Apr 23, 2025
Is Trump REALLY Going To RAISE Taxes On The Rich?
Abolish the Electoral College Vice President JD Vance and budget director Russell Vought are among those in President Trump's inner circle advocating for tax hikes on the rich.
- 15 minutes
You're going to have populist tax
cuts on no tax on tips,
no tax on Social Security, no tax,
no tax on overtime to make up that gap.
I hate to say this.
I know you got a bunch
of still Republican, Orthodox,
[00:00:16]
Orthodox folks out here.
You're going to have
to raise taxes on the wealthy.
Some in President Donald Trump's
inner circle are amusing the possibility
of pretty significant tax hikes
on the nation's wealthy in order
[00:00:35]
to not necessarily balance the budget,
but at least raise some revenue for
the federal government in order to justify
another $4.5 trillion in tax cuts.
Now, as we all know, Donald Trump
and the Republican Party
want to extend the 2017 tax cuts
that Trump secured back in his first term.
[00:00:57]
But in order to do that,
they need to justify it.
They need to cut spending.
They need to get rid of waste,
fraud and abuse.
And they also need to find ways to raise
revenue, which is why the topic of raising
taxes on the rich has come up now.
Now, this news was confirmed
by two administration officials
[00:01:13]
who spoke to the Washington Post.
There were three other individuals
who were briefed on the matter.
They confirmed the story
to the Washington Post.
And according to Jeff Stein,
who reported this story for WaPo, there
are some surprising figures in the Trump
administration who are totally on board
[00:01:30]
for raising taxes for the rich.
Those individuals, by the way,
include Vice President JD Vance
and someone I would never expect,
the budget director, Russell Vought.
So they both expressed support
to raise taxes on the rich.
[00:01:47]
Also in support is the guy that you heard
from in the very beginning of this story,
Steve Bannon.
He's been publicly urging Donald Trump
to endorse the plan in order to defang
the Democratic Party and their attacks
on the GOP being the party of the rich.
[00:02:04]
Now, look, make no mistake about it,
so far, the Republican Party
continues to be the party of the rich.
There's been a lot of rhetoric
from Donald Trump's campaign,
and now the Trump administration
about how they're looking out
for the middle class, the working class.
I haven't really seen much policy
to bolster those claims.
[00:02:22]
If they do actually raise taxes
on top earners in the country,
now we're having a conversation.
But is that likely to happen? Hold.
You're about to hear from the opponents
to this policy in just a minute.
But before you do,
here's what Steve Bannon said.
[00:02:39]
He says this meaning
raising taxes on the rich guts,
the AOC Bernie oligarchy tour politically
when it comes to higher taxes on the rich.
It's game, set, match. It's a no brainer.
This would destroy the Democrats.
[00:02:55]
And look, I think he's right about that,
to be quite frank.
I think that Bannon,
despite all of the issues I have with him,
is actually pretty smart.
He's savvy when it comes to political
strategy, and so he wants to destroy
[00:03:10]
the one significant talking point
the Democratic Party
has had against Republicans.
And that's the fact that they've always
looked out for corporate executives
over the best interests
of the American people, over the best
interests of American workers.
Now, Trump claims he wants
to change that, but will he?
[00:03:26]
And again, we haven't really seen
much evidence to bolster that claim yet.
Now, Bannon also got into the nitty gritty
of how the tax bill could work.
So one proposal would allow
the top tax rate to revert to its level
[00:03:41]
before the 2017 tax law.
Oh my God.
I mean, could they even survive that?
So from 37% to 39.6%,
this would raise taxes for those
with more than $626,350 in earnings.
[00:03:58]
People were paying that rate
prior to the 2017 tax bill.
And guess what?
Income inequality
in this country was still growing.
So they're going to be all right.
All right. They're going to be okay.
If the tax rate increase
that is the top tax rate.
[00:04:15]
So they're not going to pay 39.6%
on the entirety of their income.
But you know, the, the top, or a certain
amount of money they make above the
$625,000 will be taxed at that 39.6% rate.
[00:04:33]
So that's one of the proposals.
What else is going on?
Well, there are other things
that they're considering.
So Bannon and some other Trump allies
have also discussed a third idea
to create an even higher top tax bracket
for those earning more than $3 million
[00:04:48]
or $5 million, two of the people said.
One of the other ideas, by the way,
was to create, a bracket that would charge
higher taxes for individuals earning any,
any amount of money
above a million bucks a year.
[00:05:04]
Right.
So they're playing
with these ideas in the end.
It's unlikely to go anywhere, but I think
that it's interesting to hear that there
are people within Trump's orbit that are
pushing for these types of policies.
Now, here's what's also super surprising.
Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent
is allegedly open to a range of ideas,
[00:05:23]
including the possibility
of raising taxes on Americans earning more
than $5 million per year.
Now, let's talk about the anti-tax pro
deregulation group, which honestly makes
up the bulk of the Republican Party.
[00:05:39]
Obviously, those folks still exist
within the Trump administration as well.
And there's a lot of outside individuals,
outside allies of Trump's,
who are in his ear to discourage him
from raising taxes on the wealthy.
Those individuals include Newt Gingrich,
Steve Moore, who Trump actually tapped for
[00:05:58]
the fed board back during his first term.
Larry Kudlow and Sean Hannity, you know,
the typical neo liberal Republicans
and so more who's not who's now
the president of some think tank called
the Committee to Unleash Prosperity,
[00:06:15]
pointed to former President George H.W.
Bush's embrace of higher taxes
as political suicide.
He's like, remember what happened
to George H.W.
Bush when he raised taxes?
He didn't win a second term.
So that's what he's trying
to warn Trump about.
[00:06:30]
But George H.W.
Bush made a pretty bold promise
during his 1988 address.
And if you weren't around back then
or if you can't remember what he said,
here's a little reminder.
And I'm the one who will not raise taxes.
[00:06:48]
My opponent now says he'll raise them
as a last resort or a third resort.
But when a politician talks like that,
you know that's one resort
he'll be checking into.
And I. My opponent.
[00:07:05]
My opponent won't rule out
raising taxes, but I will.
And the Congress will push me
to raise taxes.
And I'll say no.
And they'll push and I'll say no,
and they'll push again.
And I'll say to them, read my lips.
[00:07:22]
- No new taxes.
- Yeah.
He then raised taxes,
and people were really upset about that.
But he coupled those tax hikes
with massive unpopular spending cuts.
And yeah, that did hurt him politically.
[00:07:39]
So the president accepted several tax
increases, most notably an increase
in the top personal tax rate
to 31% from Reagan's 28%.
Democrats accepted spending cuts
twice as large in dollar value.
[00:07:57]
When Americans are experiencing higher
taxes, but they're getting less in return
in terms of,
you know, government programs.
Yeah, they're going to be very upset.
But you know Trump's a little different.
I mean, I think Trump actually can
get away with raising taxes
[00:08:13]
on the highest earners in the country,
raise revenue for the federal government,
and still present himself
as a working class hero
because he's not raising taxes under these
plans that we're talking about.
It's not like he's advocating to raise
taxes on working class people, but I don't
[00:08:30]
think he's going to end up raising taxes
on anyone, to be quite honest with you.
And I think that's going to be the case
because of the influencing figures within
the administration and more importantly,
what's going down over at Capitol Hill,
because we're already hearing
[00:08:45]
a lot of pushback from people
like House speaker Mike Johnson.
Now, can Trump bully him if Trump
actually wants to raise taxes on the rich?
Maybe. Yeah, I think that's possible.
But no, I mean, when you listen
to what Johnson's saying,
he seems like he will be undeterred.
[00:09:03]
He will not sign off
on higher taxes for his donors.
I mean, the richest among us.
So let's hear a little
from his interview recently.
I believe it was on Fox News,
if I'm not mistaken.
Here's what Mike Johnson has to say
about the possibility of Congress
[00:09:18]
passing a tax hike on the rich.
There have been some reports out there
that the Trump administration
is looking at pushing the top tax rate
for those making over $1 million
back up towards 39, 40%.
Is that something that we should
expect from a Republican bill?
[00:09:37]
- I would not expect that.
- We have been working against that idea.
I'm not in favor of raising the tax rates,
because that's our party is the group
that stands against that traditionally.
So there are lots of ideas
thrown out on the table
along this process over the last year.
But I would just say for everybody,
just just wait and see.
[00:09:54]
There's more details coming.
And I think you're going to be
very pleased by what you see.
I don't think we're raising taxes
on anybody.
What we're trying to do is prevent
the largest tax increase in U.S.
History.
Was that tinted lip? Lip balm.
His. His lips were very rosy looking.
Anyway.
[00:10:09]
I'm not surprised at all
that Mike Johnson is not in favor
of raising taxes on the rich.
His campaigns are funded by the rich.
The rich do not want
to see their taxes go up.
And joining him are the who's who
of neoliberal Republicans,
including Senator Dave McCormick
from Pennsylvania, Senator Ted Cruz.
[00:10:28]
And so, again, I.
With the pushback in Capitol Hill,
with the fact that there are close
Trump allies discouraging him from raising
taxes on the rich, I genuinely predict
that it's not going to happen.
But I'm at least having a little bit
of fun with the panic that we're seeing
[00:10:44]
among the opponents to these tax hikes.
So let's talk a little bit about Steve
Moore, a little more about Steve Moore
because he's hilarious man.
So he's totally losing it over the idea
that a Republican administration
[00:10:59]
might raise taxes on the rich.
He says, quote,
this is a potential crisis in the party.
It sounds like Bernie Sanders economics.
In fact, some have especially soured
on Vice President JD Vance because of his,
[00:11:17]
you know, economic populism, which
actually appears to be somewhat sincere.
So Vance's openness to higher taxes,
in some circumstances, has provoked alarm
among some conservatives,
given his strong position to claim
the GOP presidential nomination in 2028.
[00:11:34]
Vance, in 2023, said he opposes
further cuts to the corporate tax rate,
which the president's 2017 tax law
lowered from 35% to 21%.
While in the Senate,
Vance also explored bipartisan measures to
close tax loopholes for large businesses.
[00:11:53]
So I love watching the panic, I really do.
Even though I'm not dumb enough to think,
I'm not naive enough to think
that a Republican administration
is going to push for high taxes
or higher taxes on the richest Americans.
[00:12:09]
Still, though, the idea that there are
diverse like there are diverse thoughts,
diverse
opinions within the administration.
I think that's a good thing. I really do.
And who knows, maybe that very,
very small, that minuscule populist wing
[00:12:27]
of the Trump administration could grow
into something bigger in the future.
Who knows?
Either way, I think that both parties
are realizing that there is real anger in
the country among working people who have
gotten a raw deal for many, many decades,
[00:12:43]
wages stagnant since the 1970s.
Americans are unable to buy homes.
You know, when we talk about
the American dream being dead, every facet
of life has become far too expensive.
And people look at the small group
of people who get to hoard all the wealth,
[00:13:00]
and they're angered by it.
Now, talking about raising taxes
is one thing, and I think the mistake
that the left makes
is we just kind of leave it at that.
We have the debate about how we need
to raise taxes and then we move on.
I think we need to have a better
conversation, a real debate about where
[00:13:18]
those resources end up going as well,
because there is, in my opinion,
a lot of waste in the government.
And I'm not talking about social services
and things like that.
I'm talking about funding wars abroad.
I'm talking about defense contracts
with these private defense contractors
[00:13:37]
who obviously, you know,
I think that they overestimate,
I'll put it that way,
the amount of money it costs
to develop various weapons that the
government contracts with them to obtain.
[00:13:52]
Like, it's just there's just a lot of
grift going on in the federal government.
And when there's grift going on
in the federal government, you
and I are the ones who get screwed over.
It's our tax money.
And by the way, the other thing is,
I think the Medicare system
should negotiate drug prices for all
pharmaceutical drugs, not for a handful
[00:14:09]
for all pharmaceutical drugs.
It is so incredibly unjust
that we are being price gouged
by pharmaceutical companies.
We all know it.
The federal government knows it.
In fact, the federal government
allows it to happen.
So if Trump really wants
to find some cost savings, how about start
[00:14:27]
with the pharmaceutical drug prices
and allow Medicare to negotiate those
prices so they're not being price gouged?
I doubt he's going to do that.
But there are some real ways
to save money.
It's just that, Republican benefactors,
donors, they're not fans of those
[00:14:45]
those strategies so unlikely to happen.
Trump has just confirmed that his
administration will not raise taxes
on millionaires and billionaires.
Obviously, my prediction was right.
I just wish he had like said that before.
I did a whole segment about it.
[00:15:00]
Every time you ring the bell below,
an angel gets his wings.
Totally not true, but it does
keep you updated on our live shows.
Now Playing (Clips)
Episode
Podcast
The Young Turks: April 23, 2025
- 14 minutes
- 15 minutes
- 12 minutes
- 18 minutes
- 11 minutes
- 11 minutes
- 16 minutes
- 9 minutes