Apr 9, 2025
WATCH: Trump SHOCKS With Comment To Coal Miners
President Trump said coal miners would rather mine than live in a Penthouse on 5th Avenue.
- 10 minutes
One thing I learned about the coal miners.
That's what they want to do.
You could give them a penthouse on Fifth
Avenue and a different kind of a job,
and they'd be unhappy.
They want to mine coal.
That's what they love to do.
I'm going to predict that they would
take the penthouse over the coal mining.
[00:00:15]
Just just a guess.
But apparently, coal miners would
rather pass up a comfortable lifestyle
for the thrill of doing a job that is,
in fact, incredibly dangerous
and oftentimes leads
to pretty severe respiratory illnesses
that could be deadly.
[00:00:33]
But look, I'm not at all trying
to criticize coal miners.
They're trying to make a living.
So I totally understand individuals
employed in that area not wanting to move
away from coal mining, like it's important
to understand where they're coming from.
[00:00:50]
But Donald Trump, speaking on their behalf
and making it appear as though like,
these guys don't want a nice life.
They just want to they want to mine coal.
No, I think they want a stable income.
And the way that they've been able
to get that is through coal mining.
But nonetheless, President Trump
made those comments during the signing
[00:01:08]
of multiple executive orders
that aim to revive the coal mining
industry in the United States.
Which makes me think of Germany,
to be honest with you, because Germany
decided to decommission their
nuclear power plants because nuclear bad,
[00:01:26]
even though it's a very it's like
the cleanest form of energy
and replace it with coal mining, which is
really, really bad for the environment.
I think that's dumb, but okay.
So we'll get to more on,
the signing ceremony in just a second.
[00:01:43]
But first, let me give you some
more details about the executive orders
that he signed.
The first directs all departments
and agencies to end all discriminatory
policies against the coal industry,
including by ending the leasing moratorium
on coal and federal on federal land,
[00:01:58]
and accelerate all permitted funding
for coal projects.
The second imposes a moratorium on
the unscientific and unrealistic policies
enacted by the Biden administration
to protect coal power plants
currently operating.
The third promotes grid security
and reliability.
[00:02:16]
We need nuclear power
by ensuring that grid policies are focused
on secure and effective energy production.
Nuclear power, as opposed to woke policies
that discriminate against secure
sources of power like nuclear power.
He believes,
like coal and other fossil fuels.
[00:02:33]
For those watching, you know that I added
the nuclear power parts to that statement.
But for those listening to the audio
version, I'm the one who mentioned
the nuclear power parts, not Trump.
Now, we should be focusing
on nuclear, in my opinion.
Again, if you are serious in your concerns
about the climate disaster,
[00:02:54]
the climate emergency, our renewable
energies are not enough to carry us.
We need a another reliable,
clean source of energy.
And at least in the short term, I
personally think instead of going to coal,
[00:03:10]
we should maybe go to our nuclear reactors
that are offline
and bring them back online until we
develop, you know, other forms of energy
that are clean, reliable, stable.
We don't have that yet, unfortunately.
Now, the fourth executive order
instructs the Department of Justice
[00:03:27]
to vigorously pursue and investigate
the unconstitutional policies
of radical leftist states
that discriminate against coal.
So let's take a look at this video.
This is a very important day to me,
[00:03:44]
because we're bringing back an industry
that was abandoned, despite the fact
that it was just about the best, certainly
the best in terms of power, real power.
Today we're taking historic action
to help American workers, miners,
[00:04:00]
families and consumers.
We're ending Joe Biden's war
on beautiful, clean coal once and for all.
And it wasn't just Biden, it was Obama.
And there were others.
- But we're doing the exact opposite.
- Obama.
[00:04:18]
Now, look, Biden did, in fact,
tighten regulations, which are in fact
expected to shut down many US coal plants.
But the coal industry has been struggling,
and they were struggling
well before the Biden administration
or well before the Biden administration
[00:04:36]
implemented new regulations.
Why?
Well,
because of the various sources of energy.
Coal happens to be the dirtiest.
It's the worst for the environment.
And look, environmental regulations make
it difficult to mine for coal, for sure.
[00:04:53]
And then there's also competition.
I mean, you believe in capitalism, right?
Trump competition from less expensive air,
like less expensive sources of energy
like natural gas and renewable sources,
is what has basically
taken coal companies, out of business.
[00:05:11]
So rising mining costs, environmental
regulation and competition from natural
gas and renewables all contributed to coal
production in 2023, declining to less
than half of its 2008 production peak.
The Energy Information Administration
reported on Tuesday.
[00:05:26]
But according to Trump,
it's all Democrats fault.
Okay, so look, let's hear more from Trump,
because it wasn't just Biden
he took shots at.
In the first campaign where Hillary
Clinton was about four states too early,
and she was talking about how bad coal was
and how they were going to teach coal
[00:05:46]
miners how to make widgets and gadgets and
technology, which they didn't want to do.
They want to mine one thing I learned
about the coal miners.
That's what they want to do.
You could give them a penthouse on Fifth
Avenue and a different kind of a job,
and they'd be unhappy.
They want to mine coal.
That's what they love to do.
[00:06:02]
And she was going to put them
in a high tech industry where you
make little cell phones and things.
I don't know,
do you think he'd be good at that?
I don't know.
Okay, first off, Hillary Clinton did step
in it during the 2016 election
[00:06:21]
when she essentially said that we're going
to teach coal miners how to code.
She didn't specifically say
they're going to be making
or manufacturing little cell phones.
And when I say she stepped in it,
I mean it because it was such a.
[00:06:36]
As someone who's trying to win
a presidential election, in my opinion, it
was a callous way of responding to a very,
very real concern that coal miners have
in regard to losing their livelihoods.
Right.
You have to have a better plan than we're
going to teach them how to code.
[00:06:53]
It's like a completely different industry,
a completely different sector
of the economy.
So I don't blame Trump
for picking at Hillary Clinton.
However, I do find it fascinating
that he's looking down his nose
at phone manufacturing because his
own Commerce secretary, Howard Lutnick,
[00:07:14]
said this over the weekend.
The factories being built
in America are huge.
That takes years.
And you've said that robots
are going to fill those jobs.
So those aren't.
- Really automated.
- Jobs.
It's automated factories,
automated factories.
[00:07:30]
But the key is who's going
to build the factories?
Who's going to operate the factories,
who's going to make them work?
Great American workers. You know.
You said robots on other networks,
armies of.
Millions of people.
Well, remember the army of millions
and millions of human beings
[00:07:45]
screwing in little, little screws
to make iPhones, that kind
of thing is going to come to America.
It's going to be automated.
And great Americans, the trade craft
of America is going to fix them.
It's going to work on them.
Screwing
in tiny little screws for iPhones.
[00:08:02]
It's a dream job.
It is a dream job,
but not according to Donald Trump.
Maybe he needs to reach out
to Howard Lutnick.
So they get their messaging,
you know, messaging together.
So they're saying the same things?
No. But look, in all seriousness,
I think Howard Lutnick,
[00:08:20]
this is my conspiracy theory.
I think Howard Lutnick is trying to
sabotage the Trump administration, okay?
Because he says ridiculous things
that tend to conflict
with the Trump administration.
To be quite honest with you, I think Scott
Bessent, who's the Commerce secretary?
[00:08:37]
I'm sorry.
The Treasury secretary
does a better job in communicating,
even though he's kind of in a rough spot.
You can tell he doesn't like Trump's
tariffs, but is tasked with defending them
during press interviews.
But with Howard Lutnick,
I think he's super salty
that he didn't get picked for the role.
[00:08:55]
He really, really wanted
to be the Treasury secretary.
He did not want to be
the Commerce secretary.
And he's going around talking about how,
yeah, we're going to bring manufacturing
jobs back to the United States
so they can be employed by robots.
Then he's talking about, you know,
screwing in tiny little screws on iPhones
[00:09:11]
and how that's like the great,
great trade craft of the American people.
Anyway.
But nonetheless, let's get back to
the whole notion of bringing coal mining
back to the United States.
What will Trump's executive orders
actually lead to a revival
[00:09:26]
of coal mining in the US?
Well, according to Politico,
these orders will likely keep
the few existing coal plants open.
But utility companies have indicated
not just now, but for years,
that they have no plans to build new coal
mines or essentially mine for coal,
[00:09:44]
in different areas or new areas.
So according to, the president of power
grid consulting firm Grid Strategies
and former economic advisor at
the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission,
I don't think this order changes the facts
that coal fired power plants
[00:10:01]
are old, expensive to run, and unlikely to
operate very often or for many more years.
The plants will likely be kept online
longer than believed a few years ago
due to an uptick in power demand,
but that is unrelated to this order.
[00:10:19]
So here you have the president, you know,
dipping back into 2016 greatest hits.
It's not really going to do much.
But I do, want to know if those coal
miners appreciate Trump speaking on their
behalf in regard to how they want to live,
what kind of comforts
[00:10:36]
they're willing to give up.
Nonetheless, I can understand
why they would want to keep their job.
So I understand that interest.
But I think most people
want to live a comfortable life.
Most people want to have a stable income,
just that working in the coal industry
is not the best path forward for that.
[00:10:52]
Every time you ring the bell below,
an angel gets its wings.
Totally not true, but it does
keep you updated on our live shows.
Now Playing (Clips)
Episode
Podcast
The Young Turks: April 9, 2025
- 10 minutes
- 12 minutes
- 10 minutes
- 14 minutes
- 11 minutes
- 7 minutes