's indisputable.
It doesn't matter.
Congress totally works for Israel anyway.
They can dispute the indisputable.
But one of the reasons she's not
being sanctioned is because the right wing
is starting to swing.
And the Tucker Carlson and so many others,
Marjorie Taylor Greene,
[00:14:01]
she came on the show and said we should we
shouldn't give any more money to Israel.
I'm not sure I've ever heard a Republican
politician in my lifetime say that.
Tom Massie, I suppose, probably said that.
But outside of that, I mean, they worked
[00:14:17]
100% for the state of Israel, not for us.
So now all of a sudden,
their media is changing,
some of their politicians are changing.
So all of a sudden, she's not sanctioned.
Israel is beginning to lose some power.
So that brings us to option number two.
[00:14:34]
Trump went and talked to Qatar,
Saudi Arabia, UAE.
That was just what this tour was about.
But he left Israel out,
which is already stunning.
Usually you go to Israel,
you kiss the ring of Netanyahu
or whoever's the Israeli prime minister,
and then you go, Israel's the greatest
thing that's ever been created.
Then you go to the Arab countries
and you give a generally
[00:14:51]
insulting speech publicly, and then you
do some begrudging deal with them.
Okay.
But at the end of the day,
you're going to do a deal
because they got a lot of money.
Okay.
But Trump has totally flipped that.
So he doesn't go to Israel.
He goes to the Arab countries.
Then he goes and starts
taking money from them.
Right.
[00:15:06]
And so number one,
he's got the $400 million jet from Qatar.
That's going to be Air Force One.
Number two, he's got several billion
dollar deals he's doing with Qatar
and some of the other countries,
including Saudi Arabia.
So he's just personally benefiting.
So he's like, you know, Trump.
He's like, wait,
I want to be known for peace.
[00:15:24]
And these guys are giving me
billions of dollars.
Where's the question?
But wait, the Adelsons
gave you over 300 million.
He's like, yeah, that was yesterday.
And if you don't know that, I stiff
investors, you're a bit of an idiot.
So that's why Netanyahu and Trump won.
He came in like, I own you.
I own you, right?
[00:15:44]
And then all of a sudden,
Trump starts defying him.
He's like, wait, wait, what happened?
What happened?
I thought we purchased you.
That was yesterday.
Brother Trump never,
ever cares about his investors.
He always screws them.
So now he's like,
the Arabs are offering me more money.
[00:16:02]
I guess that's a sad day for you.
So now, when he brought our freedom zone,
Jordan, within the context of those
speeches and the context of those deals.
And by the way, the other thing is he got
$142 billion arms deal with the Saudis.
So I don't know that we should be
giving the Saudis and these dictatorships
[00:16:20]
in the Gulf all of these weapons.
But we are.
And our defense contractors
are going to make a killing from it.
And by the way, Jordan,
that's another huge part of the puzzle.
It's not just Trump.
Part of the reason why we support
Israel so much is,
you know, the conspiracy theories about,
oh, the Jews are on everything.
No, no, no, no.
[00:16:35]
There's also
huge Christian Zionist voting bloc.
But even more important
is the military industrial complex.
So they're like, oh,
America is going to pass all these bills
that give 20 billion to Israel.
But really it's
so that Israel can buy our weapons.
[00:16:51]
So it's going to the defense contractors.
Then Israel is getting
those weapons, right.
So Israel is super happy.
The defense contractors are super happy.
And they don't want
that gravy train to end.
But now Trump comes in and goes,
I got a better gravy train.
We're going to arm the Arabs to the teeth.
[00:17:07]
Okay, you guys are going to make a killing
before you're making tens of billions.
Now you're going to make
hundreds of billions all of
a sudden Raytheon, Lockheed Martin, etc..
Like, you know what?
Israel's kind of optional
all of a sudden Israel is optional, right?
And so when he talked about Freedom zone,
in that context, there's this.
[00:17:26]
The second plan is the US goes in,
but we go in with Arab countries
and the Arab countries,
then run it so that Hamas doesn't
and the Palestinian Authority doesn't.
And that leads to an
independent Palestinian state.
Oh, that would be amazing.
[00:17:43]
And there's no reason not to do that.
None none none.
And by the way, if he does that,
they'll build statues of him
all over the Middle East.
And overnight, the entire Middle East
will turn into our allies,
and he'll win the Nobel Peace Prize.
[00:17:59]
Those are. I'm not kidding.
And I'm not exaggerating.
If he created it,
got actual peace in the Middle East and
created an independent Palestinian state,
guaranteed Nobel Peace Prize.
Where's the downside?
Oh, the Israeli lobby
won't give you money anymore.
He's not going to run anyway.
There's no downside at all.
[00:18:18]
Okay, the third option, unfortunately,
is sounds halfway okay, but is disastrous.
Third option is they
say there's a peace deal.
You get the hostages back. That's good.
Israel doesn't occupy the US occupies bad.
[00:18:33]
And eventually there's loose talk of a
Palestinian state at an undetermined time.
And and whether they'll ever be actually
have sovereignty in their own military
is left to the future,
in which case, Netanyahu is going
to find 8000 ways to destroy that deal.
[00:18:49]
It'll never happen.
They'll just wait Trump out
and the next establishment politician
will do whatever Israel commands.
So it's got to be option
number two, Jordan.
The fact that option two
now exists is amazing.
It's never happened in my lifetime before.
[00:19:05]
And potentially an upside
of Donald Trump's corruption.
Okay. What do you think?
Oh, no.
I have zero hope that Trump would be
involved in any legitimate peace plan.
I think I think we've seen enough from him
to know that that is all a farce.
[00:19:21]
This idea that Donald Trump
is some diplomat and peacenik
has shown time and time again,
time and time again to be untrue.
And what we're going to see here is what
we saw, telegraphed by Netanyahu and the
[00:19:38]
Israeli government for a year and a half.
They are going to destroy all of it.
And the time to get in the way, the time
to stop it was when Biden was in office.
And that's why so many people spoke up
and so many people were frustrated.
This you, of course, were critical of him
throughout and the while.
[00:19:56]
This may now as the culmination of this
operation may happen under Trump's watch,
the people who are ultimately responsible
are Antony Blinken, Joe Biden,
all the spokespeople who pretended
like they were having serious,
[00:20:12]
tough conversations with Netanyahu and the
Israelis about reining in their operation
or being mindful of civilians.
That was always a lie.
They were never legitimately behind
the scenes pushing for a cease fire.
And if you you mentioned
Israeli supporters
[00:20:28]
who pretended like this wasn't a genocide
or ethnic cleansing for the first year.
I mean, you have to be either stupid
or deliberately unwilling to recognize
what was happening to have that position.
And there are people
who spent the first year splitting hairs
[00:20:46]
over the definition of genocide
or the definition of ethnic cleansing.
And here you are.
What do you have for that?
All those people who tried to obfuscate
and distract during these conversations,
during these debates,
during these arguments on the on
behalf of the Israeli government.
[00:21:02]
What do you have to show for it?
And you know,
you've heard this phrase before.
There's a book out now
by a Palestinian author about it.
One day everyone's going to pretend
like they were against this.
One day, everyone will always
have been against this.
And when we are presented
with situations like this and Yemen is
[00:21:21]
another example, you have to think about
what your role in that is.
Is it waiting and seeing
just until things are bad enough?
And then you can give it the label
of a genocide or ethnic cleansing?
Or is it fighting,
fighting against it from day one?
[00:21:39]
And I think many of us thankfully,
and I know many people watching,
were opposed day one,
week one to this escalation from
the Israeli government and what they're
talking about in some of these plans,
like the the comment in Jeremy
Scahill's article, Palestinians would
[00:21:55]
be herded into the wasteland
of what was once Rafah in southern Gaza.
Rafah was the safe haven a year ago.
That's where people were told
to go to to escape.
Is Israel's bombing and Israel's attacks,
and now it is completely destroyed.
[00:22:12]
Same thing with Khan Younis.
Same thing with Gaza City
across the board in Gaza.
They were continually told to relocate
as Israel then demolished more and more
of Gaza after the first or second refugee
camp or hospital was attacked.
[00:22:29]
How could you not see
what the ultimate plan was?
And unfortunately, there are many people,
and some even tried to make
this case on this network that know
that Israel doesn't bomb refugee camps.
Israel doesn't bomb hospitals.
It's it's always it's always Hamas.
This was a misfire by Hamas.
[00:22:46]
Look around you look.
Look at the footage and
and genuinely try to make that case.
You are either a liar or you are obtuse.
And they're not mutually exclusive.
There are many people who still try to
make the case that Israel is, like you're
[00:23:02]
saying, the most moral army in the world.
The blood on their hands,
and ultimately Trump's and Biden's
and Blinken's and now Rubio's untold.
We can never have those lives back.
It is absolutely disgusting.
But on this plan, it's just going
to be what Netanyahu wants.
[00:23:18]
No one is brave enough at the top levels
of the US government to stand up to him,
and he's going to do whatever he wants.
Okay, I've got a comment
on a bunch of that stuff.
You're 100% right that in hindsight people
always say, oh, I was always against it.
Oh, I never liked Netanyahu.
[00:23:35]
Oh, you know, blah blah blah blah.
There'll be a thousand excuses.
A thousand. Yes.
But did you do anything?
Did you say that Israel was wrong
and that we should, that the we should
have a two state solution
and that we should have a cease fire and
that the Palestinians should be protected?
Or did you use talking points about human
shields and how they had it coming?
[00:23:55]
And the Palestinians
can't ever be trusted.
They're not like normal human beings.
No. If we give them a state, they'll
those savages will immediately attack us.
No Israeli supporter is ever allowed
to use the word savage again.
So because what's happened in Gaza
is the definition of savagery.
[00:24:14]
Okay. So okay, that's clear.
Number two, The comment
about the hospital is so right.
Anna said it yesterday too.
Remember when we had the debate and I you
know, you said somebody on the network
said, that's right, and I'm proud of that.
Why am I proud of that?
Because we had the conversations.
[00:24:30]
We had the debates
and you all saw it with your own eyes.
We didn't shut anything down.
We allowed everybody to say their piece.
And what happened?
The truth went out. We were right.
So and now it's not in question
because the debate originally was,
oh, this is the thing that Anna mentioned.
[00:24:46]
You mentioned.
Oh, remember, with that hospital
got hit in the beginning
and they're like, no way it was Israel.
Israel would never hit a hospital.
No. Everybody has to retract the story.
Israel is the most moral country
in the history of the world.
They would never, ever.
And if you say they would ever
hit a hospital anti-Semite.
[00:25:03]
Right. What happened?
They destroyed all the hospitals in Gaza.
They leveled two of them yesterday.
So now we're past 53,000 dead.
They've taken two thirds of Gaza already.
So where is Where's the O.
Oh, they would never hit any hospitals.
[00:25:19]
They hit every hospital
and every university and every school.
They destroyed them all.
So can I get a confession
from the supporters of Israel?
You were wrong, Israel.
This current government
is a bunch of savages.
And they destroyed civilization in Gaza.
[00:25:37]
I mean, if Hamas had done this to Israel,
can you imagine
if Hamas had done this to Israel?
But apparently Israel is allowed to be.
Monsters
and say, no, I can do it to Palestinians.
[00:25:53]
Their lives don't matter.
I'm going to keep going.
So the one thing I disagree with you,
Jordan on, you said they have to be
either stupid or liars.
No, you'd be shocked
at what bias does to you.
Look, I can tell you from my ethnicity.
You go talk to perfectly rational Turks,
perfectly progressive Turks,
[00:26:09]
and you ask them about Kurds.
Boom! Gone.
Bias comes in. Their eyes glaze over.
No, the Kurds are bad.
Turks are the greatest.
Turks are the most moral people
on the earth.
Blah blah blah blah blah.
No bias will blind you to anything
when it comes to these kind of issues.
[00:26:25]
But I am curious now that Netanyahu
is launching this conquest imminently
and he's saying, yes, this is our plan.
We are going to take the Palestinian land
and we are going to continue to murder
them, and we are going to drive them out.
[00:26:42]
Are you still going
to hide behind excuses?
Are you still going to be biased
and go, yeah, no.
As long as Israel is the one doing the
ethnic cleansing, then I'm okay with it
because excuse number one, two and three,
and every excuse has to do with
how Palestinians are savages and violent
[00:27:00]
and can't be trusted
and have to be murdered because they're
the because they're the violent ones.
Right. And finally, you know, this Jordan,
this idea like, oh, don't trust Trump.
He'll never, ever do the right thing
because, you know, he doesn't have good
[00:27:17]
intent and he's not actually a peacenik.
- Of course.
- Of course it isn't about good intent.
And like, all of a sudden you're like,
oh, I think maybe
Donald Trump's heart opened up.
No, no, the only reason he might do it
is because of corruption and ego.
[00:27:36]
If he thought they're going to build
statues of him all over the world, and he
was going to get a Nobel Peace Prize,
and he was going to get to take home
a couple of billion dollars.
That's why he would do it.
It's not complicated.
And Trump's not a complicated guy.
Nevertheless, it is way less likely
because still, Israel has an
[00:27:52]
enormous amount of power in this country,
and they are now exercising it
in 8000 different ways.
And so that's why on the Qatar jet.
Oh my God, every ally of Israel
is and again the jets wrong.
[00:28:09]
Right.
But every ally of Israel
is out all over media.
Every politician, including Republicans,
all of a sudden finding a way
to oppose Trump, right?
Etc.
And going no, no, no, no, no, no,
Qatar's a bunch of terrorists,
terrorist, Muslim savages.
We have our biggest space
in the Middle East, in Qatar.
[00:28:26]
If there's such terrorists,
why are we working with them?
Why are we putting our troops in danger?
No, Israel's interests are affected.
No terrorists, terrorists, terrorists.
Anti-semite. Okay, yeah.
Try that. Go ahead.
But you know what's happening?
The MAGA base is going.
You call me anti-Semite?
One more goddamn time.
[00:28:41]
I dare you call me anti-Semite
one more time, okay?
They had it up to here. So my.
I know I'm out on a limb.
I said it at the very beginning
of the Trump administration.
It's not even a majority likelihood, but
is there, for the first time, a chance,
[00:28:59]
a non-zero chance that they'll get to
the right answer because of all the forces
that I just explained,
the corruption, the ego, etc.?
Yes there is, yes, there definitely is.
There is a Possibility.
And if you're not open to
that possibility,
you're making a giant mistake.
[00:29:14]
We should.
Jordan, last thing I know,
we're so over here, but you have
to encourage that possibility.
You have to tell Trump,
oh, my God, you'll be a hero.
But by the way, he would be in that case.
But if you say nope, nope, nope, nope.
I'm just going to be super pessimistic
and I'm going to yell at him
[00:29:31]
no matter what he does, even if he does
the right thing and and and you know what?
And because if he does the right thing
and frees the Palestinians,
no, he's still doing other things wrong
since he's doing other things wrong.
I'll never give him credit,
even though this would be a historic act.
I think that's a massive mistake.
[00:29:48]
So. Do you see that encouraging him to do
the right thing, especially encouraging
the right wing to push him to do the right
thing, might be the right strategy.
I just I don't I don't have faith
in them doing that.
[00:30:04]
Like you just laid out.
All of the opposition to this plane
is rooted in Islamophobia,
much of it to be fair.
Why would they suddenly
take a different tact here?
I think we've what we have seen,
especially from the right
on foreign policy going back,
I mean, going back to the Gulf days,
[00:30:23]
if you want to be accurate,
but largely from the war on terror on it
is a jingoistic foreign policy, and that's
going to extend to Palestinians as well.
So I, I just am not holding my breath.
I mean, sure, I guess I'll encourage you
do the right thing, but like,
[00:30:40]
I feel like it's falling on deaf ears,
but they've shown how.
Can you say it's falling on deaf ears?
Joe Rogan is talking about.
It. Like, I'm not just talking
about Candace Owens.
Tucker Carlson in the far right
Rogan Theo Von's endlessly.
Like Tucker Carlson
is a straight up anti-Semite.
The reason he's taking that position
is because he's an anti-Semite.
[00:30:57]
He is a white nationalist.
That's why he's doing it.
I'm being serious.
Hold on.
If he's an anti-Semite and
and that's our speculation.
Okay.
That's terrible
and I'm going to deal with that later.
But are you trying to discourage him
from like, I'm.
[00:31:13]
Not trying to discourage him.
I'm not saying he's going to be
an effective messenger to persuade Trump.
Of course he is.
Who would be an effective messenger,
a Democrat?
- That doesn't make any sense, Jordan.
- Not.
Of course.
Tucker Carlson and Marjorie Taylor Greene
are much more likely to persuade
[00:31:29]
Donald Trump than we are.
It's not the most obvious thing
in the world.
No, I'm not.
I'm not saying any of us are going to.
He's not he's going to listen to the most
powerful and he's going to listen to the
military industrial complex that's like,
that is who will reign supreme here.
[00:31:45]
And if Israel wants weapons
and they want to continue that cash flow,
they're going to have more influence
than podcaster Tucker Carlson.
It boils down to money.
The only reason he's saying that
is because he is a white nationalist.
He you look at his comments on people
in the Middle East going back to the 2000.
[00:32:04]
He sees them as subhuman, like.
There are many comments
on that shock jock.
Jordan. Let me.
No, no, no, I'm really mad about this.
Hold on.
Hold on.
I will lift him up. There are plenty.
No, no.
Stop with that nonsense, Jordan. Hold on.
[00:32:20]
- Listen, how is this nonsense?
- Okay.
Here's why.
Because you are the people
who are saying that.
Yes. Including you.
You're being intensely selfish.
Let me explain.
So Tucker Carlson said we shouldn't go
into Iraq after he originally was
in favor of it, but after the war started,
he said, you know, we shouldn't be there.
[00:32:38]
And I don't want to deal
with these monkeys.
Now he's talking about Muslims.
That's my people.
Okay, so am I in favor of that? No, no.
Absolutely not.
So I could choose to do one of two things.
If we were back in that time,
I could either encourage
the Tucker Carlson wing of the party
to get out of Iraq, which would have saved
[00:32:56]
hundreds of thousands of lives.
Or I could say I am morally pure.
And he was Islamophobic.
I, I banish him and I cancel him.
And it's better that I cancel him
because of my feelings than we save
hundreds of thousands of lives in Iraq.
[00:33:13]
That's intensely selfish. Let it go.
Yeah. Okay.
I don't know what his intentions are,
and I don't give a goddamn
what his intentions are.
You've got to get the right wing.
I'm not saying
that it's going to be easy, Jordan.
I'm not saying I'm not naive. I don't.
It's not like I don't know.
[00:33:29]
I've been railing against the power
of the Israeli lobby and the military
industrial complex, but if we just go,
oh, no, I don't want any allies.
I don't want allies
from the people who are in charge.
Now, how could you not see that?
That's maniacal and intensely selfish.
[00:33:48]
Because they're not our allies.
When have they ever.
- Shown to be an ally?
- Right now.
- Right now they're.
- Saying, no, they're not.
They haven't done anything.
Jordan, what the hell
do you want him to do?
Marjorie Taylor Greene says,
I don't want to give any more money
because he says one thing,
you're like, oh, let's listen to him.
[00:34:04]
He hasn't done anything.
Jordan, I'm not saying go vote for Trump.
I'm not saying go support Trump.
I'm saying push Trump
to do the right thing.
But you say no.
You say no. You say no.
You're letting the Palestinians die
because.
[00:34:19]
Of your selfishness.
- It drives.
- Me crazy.
Jake, I have an award for running a
ceasefire website that millions of people
around the world have used.
- You're calling me.
- Selfish?
Yes, I am.
- Jordan, you've.
- Done.
Because I don't inherently believe
one thing that Trump said on camera.
[00:34:36]
No, it's not about believing Jordan.
It's not about believing.
So first of all, Jordan, you have been
freaking amazing on this issue.
You've been one of the best people
in the country on this issue,
and I love you for it.
Okay, but where I'm not asking you
to be naive and go,
[00:34:52]
oh, I just trust Trump on everything now.
I'm asking you to be
political and strategic and your normal,
incredibly smart self and go.
When the right wing comes to our side,
we're not going to their side
when they come to our side,
whether it's Tucker Carlson or.
[00:35:07]
God damn it, Joe Rogan,
when they're all coming to our side,
don't tell them I don't want you.
You're an anti-Semite.
You're a white nationalist.
I don't want you. And I don't believe you.
Take yes for an answer. For God's sake.
For the Palestinians sake, Jordan,
you've been amazing on this.
[00:35:23]
Please take yes for an answer.
When he does something.
No, we got to push him to do it. Jordan.
By the time he decides to do it
or not do it, it's too late.
If you just sit back and go, oh, I'm
not going to help the right, the right.
[00:35:41]
Who wants to stop the funding to Israel,
the right who wants
to stop the ceasefire, etc.?
I don't believe them. They're all racist.
I don't believe
I'm not going to help them.
Okay. Oh, oops.
They didn't have enough power
because they had no allies on our side.
They had no allies anywhere else.
And so we we we gave up.
[00:35:56]
We sat on our hands and we were losers
and we were pessimistic
and we gave up on the Palestinian people.
We just gave up on them
because calling Tucker Carlson
an anti-Semite was more important to us
than saving Palestinian lives.
That's my opinion. I can't stand it.
[00:36:11]
I think you're dead wrong on it,
I love you.
You've been wonderful on this issue.
But no, when the other side comes to us
on a super important issue
where lives are on the line,
I don't care about what their past is.
[00:36:27]
- And, oh, they said the.
- Wrong.
Word once.
Oh, what do they think about trans people?
Are you kidding me?
Let's go save some lives.
Let's save some lives.
We're not in charge.
We're not in charge. They're in charge.
And when they say yes,
we agree with the left.
Yes, we agree with Palestinians.
[00:36:43]
The correct answer,
definitively, inarguably, is yes.
Thank you for coming to our side.
We will take yes for an answer.
Every time you ring the bell below,
an angel gets his wings.
Totally not true, but it does
keep you updated on our live shows.
Now Playing (Clips)
Episode
Podcast
The Young Turks: May 15, 2025
- 22 minutes
- 36 minutes
- 7 minutes
- 15 minutes
- 10 minutes
- 7 minutes