Nov 19, 2024
Trump Appoints Oz! Is Medicare, Medicaid DOOMED?
Dr. Mehmet Oz has been nominated by President-elect Donald J. Trump to serve as the administrator of the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services.
- 14 minutes
Grocery shopping.
I'm at Wegener's and my wife
wants some vegetables for Crudité.
Right. So here's a broccoli.
That's two bucks.
Not a ton of broccoli. There.
Here's some asparagus. That's $4. Yep.
Carrots.
[00:00:15]
That's four more dollars.
That's $10 of vegetables there.
And then we need some guacamole.
That's $4 or more.
And she loves salsa. Yeah.
Salsa there. $6.
Must be a shortage of salsa.
Guys, that's $20 for crudité.
And this doesn't include the tequila.
[00:00:33]
I mean, it's outrageous.
We got Joe Biden to thank for this.
That Crudité loving Turk
has been tapped by Donald Trump to serve
as the administrator of the centers
for Medicare and Medicaid Services.
That was Doctor Oz. He happened
to lose after running for Senate
[00:00:53]
against John Fetterman in 2022.
John Fetterman won
as he was campaigning as a progressive,
something that he's actually not at all.
So he misidentified himself.
But nonetheless,
Doctor Oz will be the person
who the Senate will very likely confirm.
[00:01:10]
If you ask me for this role.
And it's a little bit disastrous because
he's a huge fan of privatizing Medicare,
essentially pushing the system toward
the Medicare Advantage system, where it's
publicly funded but privately run.
[00:01:26]
Now, let's talk a little more
about who he is.
So it's going to have
a huge impact on a lot of people.
So about a quarter of all federal spending
runs through the centers.
Oz will work under RFK Jr.
Should both of them end up getting
confirmed by the Senate and Republicans
will have control of the Senate,
[00:01:44]
53 of the senators will be Republicans.
And all you need is a simple majority
in order to confirm
Donald Trump's appointments.
And in a statement announcing Doctor Oz
as his choice to lead the agency,
Trump said that Doctor Oz would work
closely with RFK Jr to take on the illness
[00:02:03]
industrial complex and all the horrible
chronic diseases left in its wake.
Trump noted that Doctor Oz
had won nine Daytime Emmy Awards,
hosting the Doctor Oz Show,
where he taught millions of Americans
how to make healthier lifestyle choices.
[00:02:19]
There was some kooky stuff in that show
as well, but I'll be fair and honest, I
didn't watch it every day, so I don't know
everything that he talked about on there.
Trump added he'll also cut waste and fraud
within our country's most expensive
government agency, which is a third of our
nation's health care spend and a quarter
[00:02:37]
of our entire national budget.
Yeah.
All right, so proof's in the pudding,
if you will, because,
let's see what they're going to do.
The first signs are terrible,
which I'll get to in a second.
So first, a little bit of,
I don't want to say a mea culpa
[00:02:56]
because based on the facts that we had,
you know, Fetterman looked to be way
better than Doctor Oz in that election.
Not even close.
Not within miles of each other.
Right.
But it turns out Fetterman
was a giant liar.
So, you know, Doctor Oz's positions
weren't any better.
[00:03:13]
Aren't any better today
than they were when he was running.
So I've got no regret about everything
that I said about him and why he shouldn't
be the senator from Pennsylvania.
I just didn't know that Fetterman
was going to be,
you know, basically a war criminal.
And thought that, oh, my God,
war crimes are so great,
[00:03:30]
we should send tens of billions of dollars
to Israel to commit more of them.
And I have to say, if you know,
in in that one issue, Doctor Oz probably
would have been better than Fetterman in
the Senate, even though he's a Republican.
I don't know that anybody could be worse
than just absolutely demanding
[00:03:49]
that we kill as many Palestinians
as humanly possible without any ceasefire
And the brutality
that he cheerleads for is disgusting.
So that turned out to be one of the worst
Senate races of our lifetimes because
of what a giant liar Fetterman was.
[00:04:04]
And obviously, we were not interested
in the crudity of of Doctor Oz.
So now, in this new role,
does the fact that Fetterman sucked and
now we know about it affect this at all?
No. Those two things
are totally disconnected.
We're not in that race anymore.
This is not vis a vis Fetterman.
He's just on his own.
[00:04:22]
Which then leads him with,
does he have healthcare expertise?
Absolutely.
He's a great doctor.
We said that at the time.
He even operated on my uncle
and arguably saved his life.
And so tip of the hat,
as much as I could possibly do
to Doctor Oz on the medical field.
[00:04:37]
And I appreciate him for that.
Did he do some kooky stuff?
Yes, we covered it.
And so in daytime TV there was a lot of oh
my God, miracle this and miracle that.
Right.
So so he has some excellent credentials
and he did some stuff that I do
not agree with at all on his show.
[00:04:53]
So okay, now the most important part
is yes, but what are they going to do
in Medicare and Medicaid?
Privatize it.
And what Trump is basically hinting at,
and what Anna is probably going to cover
in a longer, segment tomorrow,
is they're looking to cut.
[00:05:10]
Don't be don't be putting
segments together for me, okay?
Don't put that pressure on me.
What the hell.
So it's going to be good.
Make sure you check it out.
You know, the show is live at 6 to 8 p.m.
Eastern every single day, so.
And it's going to do that tomorrow.
It's going to be the best segment
you've ever seen.
Okay. All right.
[00:05:26]
Seriously.
So they're going to look
to cut why tax cuts are coming.
So since tax cuts are coming they're going
to need to get the money from somewhere.
Elon Musk promised to cut $2 trillion.
There isn't 2 trillion to cut. Right.
So we're going to talk about the Pentagon
later and how you could do cuts there.
[00:05:43]
But when you this is not
serving the working man.
No. Guys, I would like to dispel
the notion that Medicare Advantage,
which is the privately run
but publicly funded part of the, you know,
Medicare program, does not save money.
It does quite the opposite.
[00:06:02]
It does quite the opposite
because it's privately run.
They're looking to rip off the taxpayer.
So they overcharge for services
that is not going to save money.
Please don't privatize
the Medicare system.
No, no to privatizing Medicare
would be disastrous.
Medicare polls at 77%.
It's a program
that the American people love.
[00:06:19]
That's why you had those ironic signs
back in the Tea Party day.
Get your government hands off my
Social Security and Medicare.
Those are government programs, okay?
The enormously successful government
programs, if they gut those or they
privatize them, which is much worse,
because then it makes you feel
like you got something, but in reality,
[00:06:38]
your prices are going to go way up.
You're not going to have anything
guaranteed anymore,
and you're going to go back to being
intensely insecure about health care.
And you basically want to do
for Medicare what they did.
It appears,
based on the initial read of it.
What they did
for our healthcare at large, we have.
[00:06:56]
We're one of the only developed nation
that does not have universal health care.
And what has been the result of that?
Our healthcare costs
twice what healthcare costs in every
other developed nation on average.
So we pay trillions more, trillions more
so that private corporations
[00:07:15]
can act as middlemen and rob us blind.
And we have worse results, worse results
in so many of the categories,
including life expectancy.
So if that's what they're promising
for senior Americans,
then we were right all along.
If you elect Republicans, they're going
to gut Medicare and Medicaid and then go,
[00:07:34]
oh, we are the Populist Party.
We are helping the average man so much.
No, no, we're we're we're tracking
that in every way.
And then we're going to have to see,
does the right wing populist cared
or do they not care if they go, oh, yay!
[00:07:49]
We'd love daddy to come make sure
that you take money away
from my mom or my grandmom and give it
to a giant corporation and a tax cut.
Okay, well, then we're all screwed.
So one of the things that Republicans,
certainly Republicans
[00:08:06]
in the MAGA era, complain about
is the administrative state.
And what they're referring to
is the unelected officials within the
federal government who can unilaterally
make decisions and decide on regulations
without any congressional input.
[00:08:24]
And so I actually, to some extent,
agree with them
about the undemocratic nature of that.
I mean, obviously,
we live in a representative democracy,
but sometimes I feel that these government
agencies have a little too much power
to unilaterally act
and make decisions policy wise, that I
[00:08:39]
would rather have Congress decide on.
But with that in mind, when you look
at this government agency and the kind
of responsibilities that Doctor Oz would
have, or the type of power he would have.
Keep in mind, he would be
able to set policies in some instances,
so he would oversee both
the Medicare and Medicaid system.
[00:08:57]
Obviously it's
in the name of of this title.
He would regulate the health care system.
He'd have some say over regulations,
inspects and reports on nursing homes,
sets quality standards for laboratories,
and implements the policies that decide
how much doctors, hospitals and drug
[00:09:15]
companies get paid for their services.
Now, Oz has previously chimed in
on Medicare policy.
Oz, for instance,
coauthored back in 2020
an opinion column in Forbes arguing for
a universal health coverage system in
[00:09:31]
which every American not covered
by Medicaid would be enrolled
in a private Medicare Advantage plan.
The coverage expansion.
The column said, would be financed
by an affordable 20% payroll tax.
[00:09:47]
So that would be a tax
that the employer pays.
Right.
That's what the payroll tax is presumably.
But sometimes the payroll tax is split
between the employer and the employee.
- It depends on the category.
- Yeah.
So real curious to see if this is
something that he would pursue
should he get confirmed for this role.
[00:10:02]
An archived version
of a 2022 Oz Senate campaign website
also suggested that Oz still strongly
supported Medicare Advantage,
promising he would expand access to
private sector plans expanded by President
Trump and beloved by seniors for their
low cost and high quality that could be
[00:10:21]
available to all Americans who want them.
That's not a factual statement.
That is a quote from Doctor Oz
on his campaign website.
Now, back in 2022, The Lever,
the organization run by David Sirota,
[00:10:37]
a wonderful journalist,
dug into Oz's personal finances and they
found some interesting tidbits there.
Oz and his wife own up to $550,000 worth
of stock in UnitedHealth Group and up to
$50,000 in CVS health, which owns Aetna.
[00:10:52]
Both UnitedHealth and Aetna have reported
big revenues from Medicare Advantage
plans, the privatized Medicare plans
operated by corporate health insurers.
But remember, funded by you,
the American taxpayer?
No. If they're funding, like if they're
going to transfer, let me put it this way.
[00:11:12]
If they say to you guys,
hey, you know what?
You're allowed to get private health
insurance on top of Medicare.
Great. No problem.
Of course, if you want more
than what Medicare is covering
and you want to pay for that, terrific.
Nobody's going to argue with that.
It's a free country, right?
But if they say,
let's take money out of the Medicare
budget and move it into private health
[00:11:30]
insurance plans so that you have to get
the private health insurance and pay more
and oftentimes get denied and denied
because it's not guaranteed anymore.
Well, what the hell are we doing here?
Right.
Well, why Why would that help?
There's just a lot of waste
with the Medicare Advantage system, too.
[00:11:49]
Because, again, since it's privately run,
we're talking about any private company.
Obviously, you want to maximize your
profits because you have a fiduciary
responsibility to your shareholders.
You should not introduce that system into
[00:12:04]
a program that is funded by taxpayers.
Right.
Like, to me, it just sets up a system
in which, you know, private interests
are going to rip off the taxpayers because
they want to maximize their profits.
Yeah.
So look, this is going to be one of many,
many tests for the Trump team,
[00:12:23]
both the Trump administration
and Trump's followers.
Are you going to be even 1% populist
or is this just a, you know,
a highway robbery where you're just going
to funnel more money into your private
interests that are your either your donors
or things you personally invested in?
[00:12:39]
Right.
And and then while pretending
to be for the average man and let it blow
up on the American people if you do that.
I think, I hope there will be hell to pay.
But in terms of eventually when people
figure out you robbed them, right?
Yeah.
[00:12:54]
And by the way, I mean,
Elon is looking to cut spending, right?
First place I would look is,
our Medicare system
and the fact that Medicare isn't allowed
to negotiate drug prices for all drugs.
Why are we allowing pharma
to rip off the American government?
[00:13:16]
Okay.
Like that's literally
what's happening right now.
Yeah.
So I'm going to quadruple down on that.
So what are we talking about
cutting Medicare for?
Are you crazy?
Do you know how much money we could save
if all we did was negotiate drug prices?
And so what happened?
Donald Trump, are you a populist
or are you not a populist?
[00:13:31]
Are you a capitalist
or are you not a capitalist?
Because not negotiating drug prices
is not capitalism.
It's the exact opposite of free markets.
There's no question about that.
It is crony capitalism to the extreme,
and right wing populists hate big Pharma.
They hate Big Pharma. Right.
[00:13:48]
So you're going to go along with Big
pharma and say, no, guys, we should pay
whatever prices big drug companies want.
So there's tons of savings right there
by taking on corporate power.
Are Trump and Elon and and Bobby Kennedy
junior and Doctor Oz. Are they going
[00:14:06]
to do that or are they liars?
And they're just going to privatize things
so that they and all their friends
get paid off,
and they don't actually reduce any costs?
Well, we're going to find out
because we're not in charge.
They are.
But the minute they take action
in either direction, you know,
[00:14:22]
the one show that will be honest with you,
either give them credit
or the overwhelming discredit that they
deserve if they go in the wrong direction,
we're right here
and we're going to hold them accountable.
Whether anyone in mainstream media
or right wing media does,
we're going to be honest about it
and let's see what they do.
[00:14:37]
So far, the beginning does not look good.
Now Playing (Clips)
Episode
Podcast
The Young Turks: November 19, 2024
Hosts: Cenk UygurAna Kasparian
- 15 minutes
- 9 minutes
- 14 minutes
- 18 minutes
- 12 minutes