May 12, 2025
Last Known American Hostage RELEASED By Hamas
American-Israeli hostage was released by Hamas after negotiations that did NOT include Israel.
- 14 minutes
Going to give a lot of credit here
to Donald Trump.
And if you're on the left and you're like,
oh, he brought home a hostage
and cut out Israel, but he's Trump boo.
I don't want to give him credit.
What did you what do you what do you need.
What do you like.
So did you not want
to bring home a hostage?
[00:00:15]
Did you want to make sure he followed
the orders of Israeli government?
I don't know what you want, but I'm
a fair person and an honest person.
Trump deserves a lot of credit
for this deal.
Edan Alexander, an American citizen
who until recently most thought was
[00:00:33]
no longer living thought was dead,
is going to be released in about two
hours, actually, and he's going to be
released before the eyes of Steve Witkoff,
who has done a fantastic job.
[00:00:49]
As you just heard,
President Donald Trump announced today
that a dual American citizen who also,
unfortunately, was a hostage of Hamas
has been released by Hamas.
The individual freed is Eden Alexander,
the last known American hostage in Gaza.
[00:01:06]
And it's important to understand just how
Alexander was released, how this deal was
made through the United States and Hamas.
So, per ABC news, Hamas announced its
intention to free Alexander on Sunday,
describing the decision as a part of the
steps being taken to achieve a ceasefire.
[00:01:27]
The statement said Hamas had been
in contact with American officials
over the past few days
as part of ceasefire negotiations,
and that account was backed up by an
anonymous source from the United States.
This U.S. Familiar or U.S.
[00:01:43]
Official familiar with the deal
to release.
Alexander told ABC news that the agreement
came together in recent days
via direct talks between the U.S.
And Hamas.
In other words, Israel was not part
of this hostage release negotiation.
They were not part of this deal.
[00:01:59]
We're going to revisit
that in just a minute.
But the but Trump announced this on Truth
Social as well, writing the following.
I'm grateful to all those involved
in making this monumental news happen.
This was a step taken in good faith
towards the United States
[00:02:15]
and the efforts of the mediators,
Qatar and Egypt, to put an end
to this very brutal war and return all
hostages and remains to their loved ones.
Hopefully, this is the first
of those final steps
necessary to end this brutal conflict.
[00:02:32]
I look very much forward
to the day of that day of celebration.
I mean, he mentions ending the war
several times, and it's clear that that is
what the president wants, and that is
good news, how that ends up manifesting.
We'll see.
But the Trump administration
isn't just bypassing Israel.
[00:02:50]
They're even calling Israel out
for negotiating in bad faith and serving
as an obstacle to ending the war.
According to channel 12. Here's what Steve
Witkoff, who is the Trump administration's
special envoy to the Middle East.
[00:03:06]
Hold hostage families in Israel. Quote.
We want to bring the hostages home,
but Israel is not willing to end the war.
Israel is prolonging it, despite the fact
that we don't see where else we can go
and that an agreement must be reached.
[00:03:23]
So you can kind of understand
why the Israelis hate would want
to get rid of Witkoff.
But make no mistake about it,
Witkoff is the first American official
who's willing to call a spade a spade
and call out Israel for serving
as an obstacle to a peace deal.
Yeah.
So first off, I'm going to give
a lot of credit here to Donald Trump.
[00:03:43]
And if you're on the left and you're like,
oh, you brought home a hostage
and cut out Israel.
But he's Trump boo.
I don't want to give him credit.
What did you what do you what do you need.
What do you like?
So did you not want
to bring home a hostage?
Did you want to make sure he followed
the orders of Israeli government?
[00:04:01]
I don't know what you want, but I'm
a fair person and an honest person.
Trump deserves a lot of credit
for this deal.
Okay, so, now, cutie, like, bring
the brother home already is great news.
But that also proves the second thing,
which is look at how easy it was.
[00:04:17]
Like he just.
All he had to do was remove Israel
from the negotiations, talk to him, us.
And you know what Hamas got in return?
Nothing.
Just a promise that, hey, you know what?
We'll keep this in mind.
It'll create some goodwill.
Super easy. Okay?
Why are we not getting the deal done?
Well, listen to Witkoff.
[00:04:35]
Witkoff is telling you it's
because the Israelis don't want peace.
They want continual war. Why?
Because they want to occupy
the Gaza Strip and steal that land.
Right.
And and look, Witkoff, I just want
to note, hasn't lost all hope
that there could be a ceasefire deal.
[00:04:51]
Although he's kind of going into this
with eyes wide open, like he can see
what the dynamic is with Israel involved.
He says to the hostage families,
there's currently an opportunity window
that we hope Israel and all the mediators
will take advantage of.
We are putting pressure on all mediators
and doing everything we can
[00:05:09]
to bring the hostages home.
So he still has a little bit of hope,
but I can't believe I'm saying this.
Someone who Donald Trump tapped to serve
as his special envoy to the Middle East.
Donald Trump tapped him is way better on
[00:05:25]
this issue than who Biden had involved in
peace negotiations and a cease fire deal.
It's just incredible to see it.
Yeah.
So look, redemption on every account.
So we told you this isn't about Jews.
This is about foreign governments.
[00:05:42]
Witkoff is a Jewish American,
and he's saying the right thing, doing
the right thing, representing America.
And and I appreciate it.
And doing it way better
than Anthony Blinken did.
And so it has nothing to do with religion.
It has to do
with two different governments.
[00:05:58]
One is on the wrong track,
and we need to stop enabling them.
We need to help our ally get back
to reality and and decency and morality.
And I'm sure that Woodcock agrees.
And that's why he's saying things
that are true.
Now, that leads to the second thing.
So what do we tell you?
[00:06:14]
We told you that the Democrats
are a bunch of robots,
and they're never going to waver one inch
from what the donor class wants, okay?
Trump is a wild card,
and that wild card could go disastrously,
as when he was talking about how we would
have ground troops in Gaza and build
[00:06:31]
a Trump Riviera absolute disaster.
Talking about maybe, you know,
the occupation of Gaza and the West Bank,
etc., but a wild card could also has some
chance of going in the right direction.
So it took a wild card
to have an envoy who will say,
[00:06:48]
well, the Israelis don't want peace.
- Oh, truth broke out.
- I know.
It's it's incredible.
Like so let's be honest. Let's be honest.
A Democratic envoy
would have never said that.
Not in a million.
They would not have had
permission to say that.
[00:07:03]
Joe Biden's envoys obviously never said
that they would lie on Israel's behalf.
Every time they would say,
oh, we really want to get to a cease fire.
- But it's, of course, all Hamas's fault.
- The son of a bitch.
Hamas terrorists.
Israel's great and wonderful, and there's
nothing they could do about it.
Oh my Israel. Right.
[00:07:21]
So that was Blinken and all the Jake
Sullivan and all the loser robots
in the Biden administration.
And Kamala promised
to do the exact same thing.
So if you're a Democrat, please.
Wakey, wakey.
Right.
And they won't. Oh, no.
I bet she would have miraculously
turned around 180 degrees
[00:07:37]
and done the right thing.
No, she promised that she
would never do the right thing.
So we're not, like, blind about Trump,
you crazy naive.
No. It could get way worse. Right.
But since he's not a robot,
sometimes truth accidentally breaks out.
Trump doesn't abide by any of the rules
associated with traditional
[00:07:57]
political parties in this country.
Right.
So this isn't a Republican
versus Democrat thing.
This is a Trump versus typical status
quo politician thing,
because make no mistake about it.
Had Trump been any other traditional
conservative Republican, we would not be
[00:08:15]
having a conversation about his
special envoy admitting that Israel is the
one serving as an obstacle to a ceasefire.
And so, look there there are some
interesting developments right now
because of the fact that Trump
has kind of soured on his relationship
[00:08:31]
with Benjamin Netanyahu and vice versa.
And so that might be changing
the dynamic of U.S.
Foreign policy as it pertains
to Israel moving forward, but specifically
during the Trump administration.
I think any other administration that
comes after Trump is going to revert right
[00:08:51]
back to giving Israel everything it wants.
So here's what I mean.
So, look, Netanyahu has been pushing
the United States to bomb Iran,
to get engaged in a hot war with Iran
on behalf of Israel.
To Donald Trump's credit,
he has resisted those calls.
[00:09:07]
He does not want to go to war with Iran.
In fact, what he'd like to do is enter a
new nuclear deal with Iran to prevent them
from building nuclear weapons.
And I am 100% supportive
of Trump's thinking on that.
Now, the U.S.
[00:09:23]
Also ended its strikes
against the Houthis.
Or, as Trump likes to say, the Houthis,
who were very brave, as he
also said Netanyahu didn't like that.
And again, Trump wants to engage
in these negotiations with Iran.
Netanyahu hates that.
[00:09:40]
So here's what NBC news
reported on Sunday.
Netanyahu was particularly upset
when Trump said that he had yet to decide
whether Iran would be allowed
to enrich uranium under a new nuclear deal
his administration is negotiating.
[00:09:55]
For his part, Trump has been frustrated
with Netanyahu's decision to begin
a new military offensive in In Gaza,
which the president sees as at odds
with his plan for rebuilding there.
And according to Ilan Goldenberg,
[00:10:12]
who worked on Middle East policy during
the Obama and Biden administrations,
Netanyahu cannot publicly criticize Trump
too harshly or really much at all,
because apparently Israelis love Trump,
including right wing Israelis.
[00:10:28]
So Netanyahu's whole political strategy
and survival strategy is based
on holding his coalition and holding his
political base together, Goldenberg said.
And those folks love Trump.
So for him to go very publicly against
Trump is something he really can't do.
[00:10:45]
So this this dynamic
is just really interesting, and I hope it
keeps going in this direction,
because maybe for the first time,
I don't want to say that there could
be a decoupling of this relationship
between the United States and Israel,
but Frostier relations might actually
bode well for the lives of innocent people
[00:11:04]
who are currently trapped in Gaza.
Yes, let's break down all the ways
that the decoupling is happening.
It doesn't mean that it can't be reversed.
It could be reversed at any second.
And Trump is super fickle and he can go
in a disastrous direction at any second.
Having said that, for now, let's
look at the facts without the emotions
[00:11:21]
and the tribalism involved.
Okay, so did he attack Iran
when Netanyahu told him to?
No he didn't.
That's a huge story
from the New York Times.
And there's no question
that Netanyahu wanted that attack.
[00:11:37]
And my guess is he ordered it
like he normally does.
Right.
I order the American president
to attack Iran on my behalf.
And Trump was like, no,
I haven't seen that in my lifetime.
So, okay, to be fair, you could say,
well, Biden didn't attack Iran either,
[00:11:53]
and Obama made a great deal with Iran.
So and especially Obama.
Obama did defy Netanyahu.
Netanyahu did not want that deal.
And he got us a great deal anyway.
Okay, so that's all right.
Not bad. Give credit where credit is due.
But yeah, Obama and and others
have done something a little similar.
[00:12:09]
Okay. And Obama's deal was better.
So. And I don't say that because I'm
a Democrat because, look, I'm even talking
to Republicans now going, Marjorie
Taylor Greene on this show was like
the Obama deal was actually pretty good.
I mean, I never thought
I'd see anything like that, right?
[00:12:24]
So now, okay, the second thing,
he did the deal with the Houthis,
and he cut Israel out of it.
So and Israel was super mad about it,
and he said, you're going
to stop bombing American ships,
and we're going to stop bombing Yemen.
And they were like, yep, deal.
Let's go. Right.
[00:12:39]
It didn't say anything about
stopping the bombing of Israeli ships
or ships headed to Israel.
So Israel is like, how dare you?
You did a peace deal for Americans
and you did not consider Israel first.
And Trump's like, yeah, that's right.
That's what I did.
[00:12:55]
And then the third thing
is the hostage deal.
Israel doesn't want the hostages released.
Why? Well, first of all.
All right.
And, Roy is telling you that, right?
Basically.
And but the reason they don't want him
released is because it's a pretext for.
[00:13:11]
Oh, we had to bomb Gaza more.
We had to keep taking
more and more of Gaza's land.
In fact, all of it.
We had to drive out all the Palestinians
into the desert and starve them to death
because of the hostages.
We were defending ourselves from a war
that started, I don't know, 28 years ago
[00:13:29]
or whatever, whenever it started.
Oh, we are still doing self-defense
as we took the Sudetenland.
I mean, Gaza. Okay.
So and Trump is like, oh,
so but there's an American hostage there.
Israel's like, no, shut up.
Don't worry about the American hostage.
We need him as a pawn.
Trump's like, yeah, I don't think so.
[00:13:46]
Hey, Hamas, you want to make a deal, you
give me the hostage, I give you nothing.
And Hamas is like, yeah, okay. Deal.
If you can't say that that was good from
Trump, then you really do have TDs.
Okay.
So that was great.
And the decoupling is real.
[00:14:02]
It doesn't mean it'll hold.
But if we fully decouple and go.
Israel.
So somebody's doing this
the other day, and I loved it.
Love you. See you.
Bye bye. Okay.
Hey, listen, you're a grown up country.
One of the top 20 economies.
Enjoy. Okay?
[00:14:17]
But we don't have to give you
endless money.
Nobody ever said that.
We don't have to kiss your ass.
We don't have to do our
entire foreign policy based on you.
By the way, is Trump doing it out of
good reasons or because he's getting
a lot of business deals
from Qatar, UAE and Saudi Arabia?
I don't know, but I don't care
too much either because we got to end
[00:14:34]
that genocide 100%.
And look, we live in a corrupt political
system where even foreign governments
have sway over our politicians.
And, you know,
the presidential administration.
If bribery from other players
helps balance things out
[00:14:53]
in regard to this war, I will allow it.
Every time you ring the bell below,
an angel gets his wings.
Totally not true, but it does
keep you updated on our live shows.
Now Playing (Clips)
Episode
Podcast
The Young Turks: May 12, 2025
- 16 minutes
- 18 minutes
- 14 minutes
- 12 minutes
- 13 minutes